Table 1 Comparison of thin-film FETs constructed with same material (BP) or similar preparation methods (wet transfer)

From: A clean transfer approach to prepare centimetre-scale black phosphorus crystalline multilayers on silicon substrates for field-effect transistors

Material

Preparation method

Substrate

Thickness (nm)

Dimensions (µm)

On/off ratio

Field-effect mobility (cm2 V−1 s−1)

Ref.

BP

PLD + wet transfer

SiO2/Si

~5

104

3.6 × 103

295

This work

BP

PLD

Mica

5

104

~5 × 103

213

23

BP

CVD

SiO2/Si

290

103

~105

6500

22

BP

Mechanical exfoliation

SiO2/Si

~10

5

~104

~100

32

BP

Liquid exfoliation

SiO2/Si

12

0.8

~103

0.58

33

MoS2

CVD + wet transfer

SiO2/Si

0.91

~20

106–107

35

34

MoS2

CVD + wet transfer

SiO2/Si

0.7

~40

108–109

7.6

35

MoS2

CVD + wet transfer

SiO2/Si

10

103

105

4.5

36