Table 2 Dose–effect relationship parameters and mean combination index (CI) values of chlorpyrifos (C), imidacloprid (I), and thiamethoxam (T) singly and in binary and ternary combinations in bumblebee tests after 48 h of exposure. The computer software CompuSyn was used to calculating the Dm, m, r, and CI values. The parameters Dm, m, and r are the antilog of the x-intercept, the slope, and the linear correlation coefficient of the median-effect plot, which indicate the potency (LD50), the shape of the dose–effect curve, and the conformity of the data to the mass-action law, respectively38,39,40. The Dm and m values were used to calculate the CI values (Eq. (4)), and CI < 1, CI > 1, and CI = 1 represent synergism, antagonism, and an additive effect, respectively. LD10, LD50, and LD90 are the doses producing a 10%, 50%, and 90% mortality rate in bumblebees, respectively. Doses are in micrograms of active ingredient per bee.
Pesticide(s) | Dose–effect parameter | CI value at | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dm | m | LD10 | LD50 | LD90 | |
C | 0.76593 | 2.31045 | – | – | – |
I | 0.23393 | 0.846 | – | – | – |
T | 0.43628 | 5.9474 | – | – | – |
C + I | 0.88767 | 4.15344 | 8.2139 | 1.76069 | 0.69604 |
C + T | 0.22549 | 9.38724 | 0.599 | 0.37311 | 0.25261 |
I + T | 0.19715 | 2.2892 | 1.68173 | 0.589 | 0.58701 |
C + I + T | 0.31454 | 2.1166 | 1.33942 | 0.65273 | 0.70644 |