Table 1 Comparison of breeding techniques and media additives.

From: Optimal conditions of algal breeding using neutral beam and applying it to breed Euglena gracilis strains with improved lipid accumulation

Technique

Method

Advantage

Disadvantage

Random mutagenesis

Chemical mutagen

Inclusion of unknown metabolic pathways as modification targets

No restriction on outdoor culture

Stable maintenance of strains

Need for establishing effective mutation introduction methods

Need for establishing mutant screening methods

Accompanying irrelevant mutations

UV

Gamma ray/X-ray

Heavy ion beam

Neutron (this study)

Genome editing

ZFN

Planned phenotype improvement

Stable maintenance of strains

Need for a deep understanding of metabolic pathways

Need for genome sequencing

Need for establishing genome editing methods

(Legal restrictions on outdoor culture)

TALEN

CRISPR-Cas9

Genetic engineering

Gene overexpression

Planned phenotype improvement

Need for a deep understanding of metabolic pathways

Need for establishing genetic modification methods

Instability of strains

Legal restrictions on outdoor culture

Media additive

Activator chemicals

Inclusion of unknown metabolic pathways as drug targets

No hassle of maintaining strains

Need for establishing chemical screening methods

Need for access to chemical libraries

Need for running costs in the production

Inhibitor chemicals

  1. The advantages and disadvantages of breeding methods, random mutagenesis, genome editing, and genetic engineering, and usage of media additives are summarized.