Table 11 PFM \(\Phi^{\chi } = \left[ {\phi_{jli}^{\chi } } \right]_{4 \times 4 \times 8}\) considering graduate students’ preferences.

From: Graduate students and supervisors matching decision-making considering stability-based fairness based on TOPSIS and grey correlation degrees

 

\(\vartheta_{1}\)

\(\vartheta_{2}\)

\(\gamma_{1}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{2}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{3}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{4}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{1}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{2}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{3}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{4}^{\chi }\)

\(\chi_{1}\)

(0.72,0.77)

(0.55,0.78)

(0.6,0.66)

(0.74,0.74)

(0.75,0)

(0.56,0.79)

(0.61,0.67)

(0.74,0.76)

\(\chi_{2}\)

(0,0.81)

(0.65,0)

(0,0.67)

(0.3,0.76)

(0.78,0)

(0.47,0.68)

(0.59,0.52)

(0.35,0.71)

\(\chi_{3}\)

(0,0.76)

(0.65,0.6)

(0.59,0.61)

(0.51,0.72)

(0.49,0.71)

(0.67,0.57)

(0.51,0.65)

(0.44,0.75)

\(\chi_{4}\)

(0.69,0.62)

(0.73,0.63)

(0.63,0.72)

(0.49,0.75)

(0.71,0.62)

(0.7,0.65)

(0.64,0.72)

(0.49,0.75)

 

\(\vartheta_{3}\)

\(\vartheta_{4}\)

 

\(\gamma_{1}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{2}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{3}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{4}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{1}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{2}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{3}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{4}^{\chi }\)

\(\chi_{1}\)

(0.75,0)

(0.42,0.78)

(0.6,0.55)

(0,0.76)

(0.64,0.69)

(0.48,0.69)

(0.51,0.63)

(0.76,0)

\(\chi_{2}\)

(0.73,0.76)

(0.65,0.71)

(0.75,0.63)

(0.46,0.78)

(0.75,0.68)

(0.53,0.71)

(0.73,0.57)

(0.43,0.68)

\(\chi_{3}\)

(0.56,0.7)

(0,0.66)

(0.62,0.61)

(0.48,0.73)

(0.54,0.74)

(0.64,0.66)

(0.61,0.64)

(0.48,0.8)

\(\chi_{4}\)

(0.73,0)

(0.74,0.66)

(0.66,0.75)

(0.51,0.78)

(0.7,0.58)

(0.69,0.6)

(0.64,0.67)

(0.43,0.77)

 

\(\vartheta_{5}\)

\(\vartheta_{6}\)

\(\gamma_{1}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{2}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{3}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{4}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{1}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{2}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{3}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{4}^{\chi }\)

\(\chi_{1}\)

(0.72,0.7)

(0,0.8)

(0.55,0.59)

(0.63,0.72)

(0,0.8)

(0.41,0.72)

(0.46,0.6)

(0.65,0.63)

\(\chi_{2}\)

(0.69,0.78)

(0.64,0.69)

(0.69,0.61)

(0,0.8)

(0,0.82)

(0.66,0.77)

(0.77,0.68)

(0.51,0.8)

\(\chi_{3}\)

(0.41,0.67)

(0.53,0.5)

(0.48,0.51)

(0.35,0.77)

(0,0.76)

(0.7,0.66)

(0.63,0.67)

(0.53,0.8)

\(\chi_{4}\)

(0.6,0.51)

(0.62,0.52)

(0.5,0.57)

(0.35,0.69)

(0.72,0)

(0.72,0.58)

(0.55,0.74)

(0.43,0.74)

 

\(\vartheta_{7}\)

\(\vartheta_{8}\)

 

\(\gamma_{1}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{2}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{3}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{4}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{1}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{2}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{3}^{\chi }\)

\(\gamma_{4}^{\chi }\)

\(\chi_{1}\)

(0.57,0.78)

(0.43,0.78)

(0.6,0.56)

(0.67,0.65)

(0.73,0.78)

(0.54,0.8)

(0.61,0.65)

(0.75,0.74)

\(\chi_{2}\)

(0.67,0.77)

(0.58,0.68)

(0.74,0.59)

(0.42,0.79)

(0.77,0.79)

(0.64,0.76)

(0.74,0.67)

(0.49,0.79)

\(\chi_{3}\)

(0.48,0.61)

(0.61,0.55)

(0.55,0.56)

(0.39,0.78)

(0.53,0.75)

(0.67,0.62)

(0.58,0.65)

(0.48,0.78)

\(\chi_{4}\)

(0.55,0.49)

(0.62,0.52)

(0.66,0)

(0.35,0.69)

(0.7,0.58)

(0.74,0)

(0.56,0.74)

(0.44,0.74)