Table 6 Comparison of lifetimes of algorithms with different initial energies and regions.
Lifetime\Area | M*M = 100 * 100, N = 50 BS=(50, 150) | M*M = 200 * 200,N = 200 BS=(100, 250) | M*M = 300 * 300, N = 450 BS=(150, 350) | M*M = 400 * 400, N = 800 BS=(200, 450) | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
E0 | Algorithm | 1 | 30% | 50% | 80% | 1 | 30% | 50% | 80% | 1 | 30% | 50% | 80% | 1 | 30% | 50% | 80% |
0.3 | LEACH | 536 | 587 | 618 | 728 | 186 | 345 | 455 | 549 | 44 | 162 | 274 | 493 | 21 | 82 | 152 | 392 |
LEACH-C | 587 | 591 | 596 | 600 | 300 | 448 | 475 | 495 | 124 | 264 | 332 | 424 | 27 | 168 | 226 | 359 | |
LEACH-SSA | 596 | 608 | 613 | 620 | 422 | 451 | 464 | 538 | 188 | 283 | 356 | 503 | 33 | 172 | 259 | 421 | |
LEACH-SSSA | 626 | 632 | 634 | 637 | 530 | 549 | 551 | 555 | 398 | 478 | 485 | 491 | 209 | 386 | 403 | 415 | |
LEACH-MSSA | 656 | 665 | 667 | 673 | 628 | 638 | 641 | 645 | 561 | 585 | 588 | 594 | 269 | 516 | 527 | 540 | |
0.4 | LEACH | 698 | 789 | 828 | 966 | 251 | 452 | 593 | 717 | 63 | 217 | 367 | 632 | 21 | 108 | 199 | 513 |
LEACH-C | 782 | 793 | 796 | 800 | 395 | 594 | 641 | 661 | 164 | 356 | 444 | 566 | 61 | 215 | 299 | 480 | |
LEACH-SSA | 800 | 811 | 816 | 823 | 551 | 600 | 622 | 684 | 283 | 385 | 463 | 670 | 68 | 235 | 354 | 557 | |
LEACH-SSSA | 837 | 841 | 844 | 847 | 708 | 734 | 736 | 741 | 517 | 644 | 650 | 656 | 236 | 527 | 543 | 554 | |
LEACH-MSSA | 880 | 885 | 888 | 892 | 836 | 851 | 855 | 859 | 730 | 778 | 783 | 787 | 316 | 682 | 693 | 710 | |
0.5 | LEACH | 891 | 991 | 1032 | 1187 | 289 | 569 | 755 | 891 | 83 | 273 | 460 | 796 | 24 | 133 | 252 | 644 |
LEACH-C | 983 | 993 | 997 | 1000 | 480 | 746 | 797 | 820 | 205 | 442 | 554 | 709 | 76 | 272 | 367 | 595 | |
LEACH-SSA | 1003 | 1015 | 1022 | 1028 | 692 | 754 | 779 | 847 | 346 | 481 | 582 | 841 | 106 | 298 | 448 | 686 | |
LEACH-SSSA | 1050 | 1054 | 1057 | 1060 | 903 | 918 | 921 | 925 | 727 | 807 | 812 | 818 | 281 | 667 | 681 | 690 | |
LEACH-MSSA | 1099 | 1105 | 1108 | 1113 | 1050 | 1061 | 1065 | 1071 | 919 | 971 | 975 | 981 | 541 | 855 | 869 | 891 | |
0.6 | LEACH | 1073 | 1184 | 1244 | 1463 | 362 | 671 | 908 | 1077 | 112 | 329 | 551 | 972 | 41 | 161 | 299 | 775 |
LEACH-C | 1184 | 1193 | 1195 | 1199 | 566 | 895 | 958 | 978 | 242 | 514 | 665 | 843 | 101 | 315 | 438 | 715 | |
LEACH-SSA | 1206 | 1220 | 1223 | 1230 | 807 | 903 | 937 | 1013 | 409 | 583 | 697 | 995 | 126 | 362 | 543 | 811 | |
LEACH-SSSA | 1258 | 1265 | 1267 | 1269 | 1078 | 1103 | 1104 | 1107 | 778 | 973 | 977 | 983 | 315 | 801 | 817 | 825 | |
LEACH-MSSA | 1320 | 1331 | 1333 | 1337 | 1226 | 1263 | 1270 | 1282 | 1095 | 1167 | 1170 | 1177 | 665 | 998 | 1019 | 1066 | |
0.7 | LEACH | 1238 | 1388 | 1479 | 1719 | 429 | 808 | 1052 | 1256 | 138 | 384 | 643 | 1129 | 41 | 184 | 351 | 909 |
LEACH-C | 1381 | 1388 | 1391 | 1397 | 645 | 1044 | 1122 | 1139 | 280 | 591 | 765 | 988 | 119 | 373 | 505 | 835 | |
LEACH-SSA | 1411 | 1425 | 1428 | 1435 | 950 | 1055 | 1096 | 1189 | 475 | 675 | 826 | 1154 | 174 | 421 | 605 | 957 | |
LEACH-SSSA | 1469 | 1476 | 1479 | 1482 | 1268 | 1288 | 1291 | 1293 | 871 | 1139 | 1145 | 1151 | 348 | 938 | 949 | 958 | |
LEACH-MSSA | 1542 | 1548 | 1551 | 1554 | 1479 | 1489 | 1492 | 1498 | 1290 | 1357 | 1362 | 1369 | 765 | 1256 | 1260 | 1268 | |