Table 12 Comparison in terms of SSE and overshoot.
SSE ratios | Overshoot ratios | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ps | Qs | Ps | Qs | ||
Ref 91 | – | – | 7.23% | 16.59% | |
– | – | 74.46% | 48.53% | ||
– | – | 31% | 21.74% | ||
Ref 92 | 35% | 36.93% | – | – | |
Ref 93 | Test 1 | 28.76% | 76.55% | 25.07% | 6.44% |
Test 2 | 30.48% | 24.62% | 9.19% | 6.05% | |
Ref 94 | 45.83% | 78.44% | – | – | |
56.52% | 52.22% | – | – | ||
87.50% | 48.75% | – | – | ||
Ref 95 | – | – | 73.83% | 48.38% | |
– | – | 77.58% | 82.76% | ||
– | – | 20.10% | 49.32% | ||
Ref 96 | 50% | 38.32% | 32.20% | 44.06% | |
40% | 39.68% | 32.49% | 22.77% | ||
Ref 97 | – | – | 51.49% | 62.55% | |
– | – | 62.85% | 70.83% | ||
– | – | 59.79% | 67.34% | ||
Designed technique | 76% | 85% | 72% | 83 | |
72% | 92% | 72% | 92% | ||