Table 3 Study characteristics.
Study | Population | Interventions | Measurement Index | Outcomes | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Type of athletes | Sample/Age/Gender | Method | Time/Frequency/Duration | |||
Sun21/China/RCT | Collegiate badminton athletes | 20/18.0 ± 1.04/100%male | EG: CCST CG: TST | 25 min/3 times weekly/10 weeks | FMS Technique | FMS: squat ↔; hurdle↔; straight squat (P < 0.05)↑; shoulder flexibility↔; lower waist flexibility ↔; body control push up ↔; swivel stability (P < 0.05)↑; Skill: back toss medicine ball ↔; badminton throw (P < 0.01)↑; backhand draw (P < 0.05)↑; forehand kick (P < 0.05)↑; backhand kick (P < 0.05)↑ |
Zhou12/China/RCT | Collegiate badminton athletes | 20/22.15 ± 0.17/100%male | EG: CCST CG: TST | 120 min/3 times weekly/12 weeks | Physical fitness technique | Core strength: badminton throw(P < 0.05)↑; sit-up (P < 0.05)↑; 8-stage abdominal bridge ↔ Balance: eyes-closed single leg standing (P < 0.05)↑; eyes-closed straight-line walking (P < 0.05)↑ Smash: stroke speed (P < 0.01)↑; placement stability (P < 0.01)↑ |
Khatoon10/India/RCT | Collegiate badminton athletes | 34/19–23/NR | EG: CCST CG: PT | NR/2 times weekly/6 weeks | Physical fitness | Star excursion balance test (P < 0.05)↑; Agility (P < 0.05)↑; core endurance (P < 0.05)↑ |
Wang11/China/RCT | Collegiate tennis athletes | 23/18.04 ± 2.07/100% female | EG: DCST CG: TST | 30 min/3 times weekly/9 weeks | Physical fitness technique | Core stability: supine leg lift (P < 0.05)↑; core endurance: abdominal fatigue test (P < 0.05)↑; supine back extension (P < 0.05)↑ Technique: serve accuracy (P < 0.05)↑; serve speed (P < 0.05)↑; volley (P < 0.05) ↓ |
Bashir22/India/RCT | Adolescent junior tennis players | 30/15.3 ± 0.8/NR | EG: CCST CG: RT | NR/3 times weekly/5 weeks | Physical fitness | Star excursion balance test (P < 0.01)↑; Agility (P < 0.01)↑ |
Huang23/Taiwan/RCT | Collegiate tennis athletes | 30/21.9 ± 1.9/NR | EG: DCST CG: RT | 60 min/3 times weekly/8 weeks | Technique | Accuracy: BC(P < 0.05)↑RFC (P < 0.05)↑;RFD(P < 0.05)↑; RBC (P < 0.05)↑; RBD (P < 0.05)↑; FC ↔; FD ↔; BD ↔Ball Speed: FC (P < 0.05)↑, FD (P < 0.05)↑; BC (P < 0.05)↑; BD (P < 0.05)↑; RFC↔; RFD (P < 0.05)↑; RBC (P < 0.05)↑, RBD↔ |
Gergüz24/Turkey/RCT | Junior tennis players | 40/12.03 ± 3.54/50% male | EG: CCST CG: NT | 50 min/2 times weekly/8 weeks | Physical fitnessQuality of life | Core stability (P < 0.01)↑; lower waist flexibility (P < 0.01)↑; shoulder flexibility (P < 0.01)↑; static balance (P < 0.01)↑; dynamic balance (P < 0.01)↑; stability (P < 0.01)↑ Physical functioning ↔; bodily pain (P < 0.01)↑; vitality (P < 0.01)↑; mental health (P < 0.01)↑; general health (P < 0.01)↑ |
Meng25/China/RCT | National table tennis athletes | 24/NR/71% male | EG: CCST CG: RT | 25 min/NR/9 weeks | Physical fitness Technique | Core stability (P < 0.01)↑ spin control (P < 0.05)↑ |
Guo26/China/RCT | Adolescent table tennis athletes | 27/9–17/63% male | EG: CCST CG: RT | NR/NR/12 weeks | Grade VIII abdominal bridge | Core stability (P < 0.01)↑ |
Esen27/Turkey/RCT | Collegiate tennis players | 26/NR/NR | EG: CCST CG: NT | 30 min 3 times weekly/8 weeks | Star excursion balance test | Balance (P < 0.05)↑ |
Liu28/China/RCT | Collegiate tennis players | 20/NR/NR | EG: CCST CG: NT | 30 min/3 times weekly/14 weeks | Technique | Serve speed (P < 0.05)↑ |
Ma29/China/RCT | Adolescent tennis athletes | 12/15.0 ± 3.8/100% male | EG: CCST CG: TST | 20 min/NR/8 weeks | Physical fitness | Agility (P < 0.05)↑; upper strength (P < 0.05)↑, core endurance (P < 0.01)↑; |
Arslan30/Turkey/RCT | Adolescent tennis athletes | 25/12.38 ± 1.21/NR | EG: CCST CG: NT | 20 min/3 times weekly/8 weeks | Physical fitness Technique | Lower-body strength (P < 0.01)↑; agility (P < 0.05)↑; Comprehensive performance (P < 0.01)↑ |
McCurdy13 USA/RCT | Collegiate intermediate tennis players | 35/26.14 ± 6.69/60% male | EG: CCST CG: NT | 30 min/2 times weekly/8 weeks | Physical fitness Technique | Core stability (P < 0.05)↑ Serve speed ↔ |
Yüksel31/Turkey/RCT | National Badminton players | 40/18.98 ± 1.92/55% male | EG: CCST CG: NT | 25 min/3 times weekly/8 weeks | Star excursion balance test | Balance (P < 0.05)↑ |
Chen32/China/RCT | Collegiate tennis players | 22/NR/64%male | EG: CCST CG: TST | 45 min 4 times weekly/16 weeks | Technique | Stroke accuracy (P < 0.05)↑; spin control (P < 0.01)↑ |
Türkmen33/Turkey/RCT | Collegiate tennis players | 30/20.47 ± 2.04/100% male | EG: CCST CG: NT | NR 3 times weekly/6 weeks | Physical fitness | Core strength (P < 0.01)↑; balance (P < 0.05)↑; lower-body strength (P < 0.05)↑; agility (P < 0.05)↑ |
Cui34/China/RCT | Adolescent tennis athletes | 30/16/18/100% male | EG: CCST CG: TST | 60 min/3 times weekly/8 weeks | Physical fitness | Agility (P < 0.05)↑; core stability (P < 0.01)↑ |