Table 2 Summary of sensing properties of metal-based H2 sensors

From: A comprehensive review of hydrogen sensor for thermal runaway monitoring: fundamentals, recent advancements, and challenges

Material

T (°C)

detection range (ppm)

Tested concentration (ppm)

Response

tres /trec (s)

Tested LOD (ppm)

Ref.

quasi-single-crystalline Pd NWs

RT

100–10,000

10,000

8%a

9.3//13

100

84

Pd NSs

RT

5–10,000

10,000

0.4%a

50/60

5

467

Pd NPs

RT

2.5–30,000

30,000

~4%a

12/19

2.5

83

half-pipe Pd NTs

RT

8000–18,000

18,000

2.1%a

12/18

314

468

Pt NWs

RT

0.01–1,000,000

1000

14%a

NG/NG

0.01

469

Pd NWs

RT

1000–39,000

30,000

~41.9%a

~85.7/~296

1000

470

Pd NWs

65

1000–100,000

40,000

~5.8%a

0.6/<2

1000

119

Pd NWs on Al2O3

RT

0.1–4%

30,000

~30%a

56/NG

1000

118

suspended Pd NWs

RT

4000–20,000

20,000

4.8%a

~350/~70

4000

471

Pd hollow shells (450/10)

RT

250–25,000

10,000

60%a

16/NG

250

87

Pd NPs cracks on PU

RT

5–100,000

40,000

~27%a

32.3/~38

5

97

Pd/Cr nanogap

RT

10–40,000

10,000

50%a

3/4.5

10

99

Pd nanogap

RT

15,000–40,000

15,000

On/off manner

22/NG

15,000

101

Pd0.6Au0.4 nanogap (15 nm)

RT

5–100,000

10,000

~8.1%a

11.54/9.83

5

100

Pd nanogap contains Au/Cr buffer

40

20–60,000

40,000

~55%a

60–170/30–240

20

103

PdAu Sensor

RT

3000–30,000

30,000

NG

204/198

3000

48

Pd@Pt@Yarn

RT

1–40,000

40,000

9.54%a

12/48

1

472

Au@Pd (17/4)

RT

1000–1,000,000

10,000

>225%a

NG/NG

1000

473

Pd-Sn Alloy NTs

RT

0.5–30,000

20,000

5.2%a

20.2/17.9

0.5

111

Pd-Ni+organosillica membranes

70°C

1–400

200

121%a

107/NG

1

474

Ag-Pd/Cr

200

800–40,000

40,000

2.13%a

80/170

800

475

PdMoY nanosheets

RT

1–1,000,000

10,000

18.7%a

73/40

1

104

Pd/Ni film

75

800–20,000

20,000

3.17%a

7/6

800

476

PdNi film

RT

2–10,000

10,000

~0.7%a

~315/~100

2

113

Pd63Co37 NWs

RT

1000–30,000

1000

~5-6%a

85/200

1000

477

PdNi film

40

2–40,000

40,000

~3.3%a

0.3/~

2

120

PdNi film

75

5–40,000

40,000

~2.3%a

0.4/~

5

121

  1. aRefers S = ΔR/R0 or ΔR/Rg