Table 4 Changes of the nutrient concentrations (µg h−1 root−1) in root bleeding sap under the various tillage management practices with plant growth regulators during 2021–2022 growing seasons.

From: Tillage management practices in combination of plant growth regulators to improve root growth, lodging characteristics and maize productivity under semi-arid regions

2021

2022

Growth stages

Treatments

Fe

Zn

K

P

Ca

Mg

NH4+

NO3

Fe

Zn

K

P

Ca

Mg

NH4+

NO3

V7

ED

3.1b

6.3a

480.6f.

136.2c

117.5d

115.7e

68.1e

139.4f.

2.9d

7.4a

723.3b

173.7e

288.8b

362.9b

174.0c

133.8f.

 

ER

2.3c

6.2a

380.5 g

118.8d

107.3d

107.8e

61.8e

130.5f.

2.4d

7.0a

668.8c

159.3f.

273.4b

310.6c

140.6e

124.9f.

 

EB

1.6d

6.2a

280.4 h

101.4e

97.1e

99.8f.

55.5f.

121.6f.

1.9e

6.6b

614.4c

144.8 g

258.0c

258.3d

107.2f.

116.0 g

 

YD

2.9b

5.6b

844.7b

162.6b

181.9c

176.2c

111.2c

343.6c

3.1c

6.8b

727.8b

271.6c

292.4b

239.1e

193.3b

338.0c

 

YR

2.3c

5.1b

620.0d

108.5e

120.6d

137.9d

84.4d

257.4d

2.2d

5.5c

535.3d

220.3d

253.7c

214.6f.

151.3d

251.8d

 

YB

1.8d

3.6d

467.5f.

84.6f.

74.1f.

107.0e

66.9e

244.0d

2.3d

5.0c

345.5e

181.2e

110.6e

123.5 g

93.9 g

238.4f.

 

EYD

4.1a

6.8a

902.7a

195.9a

313.9a

234.0a

158.9a

536.9a

5.1a

7.8a

917.3a

394.3a

325.9a

391.0a

223.4a

531.3a

 

EYR

3.3b

6.3a

792.2c

163.7b

234.4b

199.8b

135.8b

457.8b

4.4b

7.4a

734.9b

332.3b

253.5c

362.5b

191.5b

452.2b

 

EYB

2.2c

5.6b

579.8e

107.4e

165.2c

168.6c

103.2c

216.2e

3.6c

4.6d

526.3d

186.9e

200.6d

241.3e

160.9c

210.6e

 

CK

1.1d

4.9c

252.9 h

38.1 g

76.7f.

81.4f.

29.2 g

99.0 g

0.9f.

4.0

280.1f.

113.6 h

103.7e

181.0 h

97.7 g

93.4 g

GFS

ED

1.5c

3.5c

131.0f.

57.4b

98.7b

116.3b

48.9c

122.1c

1.0a

1.9b

175.4e

37.2c

75.1e

80.7d

69.0c

116.5b

 

ER

1.3c

3.0c

125.4f.

33.8c

79.1c

73.1c

44.6c

110.1c

1.0a

1.8b

129.2f.

29.7d

50.5f.

64.7e

40.2d

104.5c

 

EB

1.2c

2.4d

94.2 g

29.4d

58.6e

66.6d

37.5d

70.7e

1.0a

1.5b

104.7 g

10.8e

46.5f.

48.4e

30.7d

65.1e

 

YD

1.8b

4.0b

361.0a

89.5a

94.6b

125.0a

40.3c

124.0c

1.8a

3.3a

264.1d

54.1b

97.8c

89.9d

102.5b

118.4b

 

YR

1.5c

4.0b

263.1b

76.0ab

81.8c

102.0b

37.7d

99.2e

1.4a

2.5a

197.7e

21.4d

89.2d

80.7d

74.0c

93.6d

 

YB

1.1c

4.0b

165.3e

62.4b

69.0d

79.0c

35.1d

74.3e

0.9b

1.7b

103.2 g

19.2d

62.7e

50.4e

38.1d

68.7e

 

EYD

2.3a

5.5a

216.7c

89.0a

115.9a

125.9a

82.5a

157.8a

1.1a

2.3a

620.5a

88.7a

156.5a

171.7a

150.9a

152.2a

 

EYR

1.5c

4.8b

193.0d

63.7b

92.0b

106.1b

75.3b

134.7b

1.0a

2.0a

525.9b

87.8a

131.4b

135.4b

119.9b

129.1b

 

EYB

1.2c

3.0c

120.8f.

52.4b

73.8d

77.7c

39.8d

100.7d

1.0a

1.7b

431.2c

86.8a

106.4c

99.2c

88.8c

100.7c

 

CK

1.1c

1.9e

102.7 g

25.0d

48.0e

60.1d

27.6e

66.5 g

0.9b

1.1b

97.1 g

8.6e

38.4 g

40.1f.

23.3e

60.9e

  1. Values are given as means, and values followed with the different lowercase letters in the same season indicate significant differences at P ≤ 0.05 levels under the same column (LSD test).