Table 2 Results of MANOVA and post-hoc analyses on the effect of the factors pyrolysis temperature of DOR-based biochar (350 and 500 °C), application dose of DOR-based biochar (2 and 5%), soil contamination level (“low”, “medium” and “high”), soil treatment time (30, 60 and 90 days), inoculation of F. mosseae (AMF) and their interactions on soil enzyme activities (β-glucosidase and dehydrogenase) considering only amended microcosms.

From: Application of dry olive residue-based biochar in combination with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi enhances the microbial status of metal contaminated soils

Factors

β-glucosidasea

Dehydrogenaseb

DOR pyrolysis temperature (P)

Fsignificance (df)c

10.81*** (1)

7.52*** (1)

Post-hoc test

 350 °C

1162.88 a

0.40 b

 500 °C

1200.48 b

0.39 a

Biochar application dose (D)

Fsignificance (df)c

51.80*** (1)

15.86*** (1)

Post-hoc test

 2%

1232.74 b

0.38 a

 5%

1148.28 a

0.41 b

Soil contamination level (S)

Fsignificance (df)f

46.46*** (2)

5044.91*** (2)

Post-hoc test

 Low

1436.14 b

0.45 b

 Medium

1122.88 a

0.46 b

 High

1229.23 a

0.14 a

Soil treatment time (T)

Fsignificance (df)f

936.05*** (2)

22.84*** (2)

Post-hoc test

 30 days

1100.52 a

0.41 b

 60 days

1191.51 b

0.42 b

 90 days

1317.82 c

0.38 a

F. mosseae inoculation (M)

Fsignificance (df)f

0.51 (1)

18.17*** (1)

 Post-hoc test

 No inoculation

1196.07 a

0.44 b

Inoculation

1183.59 a

0.38 a

Significant interactions

P × D*, P × M*, D × M*, S × T***, T × M***, P × D × S***, P × S × T*, P × D × M*, D × S × M***

D × S*, D × T***, D × M*, S × T***, S × M***, M × T*, P × D × T***, D × S × T***, D × S × M***, D × T × M***, S × T × M***, P × D × S × T***, D × S × T × M***

  1. Median values for each variable at each factor level are also shown.
  2. aFor post-hoc tests, the values are expressed as µPNP (g soil dm)−1 (1 h)−1.
  3. bFor post-hoc tests, the values are expressed as μmol INTF (g soil dm)−1 (1 h)−1.
  4. cF-valuesignificance (degrees of freedom).
  5. For MANOVA analyses, F-values in bold denote statistical significance (p ≤ 0.05), significance levels are shown at *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01 and ***p < 0.001; for post-hoc Tukey’s HSD tests, median values followed by different letters are significantly different (p < 0.05).