Table 5 Comparison results among IABC, GA, PSO, and GWO.
Instances | fitness | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Best | IABC | PSO | GA | GWO | |
20_2_2 | 544.00 | 544.00 | 651.00 | 599.00 | 609.00 |
20_2_5 | 636.00 | 636.00 | 728.00 | 675.00 | 750.00 |
20_2_8 | 800.00 | 800.00 | 874.00 | 844.00 | 894.00 |
20_5_2 | 266.00 | 268.00 | 288.00 | 266.00 | 323.00 |
20_5_5 | 388.00 | 388.00 | 410.00 | 409.00 | 451.00 |
20_5_8 | 519.00 | 519.00 | 522.00 | 539.00 | 554.00 |
50_2_2 | 1323.00 | 1323.00 | 1422.00 | 1350.00 | 1444.00 |
50_2_5 | 1569.00 | 1569.00 | 1666.00 | 1624.00 | 1592.00 |
50_2_8 | 1721.00 | 1721.00 | 1776.00 | 1835.00 | 1750.00 |
50_5_2 | 618.00 | 618.00 | 664.00 | 643.00 | 634.00 |
50_5_5 | 754.00 | 754.00 | 819.00 | 770.00 | 767.00 |
50_5_8 | 881.00 | 881.00 | 953.00 | 911.00 | 903.00 |
80_2_2 | 2160.00 | 2160.00 | 2240.00 | 2269.00 | 2311.00 |
80_2_5 | 2364.00 | 2364.00 | 2452.00 | 2435.00 | 2461.00 |
80_2_8 | 2626.00 | 2669.00 | 2726.00 | 2695.00 | 2626.00 |
80_5_2 | 926.00 | 926.00 | 1019.00 | 994.00 | 972.00 |
80_5_5 | 1112.00 | 1112.00 | 1136.00 | 1174.00 | 1118.00 |
80_5_8 | 1265.00 | 1280.00 | 1319.00 | 1293.00 | 1265.00 |
100_2_2 | 2609.00 | 2774.00 | 2609.00 | 2755.00 | 2866.00 |
100_2_5 | 2979.00 | 2979.00 | 3099.00 | 3098.00 | 3056.00 |
100_2_8 | 3179.00 | 3234.00 | 3179.00 | 3352.00 | 3183.00 |
100_5_2 | 1179.00 | 1179.00 | 1187.00 | 1246.00 | 1203.00 |
100_5_5 | 1346.00 | 1368.00 | 1429.00 | 1403.00 | 1346.00 |
100_5_8 | 1482.00 | 1525.00 | 1578.00 | 1626.00 | 1482.00 |
200_2_2 | 5431.00 | 5550.00 | 5431.00 | 5769.00 | 5818.00 |
200_2_5 | 5748.00 | 5748.00 | 6048.00 | 6050.00 | 6007.00 |
200_2_8 | 6068.00 | 6068.00 | 6315.00 | 6320.00 | 6141.00 |
200_5_2 | 2333.00 | 2333.00 | 2418.00 | 2398.00 | 2372.00 |
200_5_5 | 2509.00 | 2526.00 | 2590.00 | 2639.00 | 2509.00 |
200_5_8 | 2672.00 | 2758.00 | 2827.00 | 2909.00 | 2672.00 |
Average | 1933.57 | 1952.47 | 2012.50 | 2029.67 | 2002.63 |
