Table 3 Comparison of OAM Manipulation Technologies for FSO Terminals.

From: Robust high-capacity free-space optical communication using OAM-based structured light and intelligent adaptive signal processing

Parameter

SLM

Dielectric metasurface

Notes

Phase control

Programmable (8–12 bit resolution)

Static (pre-fabricated)

SLM offers dynamic reconfiguration; the metasurface profile is fixed.

Refresh rate

\(\le\) 1 kHz

Not applicable

SLM refresh limits real-time switching speed.

Insertion loss

10–20%

20–40%

Metasurface loss varies with material and design.

Crosstalk (SXR)

15–20 dB

15–25 dB

Higher-order OAM modes show increased sensitivity to imperfections.

Field of view

Limited (pixel-constrained)

Wide (typically >30\(\vphantom{0}^\circ\))

SLM field of view is restricted by pixel count and fill factor.

Cost

Significantly higher

Potentially lower at scale

Metasurfaces benefit from batch fabrication and semiconductor-process compatibility.

Integration potential

Moderate

High

Metasurfaces enable ultra-thin, planar integration with detectors.

Alignment sensitivity

High (\(\mu\)rad-level precision)

Moderate

SLM requires precise angular and translational alignment.