Introduction

Given the ubiquity of alkenes in feedstock chemicals and natural products, the development of new catalytic strategies for difunctionalization of the double bonds has been an area of intense research in organic chemistry1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8. Specifically, the stereoselective heterodifunctionalization of alkenes is a powerful and widely employed tactic for the rapid construction of complex molecular architectures that are particularly valuable in synthetic and medicinal applications9,10,11,12. In this context, the asymmetric cyanoesterification of alkenes is highly desirable in the synthetic community, because two synthetically versatile functional groups—the ester and cyano groups are installed across the double bond in a single operational step. More importantly, such a methodology grants access to synthetic intermediates that are readily converted into a wide range of valuable chiral building blockings, including β-substituted-γ-aminobutyric acids (GABA) and pertinent structures in medicinally relevant compounds (Fig. 1A)13,14,15. Despite significant efforts in developing innovative methods for the practical synthesis of chiral GABA derivatives16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25, the direct utilization of more readily available alkenes as substrates for asymmetric cyanoesterification remains largely unexplored.

Fig. 1: Background information and our electrochemical method for the preparation of chiral β-cyano esters.
figure 1

A Selected drug molecules derived from chiral β-cyano esters. B Synthesis of chiral β-cyano carbonyls with cyclopropanols. C Synthesis of chiral β-cyano carbonyls with styrenes. D This Work: electrochemical Cu-catalyzed asymmetric cyanoesterification of vinylarenes. SET single-electron transfer.

The incorporation of single-electron strategies into asymmetric transition metal catalysis has equipped chemists with innovative retrosynthetic approaches for solving challenging synthetic problems by harnessing highly reactive open-shell species26,27,28,29. As a particularly elegant example, copper-catalyzed asymmetric radical cyanation of carbon-centered radicals has achieved notable success in synthesizing enantiomerically enriched alkyl nitriles30,31,32,33,34. Directly related to the present work, the Liu group devised an efficient protocol for the asymmetric cyanation of cyclopropanols by copper-catalyzed radical relay processes, providing β-cyano esters with excellent enantioselectivity (Fig. 1B)35. In addition, carbonyl radicals including acyl, alkoxycarbonyl, and carbamoyl radicals, generated by single-electron activation or hydrogen atom abstraction of the aldehydic C(sp2)–H bonds, have been successfully applied in radical-based transformations36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43. For instance, Chen, Xiao, and co-workers reported the photoredox copper-catalyzed asymmetric acylcyanation of styrenes using redox-active oxime esters as the acyl radical precursors. Photoredox-mediated single-electron transfer (SET) of oxime esters produced the key nitrogen-centered iminyl radicals that triggered C–C bond cleavage to deliver the required acyl radicals for the reaction44. However, the use of pre-functionalized substrates for the generation of carbonyl radicals could reduce the practicality of the catalytic system (Fig. 1C).

Recently, we and others have demonstrated electrochemical transition metal catalysis as a viable and potentially general synthetic platform for the innovation of radical-based transformations that are often elusive or currently impossible using existing methods45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52. Enabled by the unique attributes of this strategy, redox reactions are frequently realized in a more sustainable, efficient, and chemo-selective manner53,54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61,62,63,64,65,66,67. Based on our previous investigation of the electrochemical iron-catalyzed azidoesterification of alkenes68, we envisioned that an enantioselective variant of cyanoesterification of vinyl arenes might be accessible via the synergistic merger of electrochemical iron catalysis and asymmetric copper catalysis69,70,71. In the proposed mechanistic pathways, electrochemical iron catalysis is designed to promote oxidative production of alkoxycarbonyl radical 1 from the commercially available carbazates68,72. After that, the radical addition to the vinylarene would generate a more thermodynamically stable benzylic radical 2. Taking the advantage of electrochemistry to accommodate multiple concurrent redox events at the same electrode, anodic oxidation could also lead to the formation of a Cu(II)–CN complex 3, which would intercept the newly generated benzylic radical. The resulting Cu(III)–CN adduct is expected to undergo stereoselective reductive elimination to forge the desired C–CN bond with the aid of an appropriate chiral ligand (Fig. 1D)73,74,75,76,77,78,79,80.

In this work, we report an electrochemical copper-catalyzed protocol for the asymmetric cyanoesterification of vinylarenes. Notable features of this electrocatalytic strategy are as follows: 1) direct use of readily accessible reagents for the preparation of synthetically versatile chiral β-cyano esters from vinylarenes; 2) excellent chemoselectivity, stereoselectivity, and good functional group tolerance without the need for stoichiometric chemical oxidants; 3) good scalability for synthetic applications and has been successfully demonstrated in the efficient synthesis of drug molecules.

Results and discussion

Optimization of reaction conditions

We set out to explore the feasibility of our reaction design in the asymmetric cyanoesterification of 2-vinylnaphthalene 4 with methyl carbazate 5 and TMSCN by the combinational use of iron phthalocyanine (PcFe) (5 mol%) and Cu(OTf)2 (1.0 mol%) together with a commercial bisoxazoline ligand 6 (3.0 mol%)81 in a simple and practical undivided cell under constant current conditions. We were delighted to find that the reaction indeed occurred to give the corresponding cyanoesterification product 7 in a promising yield with excellent enantioselectivity (Table 1, entry 1). However, further reaction conditions optimization and control experiments led to the discovery that the reaction proceeded smoothly without the need for iron catalysis, the desired cyanoesterification product could be obtained in an isolated yield of 80% with 92% ee when the reaction was performed at room temperature using Cu(OTf)2/6 as the catalyst (entry 2). Our investigation into the ratio of copper to the chiral ligand revealed that a 1:3 ratio is optimal for the reaction efficiency. Efforts to decrease the ligand loading proved unsuccessful, primarily due to the reduction of copper ion to plate out on the cathode, which was visibly observed upon reaction completion (entry 3). Replacing acetic acid (AcOH) with trifluoroethanol (TFE) seriously caused the undesired copper reduction issue; the alkene was fully consumed to form various side products (entry 4). We employed Pt as the cathode to ensure facile proton reduction to outcompete copper reduction. Therefore, as expected, the substitution of the Pt cathode with an iron resulted in an acceptable but reduced yield (entry 5). These results underscored the pivotal role of the proton source selection, the copper-to-ligand ratio, and the employment of Pt as the cathode for maximizing the electrocatalytic efficiency of the copper catalyst in the reaction. Modifying the current density or running the reaction with a constant cell potential led to suboptimal results but has no obvious effect on the stereoselectivity of the reaction (entries 6–8).

Table 1 Reaction discovery and optimization[a]

Substrate scope

With the optimized reaction conditions in hand, we next evaluated the scope of vinylarenes that can be employed in this new asymmetric cyanoesterification protocol. As illustrated in Fig. 2, a diverse array of vinylarenes successfully underwent the desired oxidative three-component coupling with good to excellent reaction efficiency (723, 48–80% yield, 81–98% ee), yielding chiral β-cyano esters featuring a broad spectrum of functional groups, including ethers (8, 13), halides (1517, 2023), and esters (19) that can be utilized for further diversification. In particular, vinylarenes with electron-rich groups such as the methoxy group that might generate the corresponding benzylic radicals with very low oxidation potentials for the formation of benzylic cation intermediates were competent substrates (13), demonstrating the mild nature of our electrocatalytic protocol. In addition, sulfide (14) that was supposed to be vulnerable to traditional chemical oxidation conditions was successfully preserved in the reaction. However, a notable amount of hydroesterification side product was observed in reactions involving styrenes with electron-withdrawing groups at the para position of the phenyl ring (18 and 19). We hypothesize that the corresponding benzylic radical intermediates are more susceptible to hydrogen atom transfer, leading to the formation of these side products. Styrenes featuring a substituent at the ortho position were found to be compatible substrates for the reaction; the ortho substituent appears to enhance stereocontrol but negatively impacts the reaction yield (20, 21). Notably, the benzyl chloride (23) that could potentially undergo nucleophilic substitution by AcO or CN in the reaction system, was also tolerated. Encouraged by the compatibility of the catalytic system to electron-rich substrates, we next examined the preparation of products 24 and 25, with the later as the key intermediate for the synthesis of an anti-depressant drug (R)-rolipram (vide infra); both of the desired products were obtained from the corresponding vinylarenes with good reaction results.

Fig. 2: Scope of the electrochemical copper-catalyzed asymmetric cyanoesterification.
figure 2

All yields are of isolated products. Unless otherwise noted, reaction conditions were as follows: alkene (0.15 mmol, 1.0 equiv), TMSCN (2.0 equiv), 5 (2.0 equiv), Cu(OTf)2/6 (1.0/3.0 mol %), TBAPF6 (2.0 equiv), AcOH (1.0 mmol), MeCN (3.0 mL), carbon felt as the anode, Pt as the cathode, under N2, in an undivided cell, 9.0 mA, for 4 h.

Next, we turned our attention to determining the tolerance of this electrocatalytic system to heteroaromatic rings that are commonly found in pharmaceutically relevant compounds. Remarkably, an array of electron-rich and electron-deficient heterocycles, including pyridine (26), benzothiophene (27, 28), benzofuran (29), and indole (30) were transformed to the corresponding products in good yields with good to excellent enantioselectivities (56–78% yield, 80–94% ee). In addition to styrenes, enynes also underwent chemoselective alkene cyanoesterification to yield the desired products with good enantioselectivities (3133). Finally, we found that this electrocatalytic protocol could also be effectively applied to the functionalization of biologically active derivatives—styrenes derived from L-menthol (34), diacetonefructose (35), indometacin (36), gemfibrozil (37), and bezafibrate (38) proved to be viable substrates, affording the cyanoesterification adducts in synthetically useful yields with good stereocontrol.

Synthetic applications

For practical applications, we explored the scalability of this electrocatalytic asymmetric cyanoesterification protocol and found that it could be successfully scaled up to gram level under constant current conditions using a lower copper catalyst loading. The desired product was obtained with excellent stereoselectivity, albeit with a decreased yield (Fig. 3A). Attempts to improve the reaction yield through reactor design to address the possible mass transport issue are continuing in our laboratory. The synthesized product can be efficiently converted into the corresponding diacid compound 39, potentially useful in polymer synthesis82,83,84,85, without any loss of stereoselectivity. Moreover, the chiral β-cyano ester can be readily transformed into chiral γ-lactam 40 and γ-amino alcohol 41 with favorable reaction yields using well-established reduction methods. To further highlight the utility of our asymmetric electrocatalytic cyanoesterification method, we applied this protocol to the synthesis of pharmacologically active molecules. For example, when chiral β-cyano ester product 25 was subjected to the nickel-mediated reduction, the corresponding reductive cyclization product 42, an anti-depressant drug could be obtained with acceptable reaction efficiency. In the case of chiral β-cyano ester product 16, reductive cyclization followed by hydrolysis gave γ-amino acid product 43, which is an inhibitory neurotransmitter and is used to treat pain and certain types of spasticity (Fig. 3B).

Fig. 3: Large-scale synthesis and synthetic applications.
figure 3

A Large scale synthesis. B Product derivatization and application to the synthesis of bioactive molecules. For details, see the Supplementary Information.

Mechanistic studies

To elucidate the reaction mechanism, a series of experiments were designed and performed (Fig. 4). Cyclic voltammetry analysis indicated that the direct anodic oxidation of methyl carbazate 5 at the carbon electrode commenced with an onset potential of approximately 0.25 V (with reference to the ferrocenium ion/ferrocene redox couple in MeCN). The anodic oxidation of Cu(I)–CN to the corresponding Cu(II)–CN species in the presence of the chiral ligand, however, resulted in a feature at around 0 V (Fig. 4A). To ascertain whether the anodically generated Cu(II)–CN species could promote the oxidative fragmentation of methyl carbazate for the reaction, we conducted controlled anodic potential electrolysis at 0 V that is not sufficient to directly oxidize methyl carbazate 5, but we still observed the formation of product 7 in 15% yield with 92% ee (Fig. 4B). These data are consistent with a unique mechanistic scenario in which the copper catalyst plays a dual role: it is responsible not only for the stereoselective formation of the C–CN bond but also serves as a redox mediator that facilitates the oxidative fragmentation of methyl carbazate 5, leading to the generation of the methoxycarbonyl radical in the reaction86,87.

Fig. 4: Mechanistic studies and proposal.
figure 4

A Cyclic voltammetry studies. B Controlled potential electrolysis experiment. C Radical probe experiment. D Proposed catalytic cycles. For details, see the Supplementary Information.

In addition, a radical addition-trigged rearrangement experiment with cyclopropane-derived alkene 44 was performed to provide key support for the intermediacy of carbon-centered radical species in the reaction (Fig. 4C). Specifically, upon formation of the first C–C bond via homolysis of the double bond with alkoxycarbonyl radical, the resultant carbon-centered radical 45 would render ring rupture of the cyclopropyl group, leading to the generation of a more thermodynamically stable benzylic radical intermediate 46. This intermediate then enters the Cu-catalyzed asymmetric cyanation cycle to give the desired product via stereoselective reductive elimination from the putative Cu(III)–CN complex.

Taken together, we proposed an electrochemical copper-catalyzed mechanism for this novel asymmetric cyanoesterification reaction. As shown in Fig. 4D, the generation of methoxycarbonyl radical 48 from methyl carbazate was mediated by anodically generated L-Cu(II)–CN species in our catalytic system. Then, radical addition to vinylarene substrate produced the relatively more stable benzylic radical intermediate 49. Subsequently, radical oxidative addition to L-Cu(II)–CN to form the putative alkyl Cu(III)–CN species, which after reductive elimination forged the desired C–CN bond to furnish the final product along with the regeneration of L-Cu(I) for the next catalytic cycle.

In summary, we have established a sustainable and robust strategy for the direct and efficient preparation of chiral β-cyano esters from readily available vinylarenes and commercially available reagents with a low copper catalyst loading under electrochemical conditions. The electrochemical copper catalysis enabled the generation and utilization of the key alkoxycarbonyl radicals from alkyl carbazates in a controlled and sustainable manner and also imparted stereoselectivity control over the construction of C–CN bonds in the presence of a commercial chiral ligand. This electrocatalytic difunctionalization method exhibited excellent chemoselectivity, stereoselectivity, and high functional group tolerance, and can be successfully scaled up for preparative synthesis. We have demonstrated the utility of this protocol through the preparation of drug molecules. Given the generality and the synthetic potential of both the ester and cyano groups in the obtained products, we anticipate this new electrochemical copper-catalyzed cyanoesterification protocol will find broad applications in both synthetic and medicinal chemistry.

Methods

General procedure for cyanoesterification of vinylarenes

Solution A: Prior to use, Cu(OTf)2 (3.3 mg, 0.009 mmol) and ligand 6 (9.6 mg, 0.027 mmol) were combined stirred for 3 min in MeCN (6 mL) under a nitrogen atmosphere. Subsequently, TMSCN (96% wt, 186 mg, 1.8 mmol) was added, and the mixture was stirred continuously for an additional hour.

An oven-dried, 10 mL two-neck glass tube was equipped with a magnetic stir bar, a rubber septum, a threaded Teflon cap fitted with electrical feed-throughs, a carbon-felt anode (0.5 × 1.0 × 1.4 cm3) (connected to the electrical feedthrough via a 9 cm in length, 2 mm in diameter graphite rod), and a platinum plate cathode (0.5 × 1.0 cm2). To this reaction vessel was added methyl carbazate 5 (97% wt, 28 mg, 0.3 mmol, 2.0 equiv), tetrabutylammonium hexafluorophosphate (116 mg, 0.3 mmol). The cell was sealed and flushed with nitrogen gas for 5 min, followed by the sequential addition via syringe of solution A (1 mL), olefin substrate (0.15 mmol, 1.0 equiv), AcOH (60 mg, 1.0 mmol), and CH3CN (2 mL). The reaction mixture was then purged with nitrogen gas for another 5 min. A nitrogen-filled balloon was adapted through the septum to sustain a nitrogen atmosphere. Electrolysis was initiated at a constant current of 9 mA at room temperature. After 4 h, the tube cap was removed and electrodes were rinsed with ethyl acetate, which was combined with the crude mixture and the organic layers were concentrated in vacuo. The residue was subjected to flash column chromatography on silica gel (eluted with petroleum ether/EA) to yield the purified product.