Table 11 Comparison results of test case.
Test Case | \(N_R\) | \(K_T\) | Results | GA | PSO | ED | GWO | AO | IAO | IAO-v | CPLEX | Unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Case 1 | 3 | 20 | Best | 792.1 | 786.2 | 670.3 | 670.3 | 670.3 | 670.3 | 670.3 | 670.3 | m |
Avg | 837.8 | 843.2 | 673.7 | 696.1 | 677.7 | 675.8 | 671.4 | 670.3 | m | |||
Time | 13.68 | 24.60 | 11.66 | 26.76 | 11.32 | 12.44 | 111.12 | 5.97 | s | |||
Case 2 | 3 | 30 | Best | 1164.2 | 1141.5 | 821.6 | 843.3 | 823.0 | 821.6 | 821.6 | 821.6 | m |
Avg | 1253.3 | 1233.4 | 891.1 | 897.6 | 845.5 | 833.9 | 824.3 | 821.6 | m | |||
Time | 16.23 | 34.10 | 13.6 | 34.44 | 14.2 | 59.08 | 139.18 | 199.14 | s | |||
Case 3 | 3 | 46 | Best | 1725.1 | 1675.4 | 1208.1 | 1149.7 | 1048.6 | 1008.6 | 981.2 | 1049.2 | m |
Avg | 1842.0 | 1841.2 | 1261.8 | 1236.3 | 1084.5 | 1034.4 | 1008.3 | 1050.2 | m | |||
Time | 23.5 | 50.05 | 17.75 | 46.6 | 19.86 | 26.61 | 182.69 | 540 | s | |||
Case 4 | 4 | 20 | Best | 793.0 | 838.9 | 674.6 | 675.9 | 674.6 | 674.6 | 674.6 | 660.06 | m |
Avg | 843.2 | 920.6 | 676.2 | 701.1 | 688.9 | 686.9 | 674.7 | 660.06 | m | |||
Time | 14.67 | 26.23 | 12.5 | 28.27 | 12.32 | 23.96 | 119.93 | 4.05 | s | |||
Case 5 | 4 | 30 | Best | 1168.6 | 1226.7 | 779.1 | 801.4 | 729.4 | 728.5 | 728.5 | 793.6 | m |
Avg | 1275.8 | 1337.4 | 866.8 | 879.0 | 815.0 | 774.8 | 745.5 | 793.6 | m | |||
Time | 18.3 | 35.41 | 14.92 | 37.8 | 15.19 | 61.91 | 149.04 | 540 | s | |||
Case 6 | 4 | 46 | Best | 1658.2 | 1729.0 | 1220.1 | 1007.0 | 994.2 | 937.1 | 917.4 | 953.9 | m |
Avg | 1890.9 | 1894.8 | 1293.7 | 1186.4 | 1058.8 | 972.2 | 937.6 | 953.9 | m | |||
Time | 23.56 | 51.55 | 19.49 | 50.42 | 20.85 | 87.98 | 197.44 | 540 | s | |||
Case 7 | 5 | 30 | Best | 1294.6 | 1345.4 | 1140.5 | 1157.8 | 1148.1 | 1074.1 | 1062.0 | 1126.4 | m |
Avg | 1395.4 | 1451.7 | 1170.1 | 1206.5 | 1175.1 | 1155.3 | 1125.1 | 1126.4 | m | |||
Time | 18.324 | 36.17 | 15.34 | 37.36 | 16.3 | 66.90 | 154.13 | 540 | s | |||
Case 8 | 5 | 50 | Best | 2024.7 | 2045.5 | 1595.4 | 1483.2 | 1303.2 | 1232.3 | 1223.8 | 1291.2 | m |
Avg | 2233.0 | 2199.3 | 1638.0 | 1606.6 | 1399.6 | 1266.9 | 1243.0 | 1294.2 | m | |||
Time | 25.37 | 56.23 | 20.63 | 53.05 | 22.43 | 95.42 | 211.69 | 540 | s |
