Table 4 Summary of inter-chip free form couplers

From: Advances in waveguide to waveguide couplers for 3D integrated photonic packaging

Package

Design

IL (dB)

Pol.

1-dB Toler. (μm)

1-dB BW (nm)

L × W × H (μm)

Thru.

Process

Ref.

    

L (μm)

V (μm)

∠ (°)

     

InP to SMF

Wet etch mirror

8.6 11.3

TE TM

/

/

/

< ± 0.5 (1550)

12 × 15 × 5

Parallel

Custom

333,334

InP to SMF

FIB etch mirror

< 9

/

/

/

/

/

4 (W)

Serial

Custom

133

InP to SOI

Mirror & grating

0.71

/

± 2

± 1

/

80 (1505–1585)

/

Parallel

Custom

335,336,337

SiOx to polymer

Mirror & lens

2.6a

TE TM

± 1.5

± 5

/

100 (1500–1600)

24 (L)

Serial

New

130,338

Polymer to MMF

41° Ti-Cu mirror

1.05 1.89 1.69

/

/

/

/

/ (805) / (1310) / (1550)

6 × 6.5(W × H)

Serial

New

220,221

Polymer to SOI

2.43

± 2

30

±1. 5b

± 20 (1550)

SOI to SMF

Grating & lens

6.5

/

± 7.5

700

± 0.5

± 5 (1310)

275 (W)

Parallel

Custom

207

Polymer to polymer

TPP mirrors

0.22 0.25

TE TM

± 1.3

35

/

± 200 (850)

10 × 30

Serial

New

140

Si3N4 to Si3N4

TPP mirrors

0.49

TE

/

/

/

390 (1300–1690)

140 × 80 × 24

Serial

New

139

Si3N4 to SMF

TPP mirrors

1a

TE

± 2.2

20

2.2

300 (1340–1640)

140 × 80 × 24

Serial

New

139

Polymer to SOI

Imprint/GSL mirrors

3.6

/

± 2.5

/

/

± 80 (1550)

320 × 14 × 19

Parallel

New

58,59

Laser to SMF

DNA pyramids

0.71

/

/

/

/

/ (450)

< 10 × 10

Parallel

New

136

Polymer to SOI

mirror & grating

18.7

/

/

/

/

/ (1265)

31 × 11 × 28

Serial

New

131,339

InP to SOI

TPP mirrors

2.5

TE

± 3

± 2.25

/

± 70 (1550)

82 × 38(W × H)

Serial

New

142

SOI to SMF

TPP mirrors

0.8 3

TE TM

± 2

19

/

> 180(1460–1640) > 130(1510–1640)

135 × 70 × 27

Serial

New

141

  1. The bold values indicate that only simulation results were reported. The coupler found in ref. 207 was included because in Fig. 2b of that study, the concept is intended for a chip-to-board level coupling. Also, the longitudinal footprint from refs. 58,139,141 was reported to include the length of the inverse taper in the Si, Si3N4, and Si tapers, respectively
  2. BW bandwidth, L lateral, V vertical, ∠ angular, / not reported
  3. aEstimated based on a single mirror with μ-lens to SMF efficiency
  4. bAngular dependence of the mirror angle