Table 7 Hypothetical cost–benefit comparison of Si-NPs and Fusarium-based granular bioherbicide versus conventional herbicide use in Egyptian clover production (per feddan*).

From: Controlling dodder (Cuscuta planiflora) in Egyptian clover with silica nanoparticles and a novel bioherbicide

Parameter

Si-NPs as herbicides

Fusarium bioherbicide

Conventional herbicide

Material cost (EGP)

300–700 (local source)

250 (local source)

750–900 (imported)

Cost/application (EGP)

150

150

150

No. of applications

1–2/season

1/season

2–3/season

Total application cost (EGP)

300

150

450

Total treatment cost (EGP)

600–1000

400

1200–1350

Clover fresh yield (ton/feddan*/season)

42.9

34.3

42.7

Clover market price (EGP/ton FW)

2000

2000

2000

Gross income (EGP)

85,800

68,600

85,400

Net income (EGP) after deducting treatment cost

85,200–84,800

68,200

84,200–84,050

  1. *1 feddan =  ~ 0.42 hectares, 1 EGP = 0.020 USD (May 2025).
  2. Average fresh yield per season was calculated for each treatment based on the results achieved in the current study.
  3. Market prices are based on 2024 average values from Delta region reports. Actual figures may vary depending on market fluctuations and yield conditions.