Table 11 Comparative study table.
From: Automated detection of polymicrogyria in pediatric patients using deep learning
Reference | Datasets Used | Features or Techniques | Classifiers | Results Reported (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
PPMR dataset | CDCM loss function | ResNet50 | Recall—88.07, Precision – 71.86 | |
Embryonic brain dataset | Deep features | SVM | Accuracy – 87.7 | |
Training – Internal dataset. Testing – National Institute of Health (NIH) pediatric brain MRI database and the Developing Human Connectome Project (dHCP) database | Combining 2D and 3D CNN into an ensemble to predict myelin maturation age | 3D CNN from46 and EfficientNet-b0 as the 2D CNN | MAE Results: Cross-validation set: 2D model – 1.53, 3D model – 2.06, Ensemble model – 1.63 Internal test set: 2D model – 1.43, 3D model – 2.55, Ensemble model – 1.77 External NIH dataset: 2D model – 2.26, 3D model – 2.27, Ensemble model – 1.22 External dHCP dataset: 2D model – 0.44, 3D model – 0.27, Ensemble model – 0.31 | |
Publicly available Brain Tumor MRI dataset. These images were classified into two classes: images with or without a tumor | Transfer learning to evaluate and compare multiple pre-trained deep learning models | VGG-16, Inception-v3, and ResNet50 | Accuracies of VGG16 – 96, InceptionV3 – 78, ResNet50 – 95 Precision of VGG16 – 94, InceptionV3 – 75, ResNet50 – 92 Recall of VGG16 – 100, InceptionV3 – 70, ResNet50 – 89 F1-score of VGG16 – 98, InceptionV3 – 73, ResNet50 – 94 | |
Custom MRI dataset collected and augmented by Swati Kanchan from NIT Durgapur | Transfer learning and fine-tuning of MobileNet CNN; image resizing and normalization; GradCam for visual explanation | Fine-tuned MobileNet CNN | Validation Accuracy: 97.24; Test Accuracy: 97.86; Precision: 97.91; Recall: 97.86; F1-score: 97.86 for four class classification | |
Our Approach | PPMR dataset6 | Image processing pipeline using grayscale conversion, Min–Max normalization, histogram equalization, bilateral filtering, and Canny edge Detection | Modified DenseNet-201 and MobileNetV2 | Accuracies of DenseNet – 100, MobileNet – 99.8 Precision of DenseNet – 100, MobileNet – 99.6 Recall of DenseNet – 100, MobileNet – 100 |