Table 6 Average values of IGD, C-metric, 1/HV, and 1/PSP of OL-DEVND, INSGA_II.
Instance | IGD | C-metric | 1/HV | 1/PSP | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
INSGA-II | OL-DEVND | C(IN, OL) | C(OL, IN) | INSGA-II | OL-DEVND | INSGA-II | OL-DEVND | |
50−0−0 | 0.001365 | 0.001037 | 0.488127 | 0.177221 | 1.252565 | 1.246721 | 0.052021 | 0.049303 |
50−0−1 | 0.004428 | 0.003819 | 0.046217 | 0.388213 | 2.304726 | 2.244080 | 0.051837 | 0.030474 |
50−0−2 | 0.005552 | 0.004603 | 0.059822 | 0.401222 | 2.680807 | 3.547332 | 0.050526 | 0.023793 |
50−0−3 | 0.002681 | 0.001817 | 0.492138 | 0.048821 | 1.617982 | 1.610031 | 0.050017 | 0.028712 |
50−0−4 | 0.005661 | 0.004432 | 0.331418 | 0.329812 | 1.064302 | 1.064320 | 0.048932 | 0.027096 |
50−1−0 | 0.001708 | 0.001003 | 0.600212 | 0.288053 | 1.219747 | 1.173467 | 0.094251 | 0.046426 |
50−1−1 | 0.004309 | 0.003218 | 0.047291 | 0.442018 | 2.303739 | 2.216229 | 0.084021 | 0.048201 |
50−1−2 | 0.005531 | 0.004217 | 0.051218 | 0.399471 | 2.732106 | 2.499200 | 0.091044 | 0.047902 |
50−1−3 | 0.002627 | 0.001507 | 0.552134 | 0.050133 | 1.610114 | 1.528755 | 0.088255 | 0.048201 |
50−1−4 | 0.005521 | 0.004318 | 0.434218 | 0.440781 | 1.082231 | 1.080949 | 0.086279 | 0.047709 |
50−2−0 | 0.007097 | 0.005667 | 0.776521 | 0.287541 | 1.113149 | 1.109540 | 0.098214 | 0.052876 |
50−2−1 | 0.004804 | 0.003619 | 0.048210 | 0.461920 | 1.408377 | 1.361914 | 0.097317 | 0.052909 |
50−2−2 | 0.004783 | 0.003657 | 0.288072 | 0.284718 | 1.623250 | 1.126961 | 0.098012 | 0.053883 |
50−2−3 | 0.004008 | 0.002892 | 0.442026 | 0.053346 | 1.371167 | 1.423129 | 0.097823 | 0.054072 |
50−2−4 | 0.009208 | 0.007015 | 0.809217 | 0.005825 | 1.145454 | 1.120387 | 0.097204 | 0.052102 |
150−0−0 | 0.001769 | 0.001058 | 0.562016 | 0.387209 | 1.324324 | 1.287800 | 0.062375 | 0.053128 |
150−0−1 | 0.006407 | 0.005318 | 0.004088 | 0.552017 | 3.335379 | 3.620381 | 0.063561 | 0.053208 |
150−0−2 | 0.007098 | 0.005735 | 0.005821 | 0.621720 | 3.905777 | 3.340716 | 0.064426 | 0.054082 |
150−0−3 | 0.002817 | 0.001517 | 0.202671 | 0.362819 | 2.815973 | 1.810984 | 0.063890 | 0.055231 |
150−0−4 | 0.008817 | 0.007628 | 0.020122 | 0.802088 | 2.512430 | 2.468362 | 0.065286 | 0.054027 |
150−1−0 | 0.001816 | 0.001084 | 0.382117 | 0.299024 | 1.322730 | 1.255936 | 0.077423 | 0.055324 |
150−1−1 | 0.006218 | 0.005042 | 0.003629 | 0.552014 | 3.411048 | 3.468417 | 0.078211 | 0.056438 |
150−1−2 | 0.007163 | 0.005859 | 0.005528 | 0.682007 | 3.915841 | 3.375744 | 0.079246 | 0.057903 |
150−1−3 | 0.002887 | 0.001628 | 0.225312 | 0.248231 | 2.815973 | 1.810984 | 0.078305 | 0.058023 |
150−1−4 | 0.008817 | 0.007626 | 0.021025 | 0.799256 | 2.509933 | 2.370814 | 0.079601 | 0.060214 |
150−2−0 | 0.002372 | 0.001106 | 0.499207 | 0.242019 | 1.217176 | 1.184100 | 0.086426 | 0.065241 |
150−2−1 | 0.006738 | 0.005648 | 0.000921 | 0.642011 | 2.671568 | 2.498857 | 0.085231 | 0.065292 |
150−2−2 | 0.007412 | 0.006219 | 0.002028 | 0.556281 | 4.055347 | 3.861093 | 0.087262 | 0.066620 |
150−2−3 | 0.002866 | 0.001537 | 0.098231 | 0.244833 | 2.763790 | 1.806917 | 0.087710 | 0.066391 |
150−2−4 | 0.008874 | 0.007537 | 0.011528 | 0.834120 | 2.025390 | 1.848545 | 0.088238 | 0.067202 |
250−0−0 | 0.002669 | 0.001362 | 0.253081 | 0.500726 | 1.360541 | 1.320985 | 0.102654 | 0.071343 |
250−0−1 | 0.006738 | 0.005317 | 0.002520 | 0.634621 | 4.081666 | 3.605527 | 0.110435 | 0.072054 |
250−0−2 | 0.007664 | 0.006628 | 0.002239 | 0.530925 | 4.582174 | 3.746623 | 0.112467 | 0.073025 |
250−0−3 | 0.005021 | 0.003912 | 0.162073 | 0.162242 | 1.775480 | 2.696668 | 0.114371 | 0.073531 |
250−0−4 | 0.010538 | 0.008727 | 0.010216 | 0.552017 | 2.118967 | 2.576483 | 0.115069 | 0.074092 |
250−1−0 | 0.002678 | 0.001218 | 0.237615 | 0.490216 | 1.360594 | 1.329050 | 0.140832 | 0.089215 |
250−1−1 | 0.007738 | 0.006421 | 0.002107 | 0.620971 | 4.087104 | 3.469861 | 0.144231 | 0.090207 |
250−1−2 | 0.007698 | 0.006206 | 0.002103 | 0.612714 | 4.582174 | 3.932410 | 0.145078 | 0.090620 |
250−1−3 | 0.005027 | 0.003719 | 0.090142 | 0.156820 | 1.775480 | 1.717567 | 0.143321 | 0.091072 |
250−1−4 | 0.010509 | 0.008147 | 0.009821 | 0.552781 | 2.119452 | 2.025460 | 0.145109 | 0.092082 |
250−2−0 | 0.002318 | 0.001128 | 0.260736 | 0.334521 | 1.276380 | 1.246856 | 0.134027 | 0.091453 |
250−2−1 | 0.007065 | 0.005735 | 0.001009 | 0.482351 | 4.312575 | 3.845252 | 0.142518 | 0.090112 |
250−2−2 | 0.007429 | 0.006107 | 0.001025 | 0.392717 | 4.804782 | 3.608779 | 0.136068 | 0.092013 |
250−2−3 | 0.005098 | 0.003917 | 0.099758 | 0.152094 | 1.774576 | 1.699955 | 0.141072 | 0.092107 |
250−2−4 | 0.012289 | 0.009898 | 0.096087 | 0.112864 | 2.329911 | 2.169099 | 0.138090 | 0.092208 |
B/S/W | 45/0/0 | 30/5/10 | 20/5/20 | 45/0/0 | ||||