Table 1 Quicksummary on deep learning frameworks for the OA knee segmentation and prediction.

From: Enhanced swin transformer with dual attention for knee osteoarthritis severity grading from X-ray images

Authors

Techniques used

Accuracy

Computational complexity

Training time

Processing speed

Standard Deviation

Mean

Memory consumption

Power requirement

Robustness

AUC

Overfitting issues

Sindhu et al.

CNN

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ High

✘ low

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✘ High

✔ Average

✔ Average

✘ less

✘ High

Dalia et al.20

VGG16, Resnet

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ High

✘ low

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✘ High

✘ High

✘ low

✔ Average

✘ High

Shen et al.21

CNN, ResNet and DeepLabV3P

✘ Low

✔ Average

  

✔ Average

✔ Average

✘ High

✔ Average

✔ Average

✘ less

✘ High

Janarthanan et al.22

Support Vector Machine (SVM), Naive Bayes (NB), Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA)

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ High

✘ low

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ low

✔ Average

✘ High

Felfeliyan et al.23

CycleGAN

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ High

✘ low

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✘ High

✔ Average

✔ High

✘ less

✘ High

Viekash et al.24

CNN

✔ Average

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ low

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✔ Average

✔ Average

 

✔ Average

✘ High

Yan et al.25

Regression methods and heatmaps

✔ Average

✘ High

  

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✘ High

✘ High

✘ low

✔ Average

✘ High

Azcona et al.26

Transfer learning

✘ Low

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ low

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ low

✔ Average

✘ High

Supatman et al.27

DCNN

✔ Average

✘ High

✔ Average

✔ Average

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✔ Average

✘ High

✔ Average

✔ Average

✘ High

Zhang et al.28

CNN

✔ Average

✔ Average

✔ Average

✔ Average

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✘ High

✘ High

✔ Average

✔ Average

✘ High

Rahman et al.31

Multi-view CNN

✔ AboveAverage

✔ AboveAverage

✔ Average

✔ Average

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✘ High

✔ Average

✔ Average

✔ Average

✘ High

Pan et al.29

Hierarchical CNN + Segmentation

✘ High

✘ High

✘ High

✘ Low

✔ Average

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ High

✔ Average

✘ High

✘ High

Chen et al.30

Vision Transformer

✘ High

✘ High

✘ High

✘ Low

Not analyzed

Not analyzed

✘ High

✘ High

✘ High

✘ High

✘ High