Table 1 The mechanism and characteristics of different types of hydrogen sensors

From: A comprehensive review of hydrogen sensor for thermal runaway monitoring: fundamentals, recent advancements, and challenges

Classification

Mechanism

Advantages

Drawbacks

Chemiresistive

Based on changes of electrical signals (resistances or conductances) when H2 molecules interact with the sensing materials.

High sensitivity;

Acceptable stability;

Ease of integration37,49;

Low-cost fabrication.

Poor selectivity;

Many sensors need high operating temperatures459.

Electrochemical

Based on changes in charge transfer or electrical properties due to chemical reactions between H2 and the sensor electrode, where H2 is oxidized at the anode and O2 is reduced at the cathode.

Low power consumption;

Good selectivity460;

High sensitivity461,462.

Easy corrosion and difficult packaging for liquid electrolyte;

Susceptible to ambient conditions (oxygen and humidity levels)45;

High fabrication costs.

Thermal conductive

Detecting changes in the thermal conductivity of a gas mixture caused by the presence of H2.

Fast response;

Good stability463,464;

Low cost.

Low sensitivity48;

Susceptible to variations in flow rate and temperature465.

Optical

Relying on changes in light intensity upon exposure to H2.

Improved safety52;

Anti-electromagnetic interference;

High selectivity46.

High cost;

Difficult integration into battery production process16.

Catalytic

Measuring the temperature increase generated by flameless combustion of H2 on a catalytic surface for the detection of H2

Low-cost;

Fast response.

Poor selectivity47;

High power consumption;

Degradation of catalyst466.