Table 1 Summary of the PTC methods focused on weighting factor challenges.

From: Optimal weighting factor design based on entropy technique in finite control set model predictive torque control for electric drive applications

PTC Methods

Limitations

Weighting factor removal by reference transformation33,34

Higher computational burden as compared with conventional PTC and difficult to incorporate multiple control objectives35

Weighting factor tuning based on coefficient of variation36

Optimized weights are uncertain in this method and complex calculations are required to implement on hardware

Weighting factor tuning based on TOPSIS and NSGA-II methods37

TOPSIS and NSGA-II algorithms require complex calculations leading to computational challenges12

Weighting factor removal by Ranking method38

Ranking based techniques become unfeasible as number of control objectives increases39

Tuning of weighting factor based on simple additive technique40

Although technique is simple but not suitable for multiple control objectives11

Weighting factor tuning based on current ripples41

Highly dependent on parameter estimation8,42

Tuning of weighting factor based on error of control objectives43

This method becomes challenging and complex when number of control objectives increases44

Weighting factor tuning using Genetic Algorithm (GA)45, Simulated Annealing (SA)42 or Gravitational Search Algorithm (GSA)43, Artificial Neural Network46, Ant colony based optimization47

These algorithms are very complex and pose computational challenges48

Weighting factor tuning based on algebraic/numerical techniques49

Design complexity increases as slection of weighting factor increases50

Weighting factor selection based on homogeneous cost functions51,52,53

This technique is relatively efficient but unable to include multiple control objectives54

Direct vector selection based techniques to remove weighting factors from cost function55,56

Direct vector selection techniques provid lower computational burden and lower complexity , however cannot incorporate multiple control objecitve57

Weighting factor elimination by using cascaded structure of FCS-MPC58,59

The cascaded structure highly depended on proper selection of dealing cascaded structure60