Table 2 Checklist with SSbD guiding principles proposed for the battery machinery design stage.

From: Integration of safety and sustainability criteria into early design stages of battery cell manufacturing machinery

Section 1

Design stage-Materials efficiency—Ecodesign strategies (SSbD1; SSbD2; SSbD4, SSbD5)

1.1

Use of renewable/biobased materials in battery machinery

1.2

Use of recycled materials

1.3

Consideration of the future recyclability of materials during the selection

1.4

Use of low energy content materials

1.5

Consider environmental criteria when selecting suppliers

1.6

Prioritize the use of local raw materials

1.7

Reduce the number of different material types

1.8

Avoid overdimensioning by implementing mechanical analysis

1.9

Reduction of materials usage (Reduction in weight, volume)

1.10

Avoid the use of hazardous materials

1.11

Avoid the use of Critical Raw Materials (CRM); see Fifth list 2023 of CRM for the EU in Supplementary Table S2, and full report in46

Section 2

Manufacturing stage—Design for energy efficiency (SSbD3), prevent and avoid hazardous emissions (SSbD5) and reduce exposure to hazardous substances (SSbD6)

2.1

Reduce the number of production processes

2.2

Use of renewable energy

2.3

Optimize the energy consumption

2.4

Consider easy assembly to automate assembly processes (and subsequent dis-assembly)

2.5

Analyse new fabrication processes, optimization the process

2.6

Inspect the acceptance of the finished product at the factory

2.7

Reduce the number of auxiliaries and operational materials (e.g., water, oil, solvents)

2.8

Minimize waste production in manufacturing

2.9

Implement proper waste management in manufacturing

2.10

Use sustainable packaging trying to minimize the quantity

2.11

Use renewable transportation alternatives and optimize the logistic

Section 3

Use stage—Design for energy efficiency (SSbD3) and durability, prevent and avoid hazardous emissions (SSbD5) and reduce exposure to hazardous substances (SSbD6)

3.1

Consider the safety of the technicians

3.2

Avoid the generation of hazardous emissions during use

3.3

Minimize the number of connections in the equipment

3.4

Reduce energy consumption in comparison to similar products

3.5

Use clean energy

3.6

Establish a modular and scalable design so that it can adapt to new user requirements (e.g., compatibility with diverse cell chemistries)

3.7

Use modular assemblies that allow for the replacement of critical components. Design considering easy access to parts likely to need maintenance

3.8

Sensorisation of the product to more effectively identify the source of faults

3.9

Use digital twins to predict and correct the proper functioning of the product

3.10

Reduce the number of consumables

3.11

Choose consumables with low environmental impact

3.12

Optimization of the reliability and durability of the product

3.13

Consider whether it is necessary to sell the product or charge for its use (servitisation of the product)

Section 4

End-of-life—Consider the whole life cycle including the EoL (SSbD7, SSbD8)

4.1

Build the equipment in a modular way to facilitate maintenance and recycling at the EoL

4.2

Design the system considering that the tools required for disassembly are available and simple

4.3

Reduce the number of tools required for disassembly

4.4

Avoid permanent joints in the design

4.5

Standardize the different machine components so they can be reusable

4.6

Use surface treatments that are easy to remove

4.7

Recovery of recyclable materials (see UNE-EN ISO 11469:2001)

4.8

Minimize the landfill and incineration waste generation