Table 6 Qualitative findings summarized from the open survey questions and semi-structured interviews.
Categories | Description | Examples |
|---|---|---|
Helpful aspects | ||
Interpersonal exchange | The exchange and interaction with colleagues created a sense of cohesion and mutual understanding; it gave the opportunity for discussion, and expressing one´s own opinion | “I found the discussions in the group very helpful for exchanging ideas and getting rid of things.” |
Self-reflection | Continuously self-reflecting and becoming aware of one´s own thoughts, feelings and reactions helped to identify areas of control | “Worthwhile and very special to have this opportunity for personal reflection.” “I can change myself and my point of view, not the others.” |
Feeling of appreciation | Feeling valued and seen as a person | “Being brought to realize how important you are was very helpful for me.” |
Gaining relevant knowledge | Being shown different ideas, possibilities and options to act | “…interesting new thought-provoking ideas and breathing exercises that are easy to use” |
Moment of inner peace | Sessions offered the opportunity to find a moment of inner peace and mindful breathing, to treat oneself with something nice | “…to find a moment of inner peace, to breathe consciously” |
Low-threshold to participate | Sessions held at study sites, no additional time required to get there | “The easy access of the offer was helpful.” |
Regular appointments | Fixed appointments created a sense of commitment | “Regular appointments created a sense of commitment.” |
Barriers | ||
Session duration | Sessions too short, especially for group exchange exercises; on the other hand, some participants estimated the time required for the program as difficult to reconcile with the ward routine | “There was not enough time for exercises and exchange.” “The course times are not compatible with everyday working life.” |
Lack of support by leaders | Assumed lack of support and understanding from leaders | “Other employees were interested, but e.g. physicians argued: ´they [bosses] won’t give me time off for that.´ They don’t dare to ask.” |
Role conflict | One participant in the role of a nurse director took part with a nurse from the same team | |
Perceived effects | ||
Growing awareness and self-reflection | Becoming aware of the importance of one´s own health; reflecting oneself, behavior and thought patterns, which helps to choose different reaction patterns | “It was an enrichment for everyday life to deal differently with myself and my colleagues.” “It increased the awareness of your own situation, recognition of stress, opportunities to act.” |
Application to practice | Applying some exercises and techniques from the program within ward teams | “We self-organized the ´dyad concept´ in the team - after the Monday meeting, 2.5 min. I’ve been thinking about doing that in private too.” |
Empowerment | Participants experienced the program as motivating for change | “The program was positively encouraging and motivating to change things.” |
Patient perspective | Experiencing the exercises oneself helped to take patients´ perspectives | “It was a great experience for me because I accompany patients in the day clinic. Now I’ve experienced first-hand what’s easy and what’s hard, and now I realize for myself why it’s sometimes not that easy.” |
Sense of connectedness | A feeling of common humanity, not being alone with one´s problems | “It’s often reassuring to hear that things are stressful elsewhere too. And that you’re not alone. I always thought it was just me!” |
Sense of calmness | Sense of calmness through reflection where to put in energy and where not | “I have become calmer.” “I don’t let stress get to me.” |
Influence by/on work fellows | ||
Support by leaders | Contradictory experience, some indicated to experience their leaders as supportive and committed, others described their leaders as skeptical about the program and criticized their lack of interest | “The ward manager was totally committed and made a big effort.” “My boss was skeptical about it.” “It was waved through by the clinic and nurse management, but they never asked how things were going" |
Influence on colleagues | Colleagues were inspired to deal with the topics themselves | “For some, it has given impulses as to how things could run better.” |
Proposed adjustments | ||
Session duration | Suggested session length to be at least two hours; more time for exchange and practical exercises | “The course time should be extended to 10–12 sessions with the individual lessons being 2 hours long.” “Please make sure that the times for mutual exchange are extended.” |
Session content | More practice rather than theory and repetition of the learned concepts, providing the rationale for some exercises | “More practice and repetition would be useful” “I would like to know the background to some of the exercises. What it is good for” |
Hybrid-format | In-person sessions were preferred due to a better group dynamic, although online sessions were described as feasible and working well | “Contact was relatively good in the online sessions, but in-person was much better.” |
Further ideas | ||
Exchange platform | Possibility for exchange with colleagues and staying in touch beyond the scope of the program was desired; proposals were to offer a platform for participants to keep in touch | “A blackboard in the hospital would be cool for activities, e.g. on Mondays we meet up for a walk, have coffee… where we can simply get together as nursing staff and exchange ideas. An opportunity to maintain social contacts and get to know the teams better” |
Feedback platform | Establishing a platform for feedback, points of improvement and solutions | “A structure, being able to write what is not good and finding solutions for it, would be useful” |
Leader involvement | A desire for more leader involvement and appreciation | “…to get the management on board and show how important their appreciation is for the quality of life at work. There is a longing to be seen. Sometimes it can’t be satisfied, but it would be good if it came up a little.” |