Table 2 Comparison Table of Model Performance.

From: Multi-scale spatial-temporal transformer for traffic flow prediction

Model

PeMS03

PeMS04

PeMS07

PeMS08

MAE

RMSE

MAPE

MAE

RMSE

MAPE

MAE

RMSE

MAPE

MAE

RMSE

MAPE

HA(1995)

29.80

46.83

28.11

38.76

57.72

29.59

45.15

66.97

21.75

32.55

48.49

20.77

ARIMA(2003)

35.41

47.59

33.78

33.73

48.80

24.18

38.17

59.27

19.46

31.09

44.32

22.73

VAR(2016)

23.65

38.26

24.51

24.54

38.61

17.24

50.22

75.63

32.22

19.19

29.81

13.10

STGCN(2017)

17.55

30.42

17.34

21.16

34.89

13.83

25.33

39.34

11.21

17.50

27.09

11.29

ASTGCN(2019)

17.34

29.56

17.21

22.93

35.22

16.56

24.01

37.87

10.73

18.25

28.06

11.64

STSGCN(2020)

17.48

29.21

16.78

21.19

33.65

13.90

24.26

39.03

10.21

17.13

26.80

10.96

MTGNN(2020)

15.85

26.23

15.55

19.08

31.56

12.96

20.82

34.09

9.03

15.40

24.93

10.17

STFGNN(2021)

16.77

28.34

16.30

19.83

31.88

13.02

22.07

35.80

9.21

16.64

26.22

10.60

STGODE(2021)

16.50

27.84

16.69

20.84

32.82

13.77

22.59

37.54

10.14

16.81

25.97

10.62

DSTAGNN(2022)

15.57

27.21

14.68

19.30

31.46

12.70

21.42

34.51

9.01

15.67

24.77

9.94

GDGCN(2023)

14.66

24.30

13.94

18.44

29.79

12.52

20.15

33.21

8.50

14.82

23.87

9.35

STIDGCN(2024)

14.76

24.59

15.28

18.16

29.77

12.24

19.26

32.51

8.11

13.45

23.28

8.77

GMAN(2020)

16.87

27.92

18.23

19.14

31.60

13.19

20.96

34.10

9.05

15.31

24.92

10.13

ASTGNN(2021)

14.78

25.00

16.40

18.29

29.82

12.49

19.54

32.82

8.25

14.20

23.49

9.28

STID(2022)

15.33

27.40

14.79

18.60

30.91

12.36

20.62

34.00

8.86

15.00

24.70

9.50

PDFormer(2023)

14.94

25.39

15.82

18.32

29.97

12.10

19.83

32.87

8.53

13.58

23.51

9.05

STAEformer(2023)

15.35

27.55

15.18

18.22

30.18

11.98

19.14

32.60

8.01

13.46

23.25

8.88

DDGFormer(2024)

15.01

24.95

15.89

18.04

30.06

11.76

18.99

32.25

7.93

13.37

23.15

8.83

MSSTFormer(ours)

14.35

25.01

14.05

17.93

29.40

11.52

18.79

32.48

7.89

13.20

23.31

8.76