Table 2 Comparison Table of Model Performance.
From: Multi-scale spatial-temporal transformer for traffic flow prediction
Model | PeMS03 | PeMS04 | PeMS07 | PeMS08 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MAE | RMSE | MAPE | MAE | RMSE | MAPE | MAE | RMSE | MAPE | MAE | RMSE | MAPE | |
HA(1995) | 29.80 | 46.83 | 28.11 | 38.76 | 57.72 | 29.59 | 45.15 | 66.97 | 21.75 | 32.55 | 48.49 | 20.77 |
ARIMA(2003) | 35.41 | 47.59 | 33.78 | 33.73 | 48.80 | 24.18 | 38.17 | 59.27 | 19.46 | 31.09 | 44.32 | 22.73 |
VAR(2016) | 23.65 | 38.26 | 24.51 | 24.54 | 38.61 | 17.24 | 50.22 | 75.63 | 32.22 | 19.19 | 29.81 | 13.10 |
STGCN(2017) | 17.55 | 30.42 | 17.34 | 21.16 | 34.89 | 13.83 | 25.33 | 39.34 | 11.21 | 17.50 | 27.09 | 11.29 |
ASTGCN(2019) | 17.34 | 29.56 | 17.21 | 22.93 | 35.22 | 16.56 | 24.01 | 37.87 | 10.73 | 18.25 | 28.06 | 11.64 |
STSGCN(2020) | 17.48 | 29.21 | 16.78 | 21.19 | 33.65 | 13.90 | 24.26 | 39.03 | 10.21 | 17.13 | 26.80 | 10.96 |
MTGNN(2020) | 15.85 | 26.23 | 15.55 | 19.08 | 31.56 | 12.96 | 20.82 | 34.09 | 9.03 | 15.40 | 24.93 | 10.17 |
STFGNN(2021) | 16.77 | 28.34 | 16.30 | 19.83 | 31.88 | 13.02 | 22.07 | 35.80 | 9.21 | 16.64 | 26.22 | 10.60 |
STGODE(2021) | 16.50 | 27.84 | 16.69 | 20.84 | 32.82 | 13.77 | 22.59 | 37.54 | 10.14 | 16.81 | 25.97 | 10.62 |
DSTAGNN(2022) | 15.57 | 27.21 | 14.68 | 19.30 | 31.46 | 12.70 | 21.42 | 34.51 | 9.01 | 15.67 | 24.77 | 9.94 |
GDGCN(2023) | 14.66 | 24.30 | 13.94 | 18.44 | 29.79 | 12.52 | 20.15 | 33.21 | 8.50 | 14.82 | 23.87 | 9.35 |
STIDGCN(2024) | 14.76 | 24.59 | 15.28 | 18.16 | 29.77 | 12.24 | 19.26 | 32.51 | 8.11 | 13.45 | 23.28 | 8.77 |
GMAN(2020) | 16.87 | 27.92 | 18.23 | 19.14 | 31.60 | 13.19 | 20.96 | 34.10 | 9.05 | 15.31 | 24.92 | 10.13 |
ASTGNN(2021) | 14.78 | 25.00 | 16.40 | 18.29 | 29.82 | 12.49 | 19.54 | 32.82 | 8.25 | 14.20 | 23.49 | 9.28 |
STID(2022) | 15.33 | 27.40 | 14.79 | 18.60 | 30.91 | 12.36 | 20.62 | 34.00 | 8.86 | 15.00 | 24.70 | 9.50 |
PDFormer(2023) | 14.94 | 25.39 | 15.82 | 18.32 | 29.97 | 12.10 | 19.83 | 32.87 | 8.53 | 13.58 | 23.51 | 9.05 |
STAEformer(2023) | 15.35 | 27.55 | 15.18 | 18.22 | 30.18 | 11.98 | 19.14 | 32.60 | 8.01 | 13.46 | 23.25 | 8.88 |
DDGFormer(2024) | 15.01 | 24.95 | 15.89 | 18.04 | 30.06 | 11.76 | 18.99 | 32.25 | 7.93 | 13.37 | 23.15 | 8.83 |
MSSTFormer(ours) | 14.35 | 25.01 | 14.05 | 17.93 | 29.40 | 11.52 | 18.79 | 32.48 | 7.89 | 13.20 | 23.31 | 8.76 |