Table 4 Panel unit root tests.

From: Enhancing environmental quality and economic growth through potential effects of energy efficiency and renewable energy in Asian economies

Variable

CADF

CIPS

Level

First difference

Level

First difference

GDP

− 1.665

− 1.343

− 1.888

− 2.406b

L

− 1.729

− 2.141

− 1.291

− 3.029a

K

− 1.774

− 2.362b

− 1.629

3.316a

CO2

− 1.974

− 2.311b

− 1.742

− 3.122a

EE

− 2.209c

− 2.231c

− 1.859

− 3.083a

RE

− 1.747

− 2.214c

− 1.477

3.058a

  1. a, b, cIndicate significance at 1%, 5%, and 10% level respectively.