Table 10 Green Investors, Internal control and ESG ratings divergence.
Variables | (1) | (2) | (3) |
|---|---|---|---|
IC | IC | ESGdif | |
GI | 4.836*** | ||
(2.71) | |||
lnGI | 3.429** | ||
(2.21) | |||
IC | − 0.000*** | ||
(− 2.88) | |||
Size | 21.354*** | 21.090*** | − 0.061*** |
(5.29) | (5.25) | (− 3.19) | |
Age | − 44.839*** | − 44.768*** | 0.171*** |
(− 6.72) | (− 6.71) | (4.43) | |
ROA | 501.886*** | 502.329*** | − 0.224** |
(18.04) | (18.04) | (− 2.13) | |
Lev3 | − 9.297 | − 9.121 | 0.401*** |
(− 0.43) | (− 0.42) | (4.12) | |
Growth | 4.367** | 4.332** | 0.004 |
(2.42) | (2.40) | (0.52) | |
CashFlow | − 12.013 | − 12.237 | 0.164** |
(− 0.68) | (− 0.70) | (2.13) | |
BM | − 10.775*** | − 10.573*** | − 0.042*** |
(− 4.54) | (− 4.42) | (− 3.56) | |
Intan | − 11.970 | − 11.506 | 0.114 |
(− 0.29) | (− 0.28) | (0.54) | |
SOE | − 4.351 | − 4.179 | 0.080** |
(− 0.55) | (− 0.53) | (2.00) | |
Indep | 0.368 | 0.362 | − 0.002 |
(0.98) | (0.96) | (− 1.05) | |
Dual | 3.706 | 3.716 | − 0.024 |
(1.25) | (1.25) | (− 1.39) | |
Inst | 0.121 | 0.106 | − 0.001* |
(0.95) | (0.81) | (− 1.66) | |
Board | 6.487 | 6.711 | − 0.093 |
(0.43) | (0.44) | (− 1.25) | |
Top1 | 0.267 | 0.273 | 0.001 |
(1.54) | (1.57) | (0.77) | |
Salary | − 2.007 | − 1.996 | 0.023* |
(− 0.79) | (− 0.79) | (1.92) | |
Constant | 231.087** | 236.824** | 1.927*** |
(2.49) | (2.55) | (4.21) | |
Observations | 21,362 | 21,362 | 21,362 |
Firm FE | YES | YES | YES |
Year FE | YES | YES | YES |
Adj-R2 | 0.343 | 0.343 | 0.552 |