Table 6 The comparison results of the algorithms with D = 30 on the best value.

F1

1.068523E+02

2.046065E−01

9.027079E+07

2.545320E+10

3.668090E+04

2.327563E+09

2.212518E+02

2.552100E+00

F2

3.034429E+07

4.843791E+01

3.866970E+17

4.302386E+35

3.243556E+08

7.444072E+24

0.000000E+00

7.144800E−06

F3

2.580146E+03

1.622417E+03

1.989163E+04

6.270746E+04

4.981456E+04

1.023267E+04

1.356627E−03

3.381400E−06

F4

4.362691E−01

4.000278E+00

1.012565E+02

3.075531E+03

1.140058E+00

4.984801E+02

5.688817E−03

2.648200E−03

F5

3.581881E+01

4.278316E+01

6.074284E+01

3.483356E+02

7.273690E+01

2.208777E+02

8.954596E+01

3.382900E+01

F6

1.296731E−01

7.662107E−04

3.492141E+00

6.483407E+01

3.378435E−03

2.068939E+01

1.156592E−02

3.784700E−03

F7

8.010618E+01

9.042612E+01

1.638883E+02

8.607841E+02

7.930792E+01

3.158510E+02

1.133163E+02

5.795600E+01

F8

4.576810E+01

4.377812E+01

8.695433E+01

3.197685E+02

7.369765E+01

1.866902E+02

8.357645E+01

2.686400E+01

F9

3.353991E+01

4.456849E+01

1.934407E+02

8.462429E+03

2.741974E+02

1.793276E+03

2.451158E+02

2.490100E+01

F10

1.236777E+03

1.087651E+03

2.579004E+03

6.482077E+03

1.692920E+03

6.208016E+03

1.777147E+03

1.316400E+03

F11

2.196301E+01

1.702465E+01

2.052165E+02

3.259494E+03

1.602049E+02

1.811461E+02

2.092876E+01

1.633100E+01

F12

8.593028E+04

1.016238E+05

2.527995E+06

9.455021E+08

3.712921E+05

3.290853E+07

3.400053E+03

4.489000E+04

F13

2.157118E+02

1.104996E+02

5.972810E+04

2.433333E+08

2.612297E+04

1.109344E+05

8.691712E+02

2.464800E+02

F14

8.903657E+02

3.633828E+02

1.016913E+04

1.280052E+05

1.025964E+05

1.030058E+04

1.607166E+03

1.441700E+03

F15

6.008367E+01

4.002869E+01

3.699453E+03

2.593205E+07

4.898971E+03

2.477443E+03

2.816662E+02

2.736200E+02

F16

3.267963E+02

4.331046E+02

4.928217E+02

2.018867E+03

5.285891E+02

1.056037E+03

6.953776E+02

2.480000E+02

F17

4.981539E+01

6.811743E+01

9.120146E+01

8.697274E+02

1.681502E+02

1.278035E+02

1.976489E+02

3.839900E+01

F18

7.365750E+03

1.806577E+04

6.873488E+04

1.712025E+06

8.417784E+04

7.097923E+04

1.182169E+04

1.315000E+04

F19

2.007914E+01

1.495560E+01

8.764441E+03

7.474144E+07

1.433116E+03

8.792379E+03

4.596323E+01

6.174900E+02

F20

1.652455E+02

4.352280E+01

1.932236E+02

5.804556E+02

1.950264E+02

9.454303E+01

1.960127E+02

7.586100E+01

F21

2.431781E+02

2.530248E+02

2.725541E+02

5.161222E+02

2.703084E+02

3.943160E+02

2.723433E+02

2.286200E+02

F22

1.000269E+02

1.000010E+02

1.623281E+02

3.500901E+03

1.012834E+02

6.386560E+02

1.000343E+02

1.000000E+02

F23

3.911640E+02

3.920824E+02

4.311308E+02

7.595799E+02

4.131467E+02

5.676154E+02

4.082974E+02

3.819800E+02

F24

4.613792E+02

4.640112E+02

5.274326E+02

8.631629E+02

5.889263E+02

6.615161E+02

5.684989E+02

4.591900E+02

F25

3.838279E+02

3.834947E+02

4.032079E+02

1.166790E+03

3.844018E+02

5.490780E+02

3.839042E+02

3.834000E+02

F26

3.000524E+02

3.000018E+02

6.298026E+02

5.952464E+03

2.058838E+02

1.551585E+03

2.002229E+02

2.000200E+02

F27

4.946378E+02

5.067482E+02

5.229982E+02

7.443608E+02

5.087726E+02

5.471227E+02

5.237302E+02

5.011100E+02

F28

3.999236E+02

3.909026E+02

4.634589E+02

1.777792E+03

3.989388E+02

6.168254E+02

3.000053E+02

3.000000E++02

F29

3.918434E+02

3.793398E+02

5.220060E+02

2.232862E+03

5.702581E+02

7.995088E+02

5.685322E+02

4.598300E+02

F30

3.601612E+03

3.013336E+03

5.759281E+04

2.182670E+07

6.112615E+03

2.678563E+05

3.252771E+03

3.374800E+03

+\−\≈

22\8\0

20\10\0

30\0\0

30\0\0

29\1\0

30\0\0

25\5\0