Table 7 The comparison results of the algorithms with Dā=ā30 on the worst value.
From: A novel intelligent global harmony search algorithm based on improved search stability strategy
| Ā | HS | IHS | GHS | SGHS | NGHS | IGHS | IMGHS | NIGHS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
F1 | 2.072044E+04 | 1.744687E+04 | 4.643647E+08 | 5.800895E+10 | 6.277895E+05 | 8.835646E+09 | 2.096193E+04 | 2.081100E+04 |
F2 | 6.491563E+13 | 1.387694E+12 | 1.171382E+26 | 8.175159E+40 | 5.221311E+22 | 9.426971E+31 | 8.500180Eā03 | 1.288300Eā04 |
F3 | 1.097459E+04 | 1.583807E+04 | 4.796008E+04 | 1.313875E+05 | 2.322391E+05 | 3.936810E+04 | 9.086220E+03 | 1.064900Eā05 |
F4 | 1.845267E+02 | 1.472882E+02 | 2.499712E+02 | 1.246151E+04 | 1.984702E+02 | 1.426510E+03 | 6.411747E+01 | 1.092400E+02 |
F5 | 1.213845E+02 | 1.074553E+02 | 1.502890E+02 | 4.622845E+02 | 2.201519E+02 | 2.973286E+02 | 2.318238E+02 | 1.333200E+02 |
F6 | 6.028584Eā01 | 2.172649Eā01 | 8.496970E+00 | 9.372626E+01 | 2.989244Eā01 | 4.675106E+01 | 6.297507Eā01 | 6.227700Eā01 |
F7 | 1.752455E+02 | 1.824142E+02 | 2.791493E+02 | 1.671383E+03 | 2.532590E+02 | 4.331519E+02 | 3.223059E+02 | 1.759500E+02 |
F8 | 1.223795E+02 | 1.164097E+02 | 1.600059E+02 | 4.231056E+02 | 2.100051E+02 | 2.645997E+02 | 2.198843E+02 | 9.651100E+01 |
F9 | 1.587352E+03 | 2.042237E+03 | 3.370909E+03 | 1.650976E+04 | 8.091164E+03 | 6.002449E+03 | 7.129785E+03 | 1.024000E+03 |
F10 | 3.143604E+03 | 3.418866E+03 | 4.915291E+03 | 7.838171E+03 | 4.391321E+03 | 7.544039E+03 | 4.365324E+03 | 7.664400E+03 |
F11 | 5.820558E+02 | 1.172088E+02 | 1.033293E+03 | 8.029528E+03 | 1.913853E+04 | 1.244433E+03 | 1.823572E+02 | 1.659000E+02 |
F12 | 8.200471E+06 | 4.805210E+06 | 2.535490E+07 | 7.619030E+09 | 1.381693E+07 | 2.580293E+08 | 1.793248E+05 | 1.735000E+06 |
F13 | 6.110421E+04 | 6.116948E+04 | 5.716129E+06 | 3.828686E+09 | 5.436535E+05 | 3.431695E+06 | 6.214898E+04 | 6.109100E+04 |
F14 | 3.064803E+05 | 6.889374E+04 | 1.215528E+06 | 9.451569E+05 | 8.315814E+06 | 1.079273E+06 | 6.200836E+04 | 5.158200E+04 |
F15 | 4.135316E+04 | 3.795285E+04 | 8.669585E+04 | 4.589281E+08 | 2.302278E+05 | 2.271913E+06 | 3.393528E+04 | 8.366400E+03 |
F16 | 1.435014E+03 | 1.435238E+03 | 1.560175E+03 | 3.196043E+03 | 1.990081E+03 | 2.250118E+03 | 2.185376E+03 | 1.240500E+03 |
F17 | 7.576402E+02 | 7.571216E+02 | 9.397974E+02 | 1.670400E+03 | 1.101852E+03 | 6.877205E+02 | 1.412618E+03 | 6.540300E+02 |
F18 | 9.011841E+05 | 1.277854E+06 | 6.149307E+06 | 1.597349E+07 | 1.902476E+07 | 5.001350E+06 | 4.178598E+05 | 4.082400E+05 |
F19 | 5.135418E+04 | 4.826647E+04 | 1.659111E+05 | 5.181274E+08 | 1.495130E+05 | 1.215384E+06 | 5.292185E+04 | 5.439200E+04 |
F20 | 8.560076E+02 | 7.366954E+02 | 8.170349E+02 | 9.586575E+02 | 1.220214E+03 | 6.728616E+02 | 1.223491E+03 | 5.353900E+02 |
F21 | 3.681478E+02 | 3.525013E+02 | 3.868032E+02 | 6.211403E+02 | 4.084442E+02 | 4.787967E+02 | 4.814684E+02 | 2.930600E+02 |
F22 | 3.818090E+03 | 3.428020E+03 | 5.056001E+03 | 6.616301E+03 | 4.901014E+03 | 7.340415E+03 | 5.486943E+03 | 1.034000E+02 |
F23 | 4.858749E+02 | 4.940197E+02 | 5.406275E+02 | 1.031957E+03 | 6.090156E+02 | 6.953638E+02 | 6.277485E+02 | 4.412300E+02 |
F24 | 5.831273E+02 | 6.044994E+02 | 6.634224E+02 | 1.089566E+03 | 9.512382E+02 | 7.458484E+02 | 1.080535E+03 | 5.429400E+02 |
F25 | 4.521908E+02 | 4.270659E+02 | 6.406562E+02 | 5.158935E+03 | 4.706405E+02 | 8.113083E+02 | 4.497501E+02 | 4.241500E+02 |
F26 | 2.552411E+03 | 2.805988E+03 | 3.191595E+03 | 7.671484E+03 | 4.702895E+03 | 4.553354E+03 | 4.560004E+03 | 2.125900E+03 |
F27 | 5.661699E+02 | 5.602909E+02 | 5.723595E+02 | 1.237746E+03 | 6.962743E+02 | 6.835318E+02 | 6.346156E+02 | 5.397700E+02 |
F28 | 5.322946E+02 | 4.724356E+02 | 6.685127E+02 | 4.208768E+03 | 5.056967E+02 | 1.164292E+03 | 4.666402E+02 | 4.832900E+02 |
F29 | 1.156735E+03 | 1.285325E+03 | 1.354054E+03 | 3.108322E+03 | 1.496460E+03 | 1.948742E+03 | 1.620953E+03 | 9.737000E+02 |
F30 | 2.362344E+04 | 7.782387E+04 | 3.191253E+06 | 4.248251E+08 | 1.194065E+06 | 3.074036E+07 | 2.195591E+04 | 2.154600E+04 |
+\ā\ā | 24\6\0 | 23\7\0 | 29\1\0 | 30\0\0 | 28\2\0 | 29\1\0 | 26\4\0 | Ā |