Table 2 Green Boll damage due to pink bollworm in different states of India during 2007 to 2023 (Central Zone).

From: Resistance development in pink bollworm (Pectinophora Gossypiella Saunders) against Bt cotton and its’ establishment as mid season pest in India

Year

Maharashtra

 

Gujarat

 

Odisha

Rahuri (Irrigated)

Nanded (Rainfed)

Akola (Rainfed)

Junagarh (Irrigated)

Surat (Rainfed)

Bhavanipatna

Bt

Non-Bt

Bt

Non-Bt

Bt

Non-Bt

Bt

Non-Bt

Bt

Non-Bt

Non-Bt

2007

1.22d

17.84b

0.00

0.00

-

-

-

-

-

4.47d

0

2008

2.1d

13.23bc

0.00

0.00

-

-

-

-

-

8.45d

0

2009

3.76d

12.45bc

0.00

0.00

-

-

-

-

-

13.25c

0

2010

1.46d

17.67b

0.00

0.00

0.00

10.00d

-

-

-

22.56ab

0

2011

2.18d

15.28bc

0.00

0.00

0.00

31.00b

-

-

-

17.30bc

0

2012

0.92d

9.28c

3.50f

8.33e

0.00

21.00c

1.40c

12.97b

4.25c

12.21c

0

2013

1.04d

16.53b

7.50e

10.00d

-

10.00d

2.54b

12.00b

7.24b

15.38bc

0

2014

0.94d

14.92bc

10.40de

11.00

-

14.00d

2.61b

9.19bc

9.36b

18.34bc

0

2015

1.08d

14.83bc

22.57b

31.42b

-

13.00d

3.16b

12.77b

13.30ab

24.21ab

0

2016

16.8b

27.49ab

20.40b

35.33b

-

42.00ab

1.33c

14.90ab

14.25a

26.21a

0

2017

23.15ab

25.5ab

35.63a

49.20a

51.00a

54.00a

0.88c

4.24c

12.25ab

23.24ab

0.31

2018

24.7ab

26.58ab

32.33a

37.37b

10.00ef

16.00 cd

1.00c

12.57b

7.49b

16.37bc

3.33

2019

27.13ab

33.53a

16.00c

18.66c

23.00d

32.00b

2.14bc

13.16ab

8.41b

21.23b

0

2020

25.99ab

31.21a

13.33d

19.45c

30.00c

48.00ab

6.00a

17.57a

10.62ab

24.01ab

0

2021

30.95a

34.41a

22.50b

32.50b

41.00b

53.00a

6.32a

17.68a

15.23a

20.77b

0

2022

12.21c

17.8b

13.33d

11.33d

5.00f

7.00e

5.33a

18.15a

9.50b

16.00bc

0

2023

23.32ab

28.70ab

9.60de

8.80e

17.75e

22.50c

3.33b

12.33b

12.50ab

19.50b

-

Mean

11.70

21.01

10.98

20.53

17.78

26.68

3.01

17.85

10.37

13.13

0.23

Range

0.92–30.95

9.28–34.41

0.00–35.63

0.00–49.20

0.00–51.00

7.00–54.00

0.88–6.32

4.24–18.15

4.25–15.23

4.47–26.21

0.00–3.33 (NS)

  1. *difference in small letters within a particular column indicate significant difference (p < 0.05), NS; non significant.