Table 1 Summary of experimental Data.

From: Verification of temporal consistency constraints in the evolution of software for intelligent unmanned systems driven by model checking

model

Evolve before adding

Evolve after adding

States

R/V memory

Time(s)

Limit

States

R/V memory

Time(s)

Limit

SM

TT_SM

14.2/53.0

0.005

CT

TT_SM

14.2/53.0

0.005

CT

DPM

TT_DPM

14.3/53.5

0.008

CT

TT_DPM

14.3/53.5

0.008

CT

PPM

TT_PPM

14.3/53.3

0.026

CT

TT_PPM

14.3/53.3

0.026

CT

BDM

TT_BDM

null

null

null

TT_BDM

14.2/52.9

0.052

CT

ECM

TT_ECM

14.3/53.4

0.048

CT

TT_ECM

14.3/53.4

0.048

CT

OAM

TT_OAM

14.3/53.6

0.006

CT

TT_OAM

14.3/53.6

0.006

CT

TC

TT_TC

14.4/53.7

0.048

CT

TT_TC

14.4/53.7

0.052

NCT

model

Evolved before modification

Evolved after modification

states

R/V memory

Time(s)

Limit

states

R/V memory

Time(s)

Limit

SM

TT_SM

14.2/53.0

0.005

CT

TT_SM

14.3/53.5

0.005

CT

DPM

TT_DPM

14.3/53.5

0.009

CT

TT_DPM

14.2/54.1

0.009

CT

PPM

TT_PPM

14.3/53.3

0.025

CT

TT_PPM

14.3/53.4

0.024

CT

ECM

TT_ECM

14.3/53.4

0.047

CT

TT_ECM

14.3/53.6

0.046

CT

OAM

TT_OAM

14.3/53.6

0.008

CT

TT_OAM

14.3/53.8

0.008

CT

TC

TT_TC

14.4/53.7

0.047

CT

TT_TC

14.5/54.5

0.046

CT

model

Evolve before deletion

Evolve after deletion

states

R/V memory

Time(s)

Limit

states

R/V memory

Time(s)

Limit

SM

TT_SM

14.2/53.0

0.005

CT

TT_SM

14.1/52.7

0.002

CT

DPM

TT_DPM

14.3/53.5

0.012

CT

TT_DPM

14.2/53.1

0.008

CT

PPM

TT_PPM

14.3/53.3

0.026

CT

TT_PPM

14.5/54.2

0.021

CT

ECM

TT_ECM

14.3/53.4

0.048

CT

TT_ECM

14.3/53.5

0.043

CT

OAM

TT_OAM

14.3/53.6

0.007

CT

TT_OAM

14.4/53.7

0.007

CT

TC

TT_TC

14.4/53.7

0.048

CT

TT_TC

14.2/52.8

0.043

CT