Table 1 Results of ABBA-BABA tests of ancient gene flow between populations of Nearctic American Toads (Bufo [= Anaxyrus] americanus; AT), Houston toads (B. houstonensis; HT), Woodhouse’s Toads (B. woodhousii; WT), and Middle American Gulf Coast Toads (B. nebulifer; GT).

From: Using genome-wide data to ascertain taxonomic status and assess population genetic structure for Houston toads (Bufo [= Anaxyrus] houstonensis)

D

JK-D

V(JK-D)

Z

p value

nABBA

nBABA

nBlocks

H1

H2

H3

H4

0.004

0.004

4.1E−05

0.68

0.49

15,055

14,924

1060

AT

HT

GT

CT

0.08

0.08

2.9E−05

14.5

 < 0.001

56,864

48,555

1150

AT

HT

WT

CT

 − 0.83

 − 0.83

6E−06

 − 355.1

 < 0.001

15,055

166,312

1075

AT

GT

HT

CT

 − 0.75

 − 0.75

1.5E−05

 − 189.6

 < 0.001

13,037

89,282

1054

AT

GT

WT

CT

 − 0.31

 − 0.31

3.1E−05

 − 55.9

 < 0.001

56,864

108,079

1155

AT

WT

HT

CT

0.008

0.008

5.5E−05

1.01

0.31

13,037

12,843

1042

AT

WT

GT

CT

 − 0.84

 − 0.84

6.0E−06

 − 338.6

 < 0.001

14,924

166,312

1076

HT

GT

AT

CT

 − 0.74

 − 0.74

9.0E−06

 − 240.6

 < 0.001

25,649

169,765

1091

HT

GT

WT

CT

 − 0.38

 − 0.38

2.5E−05

 − 76.2

 < 0.001

48,555

108,079

1155

HT

WT

AT

CT

 − 0.004

 − 0.004

2.5E−05

 − 0.75

0.45

25,649

25,844

1071

HT

WT

GT

CT

0.75

0.75

1.6E−05

184.5

 < 0.001

89,282

12,843

1056

GT

WT

AT

CT

0.73

0.73

1.0E−05

235.8

 < 0.001

169,765

25,844

1091

GT

WT

HT

CT

  1. We aligned sequences to a common toad (Bufo bufo) reference genome and assumed allele states in this reference sequence were ancestral states. We used 292,117 sites and corroborated ancient gene flow between Nearctic species (i.e., B. americanus, B. houstonensis, and B. woodhousii) but no support for gene flow between Nearctic and Middle American (i.e., B. nebulifer) species. D: D statistic [i.e., (nABBA-nBABA)/(nABBA + nBABA)]; JK-D: Jackknife estimate of D statistic, V (JK-D): Standard deviation of Jackknife estimate; Z: Z-score.
  2. Significant values are in bold.