Table 4 Summary of test results.

From: Strengthening of corroded RC slab–column joints using thin-ply hybrid FRP under punching shear

Specimen

Vcr

(kN)

Dcr

(mm)

Vu

(kN)

Du

(mm)

% Change in Vu vs. S-H

Ki

(kN/mm)

S-N

44.62

0.71

217

1.53

+ 49.66%

62.8

S-H (Corroded Control)

40.64

1.01

145

3.1

0.00%

40.2

S-H-G1

70

0.98

188

1.73

+ 29.66%

71.5

S-H-G2

72

0.98

209

1.31

+ 44.14%

73.5

S-H-G3

70

0.98

219

1.13

+ 51.03%

71.5

S-H-C1

89

1.02

203

2.10

+ 40.00%

87.3

S-H-C2

121

1.01

232

1.58

+ 60.00%

119.9

S-H-C3

120

1.02

227

1.81

+ 56.55%

117.7

S-H-GCG

121

1

228

1.15

+ 57.24%

121.0

S-H-GC

121

1.02

252

1.28

+ 73.79%

118.7

S-H-GCC

122

1.03

256

1.31

+ 76.55%

118.5

Specimen

Ku

(kN/mm)

Ductility

index

Pre-cracking energy

(kN·mm)

Post-Cracking Energy

(kN·mm)

Total Energy

(kN·mm)

Failure

mode

S-N

210.22

1.00

15.84

157.76

173.60

Flexure

S-H (Corroded Control)

49.93

2.03

20.52

246.28

266.80

Flexure/

Punching

S-H-G1

157.84

1.13

34.30

188.56

222.86

Punching

S-H-G2

419.27

0.85

35.28

148.32

183.60

Punching/

Debonding

S-H-G3

996.20

0.74

34.30

128.92

163.22

Punching/

Debonding

S-H-C1

105.56

1.37

45.39

261.21

306.60

Punching

S-H-C2

194.74

1.03

61.01

217.86

278.87

Punching

S-H-C3

135.44

1.18

61.20

252.84

314.04

Punching/

Debonding

S-H-GCG

705.26

0.75

60.50

140.47

200.97

Punching/

Debonding

S-H-GC

495.07

0.84

61.71

177.87

239.58

Punching

S-H-GCC

484.18

0.85

62.83

184.15

246.98

Punching

  1. Vcr is the load at first crack; Dcr is the deflection atfirst crack load; Vu is the ultimate load; and Du is the deflection at the ultimate load.