Table 5 Panel cointegration tests for 2 models.

From: Enhancing environmental quality and economic growth through potential effects of energy efficiency and renewable energy in Asian economies

Pedroni residual cointegration test

\(\:{GDP}_{t}=F\left({L}_{t,i},\:{K}_{t,i},\:{CO}_{2t,i},\:{EE}_{t,i},\:{RE}_{t,i},{\mu\:}_{t,i}\:\right)\)

\(\:{CO}_{2t}=\left({L}_{t,i},\:{K}_{t,i},\:{GDP}_{t,i},\:{EE}_{t,i},\:{RE}_{t,i}\right)\)

 

Statistic

Prob.

Statistic

Prob.

Alternative hypothesis: common AR coefs. (within-dimension)

 Panel v-statistic

10.25009a

0.0000

0.019136

0.4924

 Panel rho-statistic

2.451390

0.9929

1.701239

0.9556

 Panel PP-statistic

− 0.809644

0.2091

− 2.449045a

0.0072

 Panel ADF-statistic

− 1.936671b

0.0264

− 2.063321b

0.0195

Weighted

 Panel v-statistic

3.325062a

0.0004

− 0.912124

0.8191

 Panel rho-statistic

2.464558

0.9931

1.847004

0.9676

 Panel PP-statistic

− 0.751423

0.2262

− 3.398269a

0.0003

 Panel ADF-statistic

− 1.969237b

0.0245

− 3.803870a

0.0001

Alternative hypothesis: individual AR coefs. (between-dimension)

 Group rho-statistic

3.433316

0.9997

2.835025

0.9977

 Group PP-statistic

− 2.984838a

0.0014

− 5.935990a

0.0000

 Group ADF-statistic

− 1.244367

0.1067

− 4.138066a

0.0000

 Kao cointegration test

− 2.160800a

0.0154

− 3.557469a

0.0002

 Westerlund test variance ratio

− 1.3810c

0.0836

− 1.4744c

0.0702

  1. a, b, cIndicate significance at 1%, 5%, and 10% level respectively.