Table 3 Comparative analysis between EBMLO-DBO and its rivals using CEC’22, D = 20.

From: Elite Bernoulli-based mutated dung beetle algorithm for global complex problems and parameter estimation of solar photovoltaic models

F

 

EBMLO-DBO

DBO

HHO

COA

AOA

WOA

PSO

GBO

NOA

SMA

ARO

LFD

C22-G1

AVG

301.65

2384.85

1441.63

1026.37

3477.08

2947.99

467.47

2120.86

2927.99

4127.77

1551.16

4332.86

C22-G1

STD

1.38

9480.85

4839.38

4802.43

1161.74

1423.36

44.89

1225.83

9230.23

2429.82

4166.38

8001.90

C22-G1

RNK

1

7

5

4

10

9

2

3

8

11

6

12

C22-G2

AVG

454.80

490.85

617.29

526.27

2159.53

576.44

436.40

460.05

833.74

520.50

772.97

570.20

C22-G2

STD

10.57

74.93

124.45

46.00

654.54

64.67

26.57

13.16

121.00

102.94

104.10

95.51

C22-G2

RNK

2

4

9

6

12

8

1

3

11

5

10

7

C22-G3

AVG

615.18

630.15

633.53

626.55

664.25

665.93

648.76

611.27

649.49

621.71

645.93

654.28

C22-G3

STD

9.03

10.64

9.26

7.58

8.79

10.42

12.29

8.25

11.66

8.86

4.74

10.98

C22-G3

RNK

2

5

6

4

11

12

8

1

9

3

7

10

C22-G4

AVG

863.42

920.44

887.64

849.53

951.49

910.27

891.01

877.27

966.69

908.01

947.02

890.58

C22-G4

STD

16.89

35.04

20.20

14.58

20.53

32.01

19.82

11.57

19.19

32.73

11.68

26.82

C22-G4

RNK

2

9

4

1

11

8

6

3

12

7

10

5

C22-G5

AVG

1408.87

2126.38

2188.71

1966.60

2992.23

3459.59

2155.64

1759.07

3236.81

2859.30

2599.35

2609.75

C22-G5

STD

337.59

569.28

506.49

430.24

360.46

1210.14

809.62

406.44

1069.82

1168.63

509.75

734.23

C22-G5

RNK

1

4

6

3

10

12

5

2

11

9

7

8

C22-G6

AVG

7409.83

1281.41

4786.89

4418.48

8169.74

8060.06

2429.74

3666.74

6886.42

6338.33

1125.70

4652.90

C22-G6

STD

6984.63

2994.64

3100.92

4182.92

7343.12

1070.03

9704.27

999.76

5402.34

1286.00

1009.88

1760.87

C22-G6

RNK

3

4

5

2

12

6

7

1

10

8

11

9

C22-G7

AVG

2065.15

2121.14

2119.48

2107.80

2239.45

2232.14

2137.17

2073.61

2182.49

2120.57

2151.16

2159.75

C22-G7

STD

22.86

42.45

38.19

48.06

100.44

68.36

31.67

28.49

51.55

40.90

23.22

45.57

C22-G7

RNK

1

6

4

3

12

11

7

2

10

5

8

9

C22-G8

AVG

2222.97

2322.80

2296.54

2243.55

2533.33

2309.11

2360.31

2233.24

2295.53

2267.97

2280.31

2375.01

C22-G8

STD

3.11

78.26

79.70

51.39

201.74

78.25

127.65

22.46

63.39

54.64

26.05

123.18

C22-G8

RNK

1

9

7

3

12

8

10

2

6

4

5

11

C22-G9

AVG

2480.80

2499.83

2576.28

2509.93

3259.03

2564.27

2467.72

2480.81

2630.88

2506.91

2592.03

2666.02

C22-G9

STD

0.03

20.30

52.59

20.54

334.72

43.54

0.68

0.04

40.32

31.16

29.35

92.29

C22-G9

RNK

2

4

8

6

12

7

1

3

10

5

9

11

C22-G10

AVG

2966.22

2799.31

4809.55

2901.22

5781.02

4794.52

4284.40

2578.70

3351.42

4087.10

3024.05

2524.17

C22-G10

STD

564.07

773.16

1359.21

748.25

788.44

1141.27

1174.42

174.22

1388.81

983.52

1202.27

84.16

C22-G10

RNK

5

3

11

4

12

10

9

2

7

8

6

1

C22-G11

AVG

2920.00

3065.81

4112.37

3574.24

8414.46

3842.55

3099.51

2920.00

5016.85

3953.99

4755.92

3419.93

C22-G11

STD

40.68

203.75

455.74

377.67

772.99

1487.05

82.65

76.11

706.85

772.70

506.43

535.32

C22-G11

RNK

1

3

9

6

12

7

4

2

11

8

10

5

C22-G12

AVG

2954.73

3014.55

2975.79

3118.69

3803.62

3087.48

2967.22

2980.13

3257.88

2958.80

3068.05

3015.53

C22-G12

STD

11.83

49.11

19.20

79.32

218.87

114.95

121.22

28.25

82.75

13.99

32.07

156.73

C22-G12

RNK

1

6

4

10

12

9

3

5

11

2

8

7

Average rank

1.83

5.33

6.50

4.33

11.50

8.92

5.25

2.42

9.67

6.25

8.08

7.91

Final rank

1

5

7

3

12

10

4

2

11

6

9

8

Back to article page