Table 5 Experimental results on randomly generated instances.
\(SN\) | \(n\) | Train type | \({D}_{k\phi }\) | \({A}_{kd}\) | \(\delta\) | \(\#{m}_{1}\) | Travel time | profit | \(T(s)\) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 29 | T1 | 2:05 | 23:24 | 24 | 27 | 21 h 19 m | 1382 | 0.34 |
T2 | 4:15 | 26:54 | 28 | 22 h 39 m | 1416 | ||||
T3 | 5:45 | 23:14 | 20 | 17 h 29 m | 1096 | ||||
T4 | 6:25 | 25:38 | 23 | 19 h 13 m | 1093 | ||||
T5 | 7:10 | 27:08 | 25 | 19 h 58 m | 1055 | ||||
2 | 35 | T1 | 3:00 | 32:04 | 30 | 31 | 29 h 4 m | 1436 | 0.57 |
T2 | 3:50 | 28:32 | 30 | 24 h 42 m | 1373 | ||||
T3 | 4:20 | 30:55 | 33 | 26 h 35 m | 1595 | ||||
T4 | 5:05 | 33:53 | 34 | 28 h 48 m | 1654 | ||||
T5 | 6:45 | 29:10 | 27 | 22 h 25 m | 1441 | ||||
3 | 55 | T1 | 6:00 | 56:14 | 51 | 48 | 50 h 14 m | 2422 | 0.71 |
T2 | 6:50 | 56:25 | 48 | 49 h 35 m | 2626 | ||||
T3 | 7:35 | 54:40 | 51 | 47 h 5 m | 2534 | ||||
T4 | 8:10 | 56:31 | 49 | 48 h 21 m | 2489 | ||||
T5 | 8:45 | 58:33 | 48 | 49 h 48 m | 2433 | ||||
T6 | 9:30 | 59:30 | 49 | 50 h | 2285 | ||||
T7 | 8:30 | 60:20 | 52 | 51 h 50 m | 2685 | ||||
4 | 65 | T1 | 3:15 | 57:33 | 55 | 59 | 54h18m | 2718 | 0.77 |
T2 | 4:00 | 54:51 | 53 | 50 h 51 m | 2889 | ||||
T3 | 4:40 | 59:40 | 57 | 55 h | 2979 | ||||
T4 | 5:10 | 55:34 | 52 | 50 h 24 m | 2573 | ||||
T5 | 6:00 | 60:51 | 59 | 54 h 51 m | 2903 | ||||
T6 | 6:45 | 59:37 | 54 | 52 h 52 m | 2682 | ||||
5 | 75 | T1 | 4:00 | 60:17 | 60 | 60 | 56 h 17 m | 3338 | 1.32 |
T2 | 4:50 | 62:08 | 62 | 57 h 18 m | 2423 | ||||
T3 | 5:30 | 60:24 | 64 | 56 h 54 m | 3272 | ||||
T4 | 6:10 | 66:01 | 64 | 59 h 51 m | 3162 | ||||
T5 | 7:00 | 64:32 | 65 | 57 h 32 m | 3067 | ||||
T6 | 7:40 | 67:24 | 65 | 59 h 44 m | 3234 | ||||
T7 | 8:15 | 65:18 | 66 | 57 h 3 m | 3227 | ||||
6 | 80 | T1 | 6:00 | 58:56 | 61 | 62 | 52 h 56 m | 3318 | 1.30 |
T2 | 6:45 | 67:41 | 67 | 60 h 56 m | 3359 | ||||
T3 | 7:40 | 65:50 | 64 | 58 h 10 m | 3281 | ||||
T4 | 8:30 | 69:20 | 68 | 60 h 50 m | 3586 | ||||
T5 | 9:15 | 65:18 | 70 | 56 h 13 m | 3007 | ||||
T6 | 10:00 | 70:25 | 66 | 60 h 25 m | 3267 | ||||
T7 | 10:45 | 71:21 | 66 | 60 h 36 m | 3424 | ||||
7 | 85 | T1 | 5:00 | 66:01 | 65 | 79 | 61 h 1 m | 3908 | 1.55 |
T2 | 5:40 | 69:27 | 77 | 63 h 47 m | 4013 | ||||
T3 | 6:15 | 71:06 | 77 | 64 h 51 m | 3924 | ||||
T4 | 7:00 | 71:17 | 74 | 64 h 17 m | 3975 | ||||
T5 | 7:45 | 70:43 | 75 | 62 h 58 m | 3790 | ||||
T6 | 8:30 | 73:10 | 74 | 64 h 40 m | 3720 | ||||
T7 | 9:10 | 72:29 | 78 | 63 h 19 m | 4054 | ||||
T8 | 10:00 | 72:32 | 74 | 62 h 32 m | 3948 | ||||
8 | 90 | T1 | 2:30 | 63:56 | 65 | 78 | 61 h 26 m | 3720 | 1.88 |
T2 | 3:10 | 65:40 | 76 | 62 h 30 m | 4115 | ||||
T3 | 4:00 | 68:56 | 74 | 64 h 56 m | 3989 | ||||
T4 | 4:50 | 69:23 | 73 | 64 h 33 m | 3979 | ||||
T5 | 5:20 | 68:09 | 73 | 62 h 49 m | 3865 | ||||
T6 | 6:00 | 70:06 | 75 | 64 h 6 m | 3951 | ||||
T7 | 7:00 | 66:07 | 77 | 59 h 7 m | 3941 | ||||
T8 | 7:45 | 70:45 | 75 | 63 h | 3652 | ||||
9 | 95 | T1 | 2:00 | 64:27 | 68 | 76 | 62 h 27 m | 3889 | 2.31 |
T2 | 2:40 | 70:32 | 80 | 67 h 52 m | 3908 | ||||
T3 | 3:20 | 69:56 | 76 | 66 h 36 m | 4009 | ||||
T4 | 4:00 | 70:26 | 79 | 66 h 26 m | 4074 | ||||
T5 | 4:50 | 70:53 | 79 | 66 h 3 m | 4133 | ||||
T6 | 5:30 | 73:23 | 81 | 67 h 53 m | 4035 | ||||
T7 | 6:15 | 73:08 | 77 | 66 h 53 m | 3946 | ||||
T8 | 7:00 | 74:30 | 75 | 67 h 30 m | 4124 | ||||
T9 | 7:35 | 74:54 | 74 | 67 h 19 m | 3892 | ||||
T10 | 8:30 | 76:22 | 83 | 67 h 52 m | 4244 | ||||
10 | 100 | T1 | 3:30 | 72:02 | 72 | 82 | 69 h 2 m | 4268 | 2.08 |
T2 | 4:15 | 74:18 | 83 | 70 h 3 m | 4261 | ||||
T3 | 5:00 | 76:12 | 84 | 71 h 12 m | 4384 | ||||
T4 | 5:45 | 77:32 | 84 | 71 h 47 m | 4172 | ||||
T5 | 6:30 | 77:25 | 82 | 70 h 55 m | 4343 | ||||
T6 | 7:10 | 79:10 | 80 | 72 h | 4078 | ||||
T7 | 7:50 | 76:33 | 77 | 68 h 43 m | 3906 | ||||
T8 | 8:20 | 79:03 | 85 | 70 h 43 m | 4599 | ||||
T9 | 8:55 | 80:34 | 83 | 71 h 39 m | 4151 | ||||
T10 | 9:30 | 81:09 | 83 | 71 h 39 m | 4170 |