Table 4 Comparison between the performance of the modified BC adsorbent in the present work and some of the BC modified with metals used for PO43− removal from water from literature.

From: Adsorptive removal of phosphate from water with biochar from acacia tree modified with iron and magnesium oxides

Metal

BC loading (g/L)

PO43− conc.

Main findings

References

Fe3+

2

20 mg/L

Max qe: 0.963 mg/g

Equilibrium time: 24 h

63

Fe2+ and Fe3+

6.25

2.4 mg/L

Max qe: 1.24 mg/g

64

Fe2+ and Fe3+

10

150 mg/L

Max qe: 28 mg/g

Equilibrium time: 5 h

65

Mg and Al

2

50 mg/L

Max qe: 74.47 mg/g

Equilibrium time: 5 h

24

Fe/Zn/Cu

2

50

Max qe: 45 mg/g

Equilibrium time: 4 h

67

Mg/Al

2.5

50

Max qe: 81.8 mg/g

Equilibrium time: 40 min

69

La

2

400

Max qe: 46.4 mg/g

Equilibrium time: 10 h

68

Ce/Fe3O4

1

75 mg/L

Max qe: 18.7 mg/g

Equilibrium time: 3 h

16

Fe3O4/MgO

2

500

Max qe: 98.5 mg/g

Equilibrium time: 4 h

Present work