Table 3 Study characteristics.

From: Effectiveness of core strength training for racket sport athletes’ performance: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Study

Population

Interventions

Measurement Index

Outcomes

Type of athletes

Sample/Age/Gender

Method

Time/Frequency/Duration

Sun21/China/RCT

Collegiate badminton athletes

20/18.0 ± 1.04/100%male

EG: CCST CG: TST

25 min/3 times weekly/10 weeks

FMS Technique

FMS: squat ↔; hurdle↔; straight squat (P < 0.05)↑; shoulder flexibility↔; lower waist flexibility ↔; body control push up ↔; swivel stability (P < 0.05)↑; Skill: back toss medicine ball ↔; badminton throw (P < 0.01)↑; backhand draw (P < 0.05)↑; forehand kick (P < 0.05)↑; backhand kick (P < 0.05)↑

Zhou12/China/RCT

Collegiate badminton athletes

20/22.15 ± 0.17/100%male

EG: CCST CG: TST

120 min/3 times weekly/12 weeks

Physical fitness technique

Core strength: badminton throw(P < 0.05)↑; sit-up (P < 0.05)↑; 8-stage abdominal bridge ↔ Balance: eyes-closed single leg standing (P < 0.05)↑; eyes-closed straight-line walking (P < 0.05)↑ Smash: stroke speed (P < 0.01)↑; placement stability (P < 0.01)↑

Khatoon10/India/RCT

Collegiate badminton athletes

34/19–23/NR

EG: CCST CG: PT

NR/2 times weekly/6 weeks

Physical fitness

Star excursion balance test (P < 0.05)↑; Agility (P < 0.05)↑; core endurance (P < 0.05)↑

Wang11/China/RCT

Collegiate tennis athletes

23/18.04 ± 2.07/100% female

EG: DCST CG: TST

30 min/3 times weekly/9 weeks

Physical fitness technique

Core stability: supine leg lift (P < 0.05)↑; core endurance: abdominal fatigue test (P < 0.05)↑; supine back extension (P < 0.05)↑ Technique: serve accuracy (P < 0.05)↑; serve speed (P < 0.05)↑; volley (P < 0.05) ↓

Bashir22/India/RCT

Adolescent junior tennis players

30/15.3 ± 0.8/NR

EG: CCST CG: RT

NR/3 times weekly/5 weeks

Physical fitness

Star excursion balance test (P < 0.01)↑; Agility (P < 0.01)↑

Huang23/Taiwan/RCT

Collegiate tennis athletes

30/21.9 ± 1.9/NR

EG: DCST CG: RT

60 min/3 times weekly/8 weeks

Technique

Accuracy: BC(P < 0.05)↑RFC (P < 0.05)↑;RFD(P < 0.05)↑; RBC (P < 0.05)↑; RBD (P < 0.05)↑; FC ↔; FD ↔; BD ↔Ball Speed: FC (P < 0.05)↑, FD (P < 0.05)↑; BC (P < 0.05)↑; BD (P < 0.05)↑; RFC↔; RFD (P < 0.05)↑; RBC (P < 0.05)↑, RBD↔

GergĂĽz24/Turkey/RCT

Junior tennis players

40/12.03 ± 3.54/50% male

EG: CCST CG: NT

50 min/2 times weekly/8 weeks

Physical fitnessQuality of life

Core stability (P < 0.01)↑; lower waist flexibility (P < 0.01)↑; shoulder flexibility (P < 0.01)↑; static balance (P < 0.01)↑; dynamic balance (P < 0.01)↑; stability (P < 0.01)↑ Physical functioning ↔; bodily pain (P < 0.01)↑; vitality (P < 0.01)↑; mental health (P < 0.01)↑; general health (P < 0.01)↑

Meng25/China/RCT

National table tennis athletes

24/NR/71% male

EG: CCST CG: RT

25 min/NR/9 weeks

Physical fitness Technique

Core stability (P < 0.01)↑ spin control (P < 0.05)↑

Guo26/China/RCT

Adolescent table tennis athletes

27/9–17/63% male

EG: CCST CG: RT

NR/NR/12 weeks

Grade VIII abdominal bridge

Core stability (P < 0.01)↑

Esen27/Turkey/RCT

Collegiate tennis players

26/NR/NR

EG: CCST CG: NT

30 min 3 times weekly/8 weeks

Star excursion balance test

Balance (P < 0.05)↑

Liu28/China/RCT

Collegiate tennis players

20/NR/NR

EG: CCST CG: NT

30 min/3 times weekly/14 weeks

Technique

Serve speed (P < 0.05)↑

Ma29/China/RCT

Adolescent tennis athletes

12/15.0 ± 3.8/100% male

EG: CCST CG: TST

20 min/NR/8 weeks

Physical fitness

Agility (P < 0.05)↑; upper strength (P < 0.05)↑, core endurance (P < 0.01)↑;

Arslan30/Turkey/RCT

Adolescent tennis athletes

25/12.38 ± 1.21/NR

EG: CCST CG: NT

20 min/3 times weekly/8 weeks

Physical fitness Technique

Lower-body strength (P < 0.01)↑; agility (P < 0.05)↑; Comprehensive performance (P < 0.01)↑

McCurdy13 USA/RCT

Collegiate intermediate tennis players

35/26.14 ± 6.69/60% male

EG: CCST CG: NT

30 min/2 times weekly/8 weeks

Physical fitness Technique

Core stability (P < 0.05)↑ Serve speed ↔

YĂĽksel31/Turkey/RCT

National Badminton players

40/18.98 ± 1.92/55% male

EG: CCST CG: NT

25 min/3 times weekly/8 weeks

Star excursion balance test

Balance (P < 0.05)↑

Chen32/China/RCT

Collegiate tennis players

22/NR/64%male

EG: CCST CG: TST

45 min 4 times weekly/16 weeks

Technique

Stroke accuracy (P < 0.05)↑; spin control (P < 0.01)↑

TĂĽrkmen33/Turkey/RCT

Collegiate tennis players

30/20.47 ± 2.04/100% male

EG: CCST CG: NT

NR 3 times weekly/6 weeks

Physical fitness

Core strength (P < 0.01)↑; balance (P < 0.05)↑; lower-body strength (P < 0.05)↑; agility (P < 0.05)↑

Cui34/China/RCT

Adolescent tennis athletes

30/16/18/100% male

EG: CCST CG: TST

60 min/3 times weekly/8 weeks

Physical fitness

Agility (P < 0.05)↑; core stability (P < 0.01)↑

  1. RCT randomized controlled trial, EG experimental group, CG comparison group, CCST combined core strength training, DCST dynamic core strength training, TST traditional strength training, PT plyometric training, RT regular training, NT no training, NR no report, FC forehand cross-court, FD forehand down-the-line, BC backhand cross-court, BD backhand down-the-line, RFC running forehand cross-court, RFD running forehand down-the-line, RBD running backhand down-the-line.