Table 1 Characteristics of the primary studies included in the meta-analysis.
Id | Author | Year | Countries | Prevalence | Sample size | Mean age | Disease duration | Risk score | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Venter G | 2021 | Australia | 14.7 | 109 | 59.5 | 204 | Moderate | 69 |
2 | Tavassoli S | 2021 | Iran | 8.5 | 129 | 56.33 | 83 | Low | 7 |
3 | Pierini F. S | 2021 | Argentina | 36.5 | 74 | 62.1 | 114 | Low | 13 |
4 | Hu Z | 2021 | China | 54.7 | 340 | 59.4 | 66 | Low | 4 |
5 | Tong J | 2019 | China | 33.6 | 865 | 55.6 | 113 | Low | 68 |
6 | Lindner L | 2020 | Germany | 6 | 5423 | 63 | 168 | Low | 51 |
7 | Hu Z | 2020 | China | 62.1 | 452 | 58 | 67 | Low | 43 |
8 | Yan S | 2019 | China | 4.19 | 788 | 56 | 48 | Low | 72 |
9 | Wafa H | 2018 | Tunisia | 48 | 173 | 54.1 | 98 | Low | 71 |
10 | Tong H | 2018 | China | 35 | 320 | 54.1 | 72 | Low | 67 |
11 | Luque Ramos A | 2019 | Germany | 25.9 | 2535 | 62.5 | Moderate | 52 | |
12 | Fauny M | 2019 | France | 26.7 | 105 | 61.1 | 144 | Low | 30 |
13 | Phuan-udom R | 2018 | Thailand | 5 | 232 | 61.1 | 155 | Moderate | 11 |
14 | Panopoulos S | 2018 | Greece | 21.4 | 182 | 61.6 | 108 | Low | 62 |
15 | Mohd-Tahir N. A | 2017 | Malaysia | 29 | 93 | 61.7 | 66 | Moderate | 59 |
16 | Kweon S. M | 2018 | South Korea | 19.7 | 76 | 64.5 | 37.5 | Low | 47 |
17 | Kim D | 2018 | South Korea | 33.8 | 142,955 | 54.2 | 24.5 | High | 45 |
18 | Heidari B | 2018 | Iran | 30.8 | 39 | 50.6 | 108 | Low | 41 |
19 | Gabdulina G | 2018 | Kazakhstan | 45.1 | 406 | 50.6 | 61.6 | Low | 31 |
20 | Ene C. G | 2018 | Romania | 32.2 | 62 | 49.43 | Low | 29 | |
21 | Choi S. T | 2018 | South Korea | 33.4 | 479 | 61.5 | 53 | Low | 27 |
22 | Rossini M | 2017 | Italian | 35 | 183 | 64 | 108 | Moderate | 65 |
23 | Meng J | 2017 | China | 41.07 | 168 | 54.3 | 146.5 | Low | 20 |
24 | Makhdoom A | 2017 | Pakistan | 40.6 | 229 | 46.4 | Low | 53 | |
25 | Galarza-Delgado D. A | 2017 | Mexico | 19.1 | 225 | 55.7 | 114 | Moderate | 32 |
26 | Singh S | 2016 | India | 5.9 | 51 | 45 | Low | 1 | |
27 | Lee J. H | 2016 | South Korea | 46.8 | 1322 | 63.7 | 145 | Low | 50 |
28 | Kim D | 2016 | South Korea | 5.5 | 5376 | 58.8 | 117.5 | Low | 44 |
29 | Innala L | 2016 | Sweden | 3.7 | 726 | 55.6 | 80.5 | Moderate | 3 |
30 | Garip Y | 2016 | Turkey | 21.2 | 160 | 53.6 | 145 | Low | 33 |
31 | Bautista-Molano W | 2016 | Colombia | 17.3 | 1652 | 58 | 110.5 | Low | 26 |
32 | Piao H. H | 2015 | China | 21.6 | 37 | 64.4 | Moderate | 63 | |
33 | Mohammad A | 2013 | Ireland | 59 | 603 | 57 | 180 | Low | 58 |
34 | Lee J. H | 2014 | South Korea | 59.1 | 545 | 57 | 135 | Low | 49 |
35 | Lee J. H | 2014 | South Korea | 51 | 100 | 61.2 | 78 | Low | 48 |
36 | Hauser B | 2014 | UK | 29.9 | 304 | 63.5 | 115 | Low | 40 |
37 | Gron K. L | 2014 | 34 countries | 17.6 | 9874 | 54.9 | 97 | Moderate | 37 |
38 | Mobini m | 2012 | Iran | 32.3 | 121 | 55.7 | 121 | Low | 57 |
39 | Lee S. G | 2012 | South Korea | 22.1 | 299 | 52.4 | 32 | Low | 16 |
40 | Gonzalez-Lopez L | 2012 | Mexico | 24.1 | 191 | 52 | 132 | Low | 36 |
41 | Ghazi M | 2012 | France | 55.4 | 101 | 56.1 | 179.5 | Low | 34 |
42 | Vis M | 2011 | (Norway, UK, Netherlands) | 35 | 102 | 61 | 204 | Moderate | 70 |
43 | Dao H. H | 2011 | Vietnam | 27.6 | 105 | 56.3 | 21 | Low | 28 |
44 | Kim S. Y | 2010 | USA | 18 | 47,034 | 55 | Low | 46 | |
45 | El Maghraoui A | 2010 | Morocco | 44.2 | 172 | 49.4 | 101 | Low | 18 |
46 | Shankar S | 2008 | India | 22 | 84 | 33.9 | 60 | Low | 66 |
47 | Sarkis K. S | 2009 | Brazil | 25.3 | 83 | 55 | 92.5 | Low | 8 |
48 | Richards J. S | 2009 | USA | 18 | 282 | 65.4 | 156 | Moderate | 64 |
49 | Oelzner P | 2008 | Germany | 47.8 | 551 | 58.4 | 144 | Low | 61 |
50 | Haugen I. K | 2007 | Norway | 19.4 | 194 | 60.9 | Low | 39 | |
51 | Nolla J. M | 2006 | Spain | 13 | 187 | 60.34 | 109 | Low | 60 |
52 | Mikuls T. R | 2005 | USA | 4.7 | 175 | 60 | 109 | Low | 56 |
53 | Heidari B | 2004 | Iran | 25 | 88 | 52.6 | 84 | Low | 42 |
54 | Manrique F | 2003 | Venezuela | 29.4 | 85 | 45.3 | 113 | Low | 54 |
55 | Haugeberg G | 2000 | Norway | 4.2 | 394 | 54.8 | 156 | Moderate | 38 |
56 | Gilboe I. M | 2000 | Norway | 5 | 75 | 45 | 95 | Low | 35 |
57 | Moconkey B | 1962 | 30.3 | 97 | 63.1 | 14.7 | Moderate | 55 |