Table 1 Summary of different models in weather normalization of PM2.5.
Model | Required datasets | Advantages | Disadvantages | Bias in trend | Scopes of application |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CTM | Emission inventories. Meteorology fields. Initial conditions. Boundary conditions. | 4-D simulation results. Physical-chemical mechanisms encoded. | Heavy computation resources. Slow in computation. Accuracy highly depends on the accuracies of inputs. Computer cluster needed. | a | Large spatial scale simulation. Relative shorter study period depends on available resources. |
MLR | Air pollutant observation. Meteorology variables. | Fast in computation. Fewer computation resources. | Address assumptions required for statistical models. Lack of physic-chemical mechanisms. | \({{\rm{PM}}}_{2.5}^{{\rm{EMI}}}\) (13%) \({{\rm{PM}}}_{2.5}^{{\rm{MET}}}\) (66%) | Site (city) or grid scales. Relative longer study period depends on observation data. |
KZ-MLR | Air pollutant observation. Meteorology variables. | Fast in computation. Fewer computation resources. | Address assumptions required for statistical models. Lack of physical-chemical mechanisms. | \({{\rm{PM}}}_{2.5}^{{\rm{EMI}}}\) (23%) \({{\rm{PM}}}_{2.5}^{{\rm{MET}}}\) (79%) | Site (city) or grid scales. Relative longer study period depends on observation data. |
RF | Air pollutant observation. Meteorology variables. | Fast in computation. Medium computation resources. | Lack of physical-chemical mechanisms. Performances depend on hyperparameters | \({{\rm{PM}}}_{2.5}^{{\rm{EMI}}}\) (3%) \({{\rm{PM}}}_{2.5}^{{\rm{MET}}}\) (29%) | Site (city) or grid scales. Relative longer study period depends on observation data. |
XGB | Air pollutant observation. Meteorology variables. | Fast in computation. Medium computation resources. | Lack of physical-chemical mechanisms. Performances depend on hyperparameters | \({{\rm{PM}}}_{2.5}^{{\rm{EMI}}}\) (3%) \({{\rm{PM}}}_{2.5}^{{\rm{MET}}}\) (28%) | Site (city) or grid scales. Relative longer study period depends on observation data. |