Table 1 Comparison of the phytoremediation capabilities for Cu and Pb of various plants used for the phytoremediation of different mining waste sites.

From: Lead and copper removal from sterile dumps by phytoremediation with Robinia pseudoacacia

Plant

Medium of application

Metal concentration (mg kg−1)

Phytoremediation indexes

Refs.

Rhizosphere

Roots

Shoots

BCF

TF

Solanum viarum

Copper mining tailing

229 (Cu)

33 (Pb)

366 (Cu)

42 (Pb)

1 (Cu)

16.4 (Pb)

1.3 (Cu)

1 (Pb)

20

Robinia pseudoacacia (black locust)

Sludge sediment of copper mine

148.78 (Cu)

4.99 (Pb)

37.96* (Cu)

2.09* (Pb)

0.359 (Cu)

0.321 (Pb)

1.571 (Cu)

1.293 (Pb)

23

Pinus elliottii Engelmann

39.53 (Cu)

0.99 (Pb)

19.87* (Cu)

3.99* (Pb)

0.070 (Cu)

0.093 (Pb)

2.086 (Cu)

16.75 (Pb)

Populus tomentosa Carr

86.12 (Cu)

1.88 (Pb)

20.35* (Cu)

4.25* (Pb)

0.145 (Cu)

0.143 (Pb)

0.510 (Cu)

3.608 (Pb)

Helichrysum microphyllum subsp. tyrrhenicum

Mine waste (sterile material)

5030 (Pb)

680 (Pb)

1020 (Pb)

0.14 (Pb)

1.50 (Pb)

38

Robinia pseudoacacia (black locust)

Sterile material

27.9 (Cu)

1543.7 (Pb)

154 (Cu)

904 (Pb)

189 (Cu)

140.96 (Pb)

6.3 (Cu)

0.14 (Pb)

0.99 (Pb)

1.3 (Cu)

This study

  1. *Value recorded in leaves.