Table 4 Performance of proposed scheme under noisy measurements (SNR = 20 dB).

From: Power system security and protection considering the integration of new energy power plants

Case no.

Disturbance type

Detection accuracy (%)

Classification accuracy (%)

Response time (ms)

Error margins (±%)

1

Voltage sag

98.5

97.2

12.8

± 0.8

2

Voltage swell

97.8

96.9

13.1

± 0.9

3

Harmonics

96.3

95.5

14.3

± 1.0

4

Transient

99.1

98.4

10.5

± 0.7

5

Flicker

97.2

96.1

13.6

± 0.9

6

Frequency deviation

98.0

96.8

12.9

± 0.8

7

Combined sag + harmonics

96.5

95.2

14.7

± 1.1

8

Combined swell + flicker

97.3

96.4

13.8

± 1.0

9

Combined transient + sag

98.7

97.5

11.6

± 0.8

10

Combined harmonics + flicker

96.9

95.7

14.1

± 1.0