Table 2 Performance of Image and Signal Based Models on the external validation set PTB-XL.

From: Automated multilabel diagnosis on electrocardiographic images and signals

Model

Label

Accuracy

PPV

NPV

Specificity

Sensitivity

AUROC

F1

AUPRC

Image

Male

0.810

0.784

0.845

0.738

0.876

0.899 (0.895–0.903)

0.827

0.904

1dAVb

0.960

0.457

0.984

0.974

0.573

0.946 (0.940–0.953)

0.508

0.457

RBBB

0.989

0.712

0.998

0.990

0.939

0.996 (0.995–0.997)

0.81

0.793

LBBB

0.993

0.823

0.998

0.995

0.898

0.997 (0.995–0.998)

0.859

0.902

SB

0.980

0.673

0.989

0.991

0.641

0.954 (0.945–0.963)

0.656

0.641

AF

0.986

0.898

0.992

0.992

0.898

0.993 (0.990–0.995)

0.898

0.934

ST

0.984

0.759

0.994

0.990

0.838

0.991 (0.989–0.993)

0.796

0.809

Weighted mean

0.982

0.743

0.992

0.989

0.805

0.981 (0.977–0.984)

0.770

0.776

Signal

Male

0.651

0.615

0.759

0.398

0.883

0.740 (0.733–0.746)

0.725

0.748

1dAVb

0.919

0.190

0.976

0.939

0.377

0.862 (0.852–0.872)

0.253

0.177

RBBB

0.985

0.660

0.996

0.989

0.847

0.986 (0.981–0.992)

0.742

0.729

LBBB

0.991

0.819

0.996

0.996

0.824

0.995 (0.993–0.997)

0.821

0.87

SB

0.980

0.659

0.990

0.989

0.680

0.955 (0.947–0.963)

0.669

0.642

AF

0.957

0.676

0.981

0.974

0.742

0.972 (0.969–0.975)

0.707

0.729

ST

0.982

0.745

0.991

0.990

0.779

0.987 (0.983–0.990)

0.762

0.794

Weighted mean

0.965

0.619

0.986

0.977

0.701

0.958 (0.953–0.963)

0.653

0.653

  1. 1dAVB 1st degree AV block, AF atrial fibrillation, AUPRC area under precision recall curve, AUROC area under receiver operator characteristic curve, LBBB left bundle branch block, NPV negative predictive value. PPV positive predictive value, RBBB right bundle branch block, SB sinus bradycardia, ST sinus tachycardia.