Table 3 Multi-observer assessment of bone image quality and artifact intensity.

From: Metal artifact reduction in ultra-high-resolution cone-beam CT imaging with a twin robotic X-ray system

Scan protocol

CTDIvol

[mGy]

Rating sum

Bone

FOM Rank

Bone

Rating sum

Artifacts

FOM Rank

Artifacts

MDCT

70 kVp 50 mAs

1.3

7

#20

7

#14

70 kVp 97 mAs

2.7

11

#14

7

#22

80 kVp 122 mAs

5.1

14

#19

9

#23

70 kVp 199 mAs

5.3

12

#25

8

#24

Sn 100 kVp 898 mAs

7.5

21

#8

23

#5

Sn 150 kVp 146 mAs

8.2

24

#5

24

#7

100 kVp 113 mAs

9.8

20

#18

14

#21

80 kVp 241 mAs

10.2

21

#17

11

#25

120 kVp 101 mAs

14.1

28

#11

18

#18

140 kVp 96 mAs

18.9

26

#21

20

#20

100 kVp 227 mAs

19.5

26

#24

15

#27

80 kVp 489 mAs

20.3

18

#32

12

#29

120 kVp 202 mAs

28.1

35

#15

18

#26

140 kVp 192 mAs

37.7

31

#27

20

#28

100 kVp 453 mAs

39.3

28

#30

14

#32

120 kVp 405 mAs

54.0

37

#28

19

#30

140 kVp 383 mAs

75.2

35

#31

21

#31

CBCT

60 kVp 0.6 mAs

2.3

7

#29

7

#19

60 kVp 1.2 mAs

4.5

14

#16

18

#4

80 kVp 0.6 mAs

4.5

21

#1

24

#1

102 kVp 0.6 mAs

9.1

24

#7

28

#2

60 kVp 2.5 mAs

9.5

16

#26

21

#12

80 kVp 1.2 mAs

9.9

28

#3

28

#3

117 kVp 0.6 mAs

13.6

33

#2

31

#6

102 kVp 1.2 mAs

16.3

33

#6

31

#9

80 kVp 2.5 mAs

17.4

32

#9

29

#11

133 kVp 0.6 mAs

21.6

35

#10

37

#8

117 kVp 1.2 mAs

23.6

41

#4

35

#10

102 kVp 2.5 mAs

34.6

35

#22

33

#16

133 kVp 1.2 mAs

36.3

42

#12

40

#13

117 kVp 2.5 mAs

44.1

46

#13

38

#15

133 kVp 2.5 mAs

61.0

46

#23

42

#17

Fleiss kappa (95% confidence interval; p < .001)

0.652 (0.618–0.686)

0.570 (0.535–0.606)

  1. CBCT, cone-beam computed tomography; FOM, figure of merit (sum of ratings2/CTDIvol); MDCT, multidetector computed tomography; Sn, 0.4 mm tin prefiltration.