Table 4 Comparing the activity of biochar@ZnO–Ce with other nanoparticles in eliminating azo dyes.

From: Enhanced photocatalytic performance of milkvetch-derived biochar via ZnO–Ce nanoparticle decoration for reactive blue 19 dye removal

Catalyst

Dye

Removal yield (%)

Reaction time

Ref.

CS-ZnS-NPs

Acid black 234

92.6

100 min

48

CS-ZnS-NPs

Acid brown

98

165 min

48

SiO2 NPs

Methylene blue

98

90 min

49

SiO2 NPs

Methyl orange

95

90 min

49

Biochar/Ag NPs

Methylene blue

96.09

140 min

53

ZnO/Al NPs

Rhodamine B

93.8

120 min

54

ZnO/Al NPs

Methylene blue

94.5

120 min

54

TiO2-GO NPs

Methylene blue

84

240 min

55

ZnAl2O4NPs

Congo red

98.3

40 min

56

CuFe2O4NPs

Methylene blue

93

100 min

57

ZnO@biochar

Methylene blue

95.19

20 min

58

Biochar@ZnO–Ce

Reactive blue 19

90.08

40 min

This study