Table 2 The results of UM functions.

From: A dual-adaptive stochastic reinforcement chimp optimization algorithm for fire detection and multidimensional problem solving

Algorithm

F1

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

F7

CHOA

Ave

7.89E−08

7.44E−19

1.90E−07

1.55E−03

48.441

3.50E−04

3.89E−03

Std

7.55E−08

6.53E−23

1.89E−07

1.96E−03

39.331

3.50E−04

3.89E−03

 

p-value

0.00033

0.0055

0.0051

0.0073

0.0068

0.0025

0.0030

ULCHOA

Ave

1.44E−12

0.00331

1.02E−07

1.35E−04

51.455

8.32E−03

1.53E−03

Std

7.53E−09

0.00023

1.44E−07

1.75E−04

33.785

5.33E−03

1.11E−03

 

p-value

0.0055

0.0044

0.0025

0.0039

0.0056

0.0051

0.0082

ICHOA

Ave

6.96E−12

2.11E−07

1.42E−08

1.22E−09

48.335

1.32E−02

3.22E−03

Std

6.44E−08

3.33E−08

0.0017E−07

1.12E−06

33.045

5.14E−03

2.02E−03

 

p-value

0.0033

0.0035

0.0014

0.0013

0.0055

0.0072

0.0083

NCHOA

Ave

2.01E−27

2.11E−08

3.02E−08

1.21E−08

47.236

1.33E−12

1.07E−03

Std

1.21E−55

8.42E−07

1.25E−06

1.11E−07

35.443

2.55E−06

2.51E−03

 

p-value

0.0015

0.0044

0.0025

0.0039

0.0073

0.0051

0.0082

DLFCHOA

Ave

3.11E−40

7.11E−22

8.11E−09

5.33E−08

63.222

7.25E−06

1.49E−03

Std

6.02E−40

6.35E−23

1.59E−08

1.22E−08

52.136

4.24E−06

6.60E−04

 

p-value

0.0033

0.0044

0.0025

0.0039

0.0056

0.0051

0.0082

ECHOA

Ave

6.44E−07

5.41E−21

8.09E−08

1.15E−08

76.350

2.33E−04

3.11E−03

Std

4.11E−07

6.44E−23

1.11E−06

1.11E−06

42.753

1.55E−05

1.55E−03

 

p-value

0.0055

0.0047

0.0032

0.0015

0.0002

0.0017

0.00001

TASR-CHOA

Ave

1.14E−33

1.87E−22

3.88E−11

1.43E−09

45.033

1.33E−10

1.00E−03

Std

0.0000

1.54E−35

2.34E−11

1.01E−09

2.441

1.25E−07

1.05E−04

 

p-value

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

ARBGA

Ave

3.85E−14

2.42E−16

0.0912

1.44E−08

51.334

4.25E−03

1.05E−03

Std

4.33 E−14

1.33E−16

0.1452

1.21E−09

21.551

5.33E−03

2.33E−03

 

p-value

0.0055

0.0055

0.0051

0.0073

0.0057

0.0025

0.0030

ARWOA

Ave

10.076E−07

0.0336

3.88E−07

1.33E−06

73.352

1.11E−13

7.29E−03

Std

7.00E−07

0.0022

1.44E−07

1.25E−06

33. 624

2.44E−09

1.04E−03

 

p-value

0.0044

0.0055

0.0051

0.0073

0.0068

0.0025

0.0030

SHADE

Ave

1.29E−30

2.33E−19

2.22E−04

1.43E−11

45.244

8.33E−10

3.05E−03

Std

2.11E−37

1.45E−12

1.10E−05

6.33E−09

32.773

1.44E−07

1.03E−03

p-value

0.0055

0.0044

0.0025

0.0041

0.0056

0.0077

0.0082

CMA-ES

Ave

2.02E−31

0.00E+00

1.25E−09

2.09E−09

47.336

5.02E−16

3.20E−03

Std

3.14E−42

0.00E+00

2.87E−08

1.99E−09

23.4421

1.44E−09

7.07E−03

p-value

0.0077

0.048

0.0011

0.451

0.0047

0.0055

0.0033

LSHADESPACMA

Ave

0.07537

2.25E−12

8.25E−09

1.44E−08

52.921

8.25E−10

7.70E−03

Std

0.1480

1.52E−12

1.59E−08

1.21E−09

17.712

1.24E−07

2.11E−03

p-value

0.0025

0.0055

0.0051

0.0062

0.0068

0.0025

0.0030