Table 1 Summary literature of pre-prohibition era
From: A rapid narrative review of the clinical evolution of psychedelic treatment in clinical trials
Study | Patient demographics | Treated disorder(s) | Psychedelic used/dosage | Therapy type | Treatment duration | Control group | Outcome measures |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Whitaker31 | N = 100 (f = 49) | Wide of treatment-resistant conditions, including schizophrenia, recurrent depression, and personality disorders | LSD (100–250 μg) | LSD integrated with unspecified psychotherapy | Varied number of LSD and psychotherapy sessions. | Yes | Symptoms reported by patient, and clinical assessment by therapist |
Kast59 | N = 128 | Terminal metastatic malignant disease | LSD (100 μg) | None | One LSD session | None | Pain intensity, affective changes, approach to illness and death, sleep patterns, visual distortions/hallucinations, fear/panic reactions |
Chwelos et al.21 | N = 24, N = 16 | Alcoholism, with character disorders, psychopaths, borderline, or actual psychoses | LSD (200–400 μg) at times mescaline (200 μg or more) | LSD session followed by AA meetings | One LSD session, and a few integration sessions, all in one week | None | Reduction in alcohol consumption |
Chandler & Hartman11 | N = 110 (f = 48) Age: 15–62 | Psychoneurosis, addiction, personality, and sociopathic disorders | LSD-25, baseline dosages 25 μg or 50 μg or larger in later sessions | LSD session is a facilitating agent in psychotherapy | 7–8 LSD sessions (each 4–4.5 h) | None | Therapist clinical assessment based on patients’ subjective reports |
Smith32 | N = 24 | Alcoholism, psychopathy, and character disorders | LSD (200–400 μg) or mescaline | Psychotherapy aided by occupational and recreational therapy, LSD sessions as an adjunct | One LSD or mescaline session 2–4 weeks after initial treatment, follow-up 2 months to 3 years. | None | Alcoholics Anonymous assessments of alcohol consumption |
Lewis & Sloane9 | N = 23 (f = 8) Age: 18–64 | Primarily obsessional illness, but few additional disorders | LSD (25–500 μg) | LSD sessions once or twice a week with psychodynamics interpretation | Few weeks to 4 months of LSD sessions. In some cases regular psychotherapy for up to a year | None | Therapist clinical assessment of symptoms |
Eisner & Cohen46 | N = 22 | Neurotic depressions, anxiety states, character disorders, borderline schizophrenia | LSD 100–150 μg) increased incrementally. | LSD sessions with psychotherapy interpretation | 4–5 weekly LSD sessions with supportive psychotherapy and a follow-up period of 6 to 17 months | None | Therapist clinical assessment of symptoms |
Sandison et al. 25 | N = 36 | Psychoneuroses and related conditions | LSD (25–400 μg) | Psychotherapy aided by LSD sessions | One year with varying durations for individual patient | None | Improvement in psychoneurotic symptoms, recovery of repressed memories, mental state |
Sandison24 | N = 36 | Neuroses, obsessional neurotics, depressive states | LSD (25–400 μg) | LSD-assisted psychotherapy, with Jungian analytical psychology | Use of LSD over 8 months | None | Improvement in recovery of repressed memories, changes in mental states, increase in patient’s faith, and in their artistic inclination |
Jensen10 | N = 45 | Alcoholism | LSD (200 μg) | Inpatient individual and group therapy along with AA program, and a few LSD sessions | 8 weeks treatment with 1 LSD session at the end. Follow up 6–18 months | Yes | Alcohol consumption – abstinence |
Smart et al.55 | N = 30 (f = 2) | Alcoholism | LSD (800 μg), or ephedrine (60 mg) | Inpatient treatment and one LSD/ephedrine session | One LSD /ephedrine session a week before the end of the treatment program | Yes | Duration and frequency of abstinence |
Alnæs30 | N = 20 patients N = 20 control All Females | neurosis, anxiety, compulsive neuroses | LSD (25–500 μg) with either Psilocybin (20–30 mg) or CZ-74 | Psychoanalytically-oriented therapy with either psycholytic or psychedelic - peak sessions. | Varied number of LSD sessions as needed | None | A questionnaire evaluating changes in consciousness |
Busch & Johnson45 | N = 8 (4 Inpatient) | Mainly schizophrenia, psychoneurosis, and other disorders | LSD (30–40 μg) | Patients who had ongoing psychotherapy were chosen for one LSD session. | One LSD session (each 4–8 h) | None | Clinical assessment of an individual’s capacity to manage emotions, access memories, and cultivate insights concerning childhood trauma |
Pahnke84 | N > 300 | Alcoholism, neuroses, narcotic, addiction, psychological distress (cancer patients) | LSD (200–450 µg) Dosages varied based on psychotherapy. | Psycholytic therapy, psychedelic-chemotherapy, and psychedelic-peak therapy | Varied, some studies had multiple sessions over a long term | Yes | Subjective improvement, Psychological and social measures, psychedelics safety measure in cancer patients |
MacLean et al.60 | N = 100 (f = 34; 61 alcoholics) | Alcoholism, anxiety reaction neurosis, personality trait disturbances | LSD (400–1500 μg) | Psychedelic therapy – the inpatient LSD session is the primary vehicle for personality change | One LSD session followed 2- days preparatory time, follow-up 3–18 months | None | Improvement in alcoholism and psychiatric conditions |
Sherwood et al.85 | N = 25 (f = 10) | Variety, including neurosis, alcoholism, marital problems | LSD (100–200 µg) with mescaline (200– 400 mg) | Psychedelic-assisted therapy with a focus on the subject’s intention and willingness to engage | Preparation time: 2–3 weeks, LSD/mescaline sessions over few months | None | Patient report, clinical assessment |
Leary et al.29 | N = 175 | No specific disorder | Psilocybin (12–20 mg) | Group setting with informal discussions and Q&A sessions prior to the psychedelic session. | Not discussed | None | Impact of psychedelics experiences on pleasantness, learning, positive life changes, and interpersonal dimensions reported by patients and assessed by clinician. |
Johnson48 | N = 95 | Alcoholism | LSD (300–500 µg) | Inpatient LSD session, and outpatient individual and group therapy sessions | One LSD session, follow-up of 12 months. Therapy included pre- and post-LSD interviews | Yes | Clinician assessment of LSD efficacy in facilitating positive transference and cementing patient-therapist rapport, and overall effect on personality modification |
Mogar & Savag12 | N = 70 (f = 27) | Primarily psychoneurotics and personality trait disturbances | LSD (200–300 µg) plus mescaline (200–400mg) | Preparation of weekly inhalations of 30% CO2 and 70% O2, then LSD/mescaline psychedelic therapy | 1 month of preparation, then one LSD/mescaline session, follow-up evaluations 2 & 6 months post-LSD | Not clear | Measures of changes in personality Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI), value-belief Q-Sort, the Interpersonal Check List (ICL), and a semi structured Behavior Change Interview (BCI), and report of changes by patients |
Stockings14 | Age: 20–30 | Effects of Mescaline which resembles psychotic states | Mescaline synthetic (200–500 mg) | No Therapy | Not applicable | None | Assessment of hallucinations, delusions, mood, thought patterns, motor disturbances, intellectual disturbance by patients report and clinician |
Ditman et al.13 | N = 99 | Alcoholism | Three groups: 1. LSD (200 µg) 2. Methylphenidate (75 mg) 3. Chlordiazepoxide (75 mg) | Doctors and volunteers support the process. Orientation before the dosing for each group. | Single drug session | None | Prior and after the LSD session, patient reports on a 5-point scale on: 1. Pleasant emotion; 2. self-understanding; 3. Mystical feeling; 4. Parapsychological sensation; 5. Sensory and perceptual alternations; 6. Unpleasant emotion 7. Evaluation of the experience |