Table 3 Probabilistic cost-effectiveness results compared to no treatment using list prices.

From: Cost-effectiveness of anti-vascular endothelial growth factor and macular laser treatments for people with centre-involving diabetic macular oedema and central retinal thickness of at least 400 micrometres

Strategy

Total cost per person

Total QALYsa per person

ICER

NMBb [95% CI]

at £20,000 per QALY

Rankedc by NMB

Rankedd by NMB

No treatment

£3,822

8.503

-

£166,238

[£152,957 – £180,234]

5

8

Subthreshold micropulse laser

£4,458

8.944

£1,442

£174,414

[£160,952 – £187,227]

2

1

Standard threshold laser

£4,919

8.928

£2,579

£173,646

[£159,605 – £187,244]

3

3

Bevacizumab

£9,308

9.211

£7,746

£174,916

[£161,429 – £187,533]

1

2

Bevacizumab plus standard threshold laser

£11,325

9.211

£10,593

£172,899

[£159,168 – £186,269]

4

4

Ranibizumab biosimilar (Ongavia)

£23,252

9.225

£26,276

£161,251

[£147,381 – £174,920]

6

5

Ranibizumab (Lucentis)

£24,039

9.224

£28,054

£160,434

[£146,828 – £174,059]

8

10

Ranibizumab (Ongavia) plus standard threshold laser

£24,164

9.210

£28,073

£160,043

[£146,307 – £173,534]

9

7

Brolucizumab

£24,348

9.268

£26,824

£161,016

[£147,669 – £173,755]

7

6

Ranibizumab (Lucentis) plus standard threshold laser

£24,904

9.209

£29,878

£159,268

[£145,571 – £172,882]

10

12

Faricimab

£33,979

9.271

£39,250

£151,448

[£137,073 – £164,968]

11

11

Aflibercept

£34,522

9.267

£40,196

£150,813

[£136,809 – £164,845]

12

9

  1. a QALYs were calculated by multiplying the time spent in a health state by the corresponding utility value for that state, while adjusting for utility losses due to adverse events associated with the treatment.
  2. b NMB was calculated using the formula [(QALYs x £20,000) – Cost]; the strategy having the highest NMB considered the most cost-effective.
  3. c The ranking is based on the list prices.
  4. d The ranking is based on the confidential patient access scheme prices available to NICE for aflibercept, brolucizumab, faricimab, ranibizumab (Lucentis) and ranibizumab biosimilar (Ongavia). These prices and the results using them cannot be disclosed due to confidentiality agreements
  5. ICER incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, NMB net monetary benefit, QALYs quality-adjusted life years.