Table 6 Significant predictors of perception accuracy and bias from binary (BLR) and multinomial (MLR) logistic regression models.

From: Do pastoral and agro-pastoral perceptions align with observed climate extremes? Evidence from the Koh-e-Suleiman Range, Pakistan

Dependent variable

Model

Outcome category

Predictor(s)

Odds ratio (95% CI)

p-value

Interpretation

Temperature

BLR

Accuracy

TLU

1.070 (not reported)

0.035

Larger herds associated with higher odds of correctly perceiving warming.

MLR

Misjudgment

Age

0.97 (0.96–0.98)

\(<0.001\)

Older respondents less likely to misjudge.

  

Education

0.95 (0.93–0.97)

\(<0.001\)

Higher education reduces misjudgment.

  

TLU

0.93 (0.91–0.95)

\(<0.001\)

Livestock wealth decreases misjudgment odds.

 

Underestimation

Education

0.16 (0.14–0.18)

\(<0.001\)

Education strongly protects against underestimation.

Cold spells

BLR

Accuracy

Age

1.032 (not reported)

0.027

Older respondents are more likely to correctly perceive cold spells.

  

Education

1.129 (not reported)

0.009

Higher education improves cold-spell accuracy.

  

Income

0.017

Higher income improves cold-spell accuracy.

MLR

Overestimation

Income

1.00 (1.0000–1.000002)

\(<0.001\)

Marginal effect: wealth linked to slight overestimation.

Rainfall

BLR

Accuracy

\(>0.10\)

No significant predictors found.

MLR

Misjudgment

Age

1.03 (1.01–1.05)

\(<0.001\)

Older respondents have slightly higher odds of misjudging rainfall.

  

Education

0.85 (0.82–0.88)

\(<0.001\)

Higher education reduces rainfall misjudgment.

Rain intensity

BLR

Accuracy (marginal)

Education

0.068

A marginal negative association between education and accuracy.

MLR

Overestimation

Education

1.08 (1.05–1.11)

\(<0.001\)

More education predicts overestimation.

Floods

BLR

Accuracy (marginal)

Age

0.063

A marginal positive association between age and accuracy.

MLR

Overestimation

TLU

1.02 (1.01–1.03)

\(<0.001\)

Larger herds linked to a slight increase in flood overestimation.

Warm spells

BLR

Accuracy

\(>0.10\)

No significant predictors found.

Drought spells

BLR

Accuracy

\(>0.10\)

No significant predictors found.

  1. BLR, Binary logistic regression; MLR, Multinomial logistic regression. Odds ratios (OR) with 95% confidence intervals show how predictors (age, education, income, TLU) affect perception accuracy or bias. OR > 1 means the predictor increases the likelihood of correct perception (or a given bias), while OR < 1 means it reduces the likelihood. Only statistically significant results (\(p < 0.05\)) are reported. The reference category for all logistic regression models is “Correct perception.” For multinomial logistic regression models, “Correct perception” was used as the reference outcome category; all odds ratios are interpreted relative to this baseline. Continuous predictors (age, income, TLU) were entered as continuous variables.