Table 4 Presumptive loss of function variants in known disease-related genes that are not disease-causing†

From: Diagnostic implications of pitfalls in causal variant identification based on 4577 molecularly characterized families

Gene

Variant

Zygosity

Disease name

Phenotype-specific OMIM ID

Reason to question pathogenicity

Proposed mechanism for non-pathogenicity

COL8A2

NM_005202.4:c.1815C>A;p.(Tyr605*)

Homozygous

Corneal dystrophy, Fuchs endothelial, 1

136800

Updated high MAF

Pathogenicity is due to GOF rather than LOF59

DENND5A

NM_015213.4:c.3387+3G > T;r.3305_3387del;p.(Lys1102Thrfs*27)

Homozygous

Developmental and epileptic encephalopathy 49

617281

Homozygous in an unaffected sibling

?Resilience

RPGR

NM_000328.3:c.1905+1 G > A

Hemizygous

Cone-rod dystrophy, X-linked, 1

304020

Homozygous in healthy individuals

The variant is a missense variant in the canonical transcript while +1 in all others

LIPN

NM_001102469.2:c.302delG;p.(Gly101Glufs*7)

Homozygous

Ichthyosis, congenital, autosomal recessive 8

613943

Homozygous in an unaffected sibling

Gene-disease assertion in OMIM is based on one family

IQSEC1

NM_001134382.3:c.2978del;p.(Pro993Hisfs*127)

Homozygous

Intellectual developmental disorder with short stature and behavioral abnormalities

618687

Homozygous in healthy individuals

The deleted bp is the last bp in the exon-intron boundary and the intron is only one base pair long

NPHP4

NM_015102.5:c.2818-2 T > A

Homozygous

Nephronophthisis 4

606966

Updated high MAF

Previous study has shown that the aberrant transcripts do not cause frameshift truncation28

GNAT1

NM_144499.3:c.858 C > G;p.(Tyr286*)

Homozygous

Night blindness, congenital stationery, type 1 G

616389

Homozygous in an unaffected father

Truncates ~20% of the protein where no deleterious variants are reported

OFD1

NM_003611.3:c.2600-1 G > C

Hemizygous

Orofaciodigital syndrome I

311200

Hemizygous in an unaffected father

The variant is not a LOF variant (does not cause a frameshift truncation)

EVC

NM_001306090.2:c.2731 C > T,p.(Arg911*)

Homozygous

Ellis-van Creveld syndrome

225500

Updated high MAF

Truncates ~9% of the protein

GUCA1A

NM_001384910.1:c.235delC,p.(Ala79Glyfs*23)

Homozygous

Cone dystrophy-3

602093

Homozygous in healthy individuals

Pathogenicity is due to GOF rather than LOF60

MKS1

Exon 1 loss at the RNA level

Homozygous

Bardet-Biedl syndrome 13

615990

Alternative etiology was identified

Technical error

LETM1

NM_012318.3:c.1678A>T;p.(Lys560*)

Homozygous

Neurodegeneration, childhood-onset, with multisystem involvement due to mitochondrial dysfunction

620089

Homozygous in an unaffected sibling

?Resilience

LZTFL1

NM_001276379.1:c.3 G > A;p.?

Homozygous

Bardet-Biedl syndrome 17

615994

Updated high MAF

Startloss in some transcript and UTR variant in others. GTEX database reported that the shorter transcripts (where the variant is located in the UTR regions) are the ones abundantly expressed in most tissues especially the brain and reproductive organs

PDE11A

NM_016953.3:c.1633C>T;p.(Arg545*)

Homozygous

Pigmented nodular adrenocortical disease, primary, 2

610475

Homozygous in an unaffected sibling

Pathogenicity is due to GOF rather than LOF61

RP1L1

NM_178857.6:c.5959 C > T;p.(Gln1987*)

Homozygous

Retinitis pigmentosa 88

618826

Updated high MAF

Truncates a small part of the C-terminus where no deleterious variants are reported

CDKL5

NM_003159.2:c.2854 C > T;p.(Arg952*)

Heterozygous

Developmental and epileptic encephalopathy 2

300672

Updated high MAF

Truncates 7.7% of the protein

  1. †Variants involved in complex compound heterozygosity are listed in Table 3.