The mammalian liver circadian clock

The mammalian circadian system is a network of cellular clocks that coordinates the timing of internal physiological processes in anticipation of daily recuring environmental changes. Nearly every organ and cell in the body harbours a circadian clock. Together, these clocks are organised to produce coherent, ~24-h tissue-level oscillations. In mammals, the central circadian pacemaker is localised in the bilateral suprachiasmatic nuclei (SCN) of the hypothalamus and receives input about environmental light directly from the retina. The SCN clock entrains to the light-dark cycle and then coordinates the timing, or phases, of tissue clocks located throughout the brain and body1,2. Importantly, while the molecular building blocks of the clock are largely preserved across tissues, each tissue clock entrains with a different temporal relationship to the light-dark cycle3,4. The putative value of this circadian organisation is that it temporally partitions behaviour and tissue-specific gene expression and biochemistry so that internal processes anticipate predictable changes in the environment, such as food availability and predation, caused by Earth’s rotation on its axis5 (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1: Circadian coordination of liver metabolism.
figure 1

A circadian pacemaker in the hypothalamic suprachiasmatic nuclei (SCN) is reset by the external light-dark cycle. Through temporal regulation of behavioural functions such as the sleep-wake cycle or feeding-fasting rhythms, endocrine outputs and the autonomic nervous system (ANS), the SCN clock controls the timing of cellular clocks in hepatocytes (and other central and peripheral tissues). At the molecular level, these clocks are comprised of interlocked transcriptional-translational feedback loops (TTFLs) of clock genes and proteins characterised by marked 24-h rhythms in transcriptional activity and protein abundance. In the liver, local clock rhythms and internal (e.g., hormones) and external circadian inputs (e.g., meal schedules) are integrated to generate metabolic clock outputs such as glycogen storage/release, bile acid and triglyceride biosynthesis.

The liver is arguably the most well-studied peripheral circadian clock in mammals. It responds dynamically to feeding and fasting cycles and, when nutrients are abundant, it stores energy as glycogen, triglycerides and proteins. Conversely, during periods of fasting or increased energy demand, the liver mobilises energy reserves. Most liver functions have 24-h rhythms to anticipate periods of energy supply and demands. In addition to regulating daily cycles of nutrients, the liver also rhythmically metabolises bile acids, amino acids, toxins and drugs (for reviews see refs. 6,7). Circadian rhythms in liver function are regulated in part by the molecular circadian timekeeping mechanism. The molecular clock in mammals is based on a set of transcriptional-translational negative feedback loop. The circadian protein BMAL1 heterodimerizes with CLOCK (or NPAS2 in some tissues) to drive the transcription of Period (Per1, 2, 3) and Cryptochrome (Cry1, 2) genes. As PER and CRY proteins are translated, they dimerise, translocate into the nucleus and feedback on BMAL1/CLOCK to inhibit their own transcription. This cycle takes approximately 24 h to complete and thus sets the pace of cellular circadian clocks. An additional accessory feedback loops contribute to cellular timekeeping. For example, the BMAL1/CLOCK regulated nuclear receptors ROR (α, γ, β) and REV-ERB (α, β) activate and inhibit the expression of Bmal1 and Clock, respectively, and contribute to fine tune the time keeping system8 (Fig. 1).

Meal timing also regulates circadian rhythms in liver gene expression and function. Consequently, perturbing the daily rhythm of food intake has a strong impact on the organisation of the rhythmic liver clock and physiology9,10,11,12,13,14. When feeding is restricted to the inactive phase, the phases of circadian clocks in peripheral tissues involved in energy metabolism, including the liver, white adipose tissue (WAT), and gut, entrain to feeding time independently of the central circadian clock and other non-metabolic tissues clocks15,16. This results in, both, internal (liver, gut etc. vs. SCN) and external circadian misalignment (liver, gut vs. light-dark cycle)17.

While mechanisms are still not entirely clear, food-borne metabolites and postprandial hormone signals such as insulin, oxyntomodulin, glucagon-like peptide 1 and leptin can act as “zeitgebers” (German word for “time giver”) for circadian clocks in peripheral organs and parts of the brain18,19,20,21. Other factors more prevalent during fasting phases (e.g., during sleep), such as fatty acids or glucagon, may act as pre-feeding signals to reset peripheral clocks22,23. Additionally, feeding is associated with an increase in body movements that contribute to the rhythmic body temperature15,24,25 that, in turn, may act as a synchroniser of the peripheral circadian clocks26,27,28,29 (Fig. 1).

In sum, ~24-h rhythms of liver functions are controlled by both the molecular circadian timekeeping mechanism in hepatocytes and by systemic factors, particularly those related to food intake. Thus, the liver is perfectly poised to anticipate predictable changes in nutrient availability as well as respond to unpredictable metabolic demands.

Disruption of rhythmic liver function is associated with metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD)

Metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD) is defined by an excessive accumulation of lipid in the liver in the presence of at least one cardiometabolic risk factor. MASLD comprises isolated liver steatosis (metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver (MASL)), steatohepatitis (MASH), as well as fibrosis and cirrhosis. The new definition thus highlights the metabolic roots of the disease and its tight association with type 2 diabetes (T2D), obesity and other cardiometabolic risk factors30,31. MASLD is the most common chronic liver disease and its prevalence is projected to increase even further. At least one in four patients with MASLD has MASH, which is the second leading cause of liver disease in adults scheduled for liver transplantation in the USA32. In patients with obesity and T2D, prevalence of MASLD increase two- to fourfold, depending on age and comorbidities33,34.

Progression of liver damage in MASLD is extremely variable. Whereas simple steatosis reflects non-progressive dysfunctional metabolism, MASH is a chronic liver disease that may progress undiagnosed for years, before eventually emerging as liver failure and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). The earliest event initiating MASLD is absolute or relative calorie excess, as confirmed by the link between MASLD and obesity. Limited physical activity or sedentary behaviours are complementary aspects of calorie imbalance, irrespective of body mass index35. As triglyceride synthesis outpaces the capacity for VLDL synthesis and export, triglycerides accumulate within hepatocytes, resulting in steatosis and eventually lipotoxicity36. Additional increased de novo lipogenesis from carbohydrates, specifically fructose, may produce similar lipotoxic effects. Moreover, consumption of sugar-sweetened drinks containing either fructose or sucrose, which is converted to fructose and glucose in the gut, may be more potent than dietary lipids in promoting MASH37,38. Uncontrolled and incomplete lipid oxidation, oxidative stress and activation of the unfolded protein response are two well characterised pathways that promote cell death in MASH. These multiple insults synergistically drive the development and progression of MASLD, particularly in genetically predisposed people.

Increasing evidence suggests an association between MASLD and the perturbation of the daily rhythms in liver physiology, also called circadian disruption. Liver physiology has been studied in rodent models with circadian disruption including light at night39,40, forced work during the resting phase mimicking shift work41, chronic shifts of the light-dark cycle42,43,44, and genetic disruption of molecular clock function in hepatocytes43,45,46. These animal studies demonstrated that circadian disruption causes fatty liver and MASLD. However, recent studies suggest a more contrasted conclusion. In contrast to hepatocyte-specific circadian clock disruption, disabling the molecular clock in the entire animal47,48,49 or in the intestinal epithelium50 protects mice from MASLD and MASH. While the mechanism is not clear, it likely involves perturbations of circadian clock-dependent endocrine regulation and/or nutrient storage that decrease lipid storage and steatosis in the liver and, consequently, the associated fibrosis and inflammation.

In humans, clinical data are still lacking that document a tight link between disruption of liver circadian rhythms and MASLD/MASH. Recent studies of liver biopsies collected at different times of the daily cycle showed that rhythmic gene expression, including circadian clock gene expression, is disrupted in patients with HCC51. Moreover, increased liver fibrosis severity in human was associated with a decreased expression of circadian clock genes48. Another recent report shows that while livers from MASH patients do not have altered expression of circadian clock genes, the time-of-day-dependent expression of hundreds of transcripts involved in cell-to-cell communication, intracellular signalling and energy metabolism were altered52. Amino acid and lipid metabolome rhythms were also altered suggesting that MASH modulates output rhythms. Similarly, circadian disruption caused by chronic jet lag in a “humanised liver” mouse model in which mouse hepatocytes were partially replaced by human hepatocytes led to MASH and HCC with characteristics similar to the human diseases44. Altogether, these studies suggest that perturbation of rhythmic liver physiology is associated with the development of MASLD.

The relationship between circadian disruption and MASLD is further supported by studies of MASLD in shift workers. One study of >8000 shift workers showed no association with MASLD53. However, a more recent study of >6000 rotating and night shift workers in China showed that longer duration of shift work and extended nighttime work hours increased the risk of MASLD by 23%54. In a comparable study of male shift workers, night shift work was associated with elevated alanine transaminase levels, which is a marker of hepatic pathology55. In a large-scale, retrospective analysis of UK Biobank data, night shift work was associated with MASLD, and the risk increased as years of night shift work increased56. Moreover, irregular schedules of shift work and extreme late chronotype were also associated with elevated liver steatosis57. These results are summarised in Table 1. Interestingly, there is an association between the risk of HCC (and other types of cancer, even in the absence of cirrhosis) and geographical location in a time zone58,59. Those in the Western portion of a time zone have greater HCC risk, possibly because they experience more circadian disruption caused by delayed exposure to sunlight.

Table 1 Overview of the studies reporting the impact of shift work on MASLD

Another highly prevalent condition with chronodisruptive potential and an impact on liver steatosis is sleep apnoea. Obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) is characterised by recurring obstruction of the upper airways during sleep. This results in sub-optimal ventilation and intermittent hypoxia which promotes arousal and reduces overall sleep quality60 and alters circadian activity rhythms61. Mounting evidence suggests OSA and chronic intermittent hypoxia (CIH) are risk factors for MASLD62,63,64. In MASLD patients with OSA, CIH triggers an increase in oxidative stress and generation of reactive oxygen species, release of pro-inflammatory cytokines, and induction of systemic inflammation, which further exacerbate liver steatosis and inflammation65. In addition, OSA in a mouse model is associated with tissue-specific transcriptomic changes in circadian rhythmicity and mean 24-h gene expression levels66. Moreover, hypoxic events themselves act as synchronising stimuli for some tissue clocks. Such tissue-specific responses to OSA-associated hypoxic intervals may provoke circadian tissue clock misalignment (or internal desynchrony) reminiscent of what is observed in animal models of shift work67.

These observations support the hypothesis that high amplitude circadian rhythms protect against the development of liver disease. Accordingly, restoring rhythmic feeding in animals during high-fat (HFD) obesogenic regimen with time-restricted feeding68,69 or synchronising the clock using small molecules targeting the ROR/REV-ERB pathway improves MASLD in mice70,71,72. However, in clinical trials, time-restricted feeding was no more effective than caloric restriction in treating obesity and MASLD73,74,75,76.

MASLD and cirrhosis are related to disrupted circadian physiology and sleep

Research on obesity and MASLD has shown that there are reciprocal connections between metabolic liver disease and circadian physiology. Chronic consumption of HFD, which leads to MASLD in mice77, alters circadian physiology and global rhythmic metabolism in mice. HFD consumption disrupts daily rhythms of meal intake and the associated humoral signals, as well as rhythmic gene expression in peripheral tissues including the liver in male mice69,78,79,80,81. During HFD feeding, mice increase their food intake during the light phase, which is the resting phase for nocturnal rodents during which they normally do not eat79. A parallel observation was made in mice carrying a mutation in the circadian Clock gene, which also promotes overweight and obesity82. Genetic animal models of obesity including the mouse Ob and Db mutations of Leptin and its receptor, respectively, also have disrupted eating rhythms83,84,85. The disruption of the eating rhythm by HFD consumption is reversible86 and dependent on sex and strain since female C57BL/6J mice or mouse strains that are resistant to HFD-induced obesity do not have disrupted eating rhythms during HFD feeding87,88.

The SCN circadian pacemaker and circadian entrainment are also affected by HFD consumption in mice. The circadian period of locomotor activity, a direct output of the activity of the SCN clock, is increased during HFD feeding79. Moreover, the response of circadian activity rhythms to a light pulse, a property of the SCN clock, was also altered89. However, these effects are not specific to obesity and metabolic syndrome. Choline-deficient diet, which rapidly induces liver fibrosis with minimum impact on body weight90, causes wide-spread changes liver transcriptome diurnal rhythms including genes associated with lipid metabolism and inflammatory processes91,92. It also advances the phases of the liver and kidney circadian clocks, suggesting an impact on the global circadian physiology91,92.

In humans, the impact of liver diseases on circadian behaviour has been mainly studied in patients with cirrhosis to identify aetiological strategies to manage the sleep-wake disturbances that are common in these patients93 (Fig. 2). Delayed sleep and wake timing, daytime sleepiness, increased sleep latency and interrupted night sleep are more common in patients with cirrhosis than in patients with other chronic diseases (e.g., renal failure requiring dialysis)94,95,96,97. While sleep-wake abnormalities in patients with cirrhosis have traditionally been ascribed to hepatic encephalopathy, they have recently been linked to excessive daytime sleepiness98 and, in its more severe forms, sleep–wake inversion99. Further, the hepatic metabolism of hypnotic drugs is disturbed in cirrhotic patients100 and patients are extremely sensitive to these medications. Therefore, special care must be taken when treating their sleep disturbances. However, the increase in daytime sleepiness also impairs night sleep and the sleep–wake cycle, making difficult to separate in patients the influence of the increased daytime sleep and the perturbed nighttime sleep. Homoeostatic101,102 and circadian abnormalities in sleep–wake regulation have been associated with liver cirrhosis. The latter includes phase delays in the daily rhythms of melatonin103,104 and cortisol105, impaired melatonin responses to light103 and impaired melatonin catabolism106. There is also anecdotal evidence that liver transplantation can reverse sleep disturbances107, suggesting a direct effect of the cirrhotic liver on circadian behaviour. There are other, largely unexplored mechanisms through which cirrhosis, and especially decompensated cirrhosis, might affect the circadian timing system, including endocrine108 and metabolic109 disruptions as well as sympathetic denervation110 potentially affecting the communication with the SCN, abnormal temperature regulation, reduced muscle mass and ability to exercise, and aberrant meal timing (i.e., evening snacking) (reviewed in ref. 7).

Fig. 2: Circadian disruption-MASLD/MASH crosstalk.
figure 2

Circadian disruption is a risk factor for the development of fatty liver disease. It can arise from external factors such as light at night or shift work-associated alterations in sleep-wake cycles or internal factors such as sleep apnoea, clock gene modifications or metabolic dysfunction. Through alterations in oxidative stress, cytokine release and hypoxia, circadian disruption promotes the development of all levels of fatty liver disease—from steatosis to cirrhosis. Vice versa, MASLD/MASH can feed back on circadian regulatory functions through the same pathways, thus generating a vicious cycle of chronometabolic dysfunction.

Clinically, sleep–wake rhythm disturbances are associated with the onset and the worsening of chronic

liver disease and negatively affect quality of life and health95. Observational studies showed that short sleep duration and poor sleep quality were associated with increased risk of MASLD in middle-aged111 and younger people112. A meta-analysis reported increased risk of MASLD in people experiencing insomnia113. Additionally, a study comparing 46 patients with histologically diagnosed MASLD to 22 healthy individuals found that MASLD patients had later sleep onset times, worse sleep quality and shorter sleep duration114. Furthermore, large cohort longitudinal studies support the relationship between sleep disturbances and duration and MASLD115,116. However, it is unknown whether sleep disturbances promote MASLD and how MASLD influences sleep. A recent bidirectional Mendelian randomisation study using genetic and sleep data found that different sleep traits could trigger and foster progression of MASLD, whereas MASLD did not appear to alter sleep traits, thereby rejecting the two-way hypothesis117.

Poor sleep quality and delayed sleep onset could affect metabolic physiology and thereby promote MASLD. Obesity, a risk factor for MASLD, is associated with fragmented daily temperature and sleep rhythms118, as well as changes in endocrine oscillations, e.g., of nocturnal melatonin119,120. Sleep disturbances can also dysregulate hormones such as ghrelin and leptin and the activity of the endocannabinoid system121,122,123. Studies in healthy individuals showed that sleep restriction increases appetite and calorie intake, decreases insulin sensitivity and alters cortisol levels124. MASLD patients are more likely than healthy patients to eat later in the day114 and go to bed later114,125. Furthermore, the combination of late chronotype with poor adherence to a Mediterranean-type diet is associated with advanced liver fibrosis in patients with MASLD126. In a study of 295,837 participants who were followed for 15 years, a U-shaped relationship between duration of sleep and the incidence of HCC and mortality from chronic liver disease was observed127. Excessive daytime sleepiness and longer daytime naps also increases MASLD risk113,128 (Table 2).

Table 2 Overview of the studies reporting the link between MASLD and sleep disruption.

MASLD influences the physiology of peripheral organs and global physiology

Because of its central role in organising metabolism, disruption of the circadian clock is associated with obesity and insulin resistance129,130. In a clinical study, only ten days of circadian misalignment were sufficient to reduce insulin sensitivity131. Thus, insulin resistance caused by circadian disruption could contribute to the development of MASLD by stimulating adipose tissue to expand and release pro-inflammatory adipokines and free fatty acids, leading to systemic inflammation and ectopic fat accumulation132,133. This state of chronic systemic inflammation, also observed in obesity and T2D, is associated with the disruption of the circadian clock in skeletal muscles and WAT134,135, possibly because of the direct interaction between the inflammation-activated transcription factors NF-κB and BMAL1136,137. The relationship between malnutrition or sarcopenia, which is common in decompensated cirrhosis, and circadian disruption has not been well studied. In cirrhosis patients, malnutrition and sarcopenia has been attributed to the combination of abnormalities in nutrients intake, absorption and metabolism138. Albeit reasonable (please refer to ref. 7 for a review), the possibility that it may relate, at least to some extent, to liver clock dysfunction and central-peripheral clock desynchrony has remained untested.

Is the liver a hub between central and peripheral clocks?

The liver integrates rhythmic systemic cues to synchronise its physiology with nutrient cycles and food intake and transmits these signals to other tissues, including the central clock in the SCN2. Accordingly, and as previously discussed, advanced fibrosis is associated with alterations of the activity/sleep cycle and disturbed metabolism in other tissues, potentially through inter-organ communication. There is other evidence that the liver clock communicates with circadian clocks in other organs. For example, WAT and lung circadian clocks cannot entrain properly to feeding rhythms in mice with Bmal1 deleted in hepatocytes139. The liver clock is also necessary and sufficient to integrate feeding signals and restore rhythmic liver physiology in animals otherwise devoid of functional circadian clocks140. Moreover, the reconstituted liver clock in these clock-less mice also communicates with the clocks in skeletal muscles and regulates rhythmic gene expression in muscles140,141. However, the restoration of the rhythmic physiology of these tissues is only partial and functional clocks in both liver and skeletal muscles are required to completely restore glucose metabolism in condition of rhythmic feeding140,141.

The role of the liver in coordinating global physiology in animals with functional circadian systems is less clear. Mice in which mouse hepatocytes were replaced by human hepatocytes were unable to integrate signals from the mouse142. Mice with human hepatocytes had advances liver circadian clocks, similar to clock-less animals with functional circadian clocks restored only in hepatocytes143. Strikingly, this liver phase advance impacted their global physiology. Additionally, mice with human hepatocytes had altered rhythms of gene expression in the SCN and the arcuate nucleus of the hypothalamus. Their capacity to synchronise to daytime feeding was impacted. The humanised mice showed a behaviour similar to that of SCN-lesioned animals142. Considering the similarities in phenotypes, similar mechanisms could be involved in altering the phases of liver clocks in mouse models of liver fibrosis91,92 and in humans with liver cirrhosis93. Thus, it is possible that in MASH or liver cirrhosis, the liver could transmit signals to the hypothalamus to modulate diurnal activity.

The mechanism that could transmit the signal from the pathogenic liver to the brain and other organs remains elusive. One hypothesis is that abnormal circulating factors originating from the liver and specific to MASLD impact the rhythmic physiology of other central and peripheral organs. Accordingly, MASLD leads to perturbed profiles of circulating proteins and metabolites144,145. A recent study shows that disrupting the liver circadian clock by simultaneously deleting Rev-erbα and Rev-erbβ or Bmal1 specifically in hepatocytes of adult mice disrupted their feeding rhythm146. Because deletion of Rev-erbα/β or Bmal1 is associated with disrupted liver physiology139,147,148,149, this condition could recapitulate models of MASLD and mice with “humanised” livers. Surprisingly, the perturbation of the feeding rhythm was lost after vagotomy or ablation of liver vagal afferent neurons, implying a role of the autonomous nervous system (ANS). In addition, the perturbation of the feeding rhythm and body weight gain caused by HFD feeding were mitigated by liver vagotomy146. Together, these data highlight a potential critical role of the ANS in the modulation of SCN activity by the cirrhotic liver, exemplified by the fact that lipid liver accumulation modulates the activity of the ANS via the alteration of direct GABAergic connections150,151. However, this result is at odds with previous publications showing a normal feeding rhythm in hepatocyte Bmal1149,152 and Rev-erbs153 knockout mice. Moreover, this finding must be considered relative to numerous studies that showed that severing the neuronal connection between the liver and the SCN through vagotomy or liver transplantation was sufficient to induce a global loss of the diurnal feeding pattern in rodents154,155,156,157, a phenomenon not observed in this study.

Conclusion

Mounting evidence suggests there may be bidirectional connections between the liver and the central clock that regulate circadian behaviour. Circadian disruption leads to liver steatosis and MASLD with liver fibrosis is associated with alterations of circadian rhythms and sleep (Fig. 3). Accordingly, restoring a rhythmic liver physiology through dietary intervention of small molecules targeting the circadian clock appears like an interesting strategy that was successful in animal models. Reciprocally, anecdotical evidence tends to show that eliminating liver fibrosis can restore circadian rhythmicity and sleep in patients with liver cirrhosis. Recent experimental evidence suggests a role of the ANS in this inter-organ communication. Accordingly, degeneration of sympathetic liver innervation observed in MASLD could play a role in both the pathophysiology of the disease and the associated alterations of circadian behaviour110. Therefore, the liver–brain connection would deserve more attention in future research.

Fig. 3: Systemic effects of altered circadian regulation in MASH.
figure 3

Disrupted circadian outputs from the diseased liver can affect metabolic and immune rhythms in other tissues. In MASH patients or animal models of fatty liver disease repercussions on rhythmic functions outside the liver have been shown for the SCN (sleep–wake cycle regulation), the arcuate nucleus (appetite regulation), metabolic tissues such as muscle (lipid and carbohydrate metabolism), and inflammatory processes in the lung and circulating immune cells.