Table 3 Practitioner characteristics
Authorref. | Country | Sample size | Occupation | COPD expertise/engagement | Gender | Ethnicity | Mean age (years) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fotokain et al.60 | Iran | 5 | Nurses = 3 | NR | NR | NR | NR |
Physiotherapist = 1 | |||||||
Pulmonologist = 1 | |||||||
Hillebregt et al.57 | The Netherlands | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | NR |
Hyde et al.56 | Ireland | 5 | Practice nurse = 3 | Delivered usual care to patient participants with COPD | Female: 3 | NR | NR |
General practitioner = 2 | Mean years in post: 13 | Male: 2 | |||||
Johnston et al.49 | Australia | 16 | Hospital-based medical practitioners = 9 | “Actively involved” in the care of COPD patients in primary and tertiary care settings | NR | NR | NR |
General practitioner = 7 | |||||||
Johnston et al.48 | Australia | 12 | General practitioner = 12 | “Actively involved” in the care of COPD patients in a tertiary care setting | Female: 10Male: 2 | NR | NR |
Kayyali et al.54 | UK | 23 | General practitioner = 1 | NR | NR | NR | NR |
Specialist doctors = 13 | |||||||
Nurses = 6 | |||||||
Physiotherapists = 3 | |||||||
Ogunbayo et al.22 | UK | 20 | General practitioner = 2 | Multidisciplinary healthcare teams involved in COPD care | Female: 15 Male: 5 | Caucasian: 20 | 45 |
Nurses | |||||||
Practice nurse = 2 | |||||||
Respiratory nurse = 1 | |||||||
Pharmacy | |||||||
Practice pharmacist = 1 | |||||||
Community pharmacist = 1 | |||||||
Respiratory | |||||||
Specialist respiratory/COPD practitioners = 6 | |||||||
Consultant respiratory physician = 1 | |||||||
Allied health professionals | |||||||
Physiologist = 1 | |||||||
Physiotherapist = 1 | |||||||
Occupational therapist = 1 | |||||||
Other | |||||||
Community matron = 2 | |||||||
Exercise instructor = 1 | |||||||
Summers et al.53 | UK | 17 | Respiratory physiotherapists = 17 | With ⩾12 months current or previous experience of working with patients with COPD in a non-acute setting | Female: 13Male: 4 | Caucasian: 14Black African: 1White S African: 2 | NR |
Verbrugge et al.50 | The Netherlands | 14 | Respiratory nurses = 14 | Nurse-led clinics with a population of COPD patients in general hospitals, homecare organisations, and a university hospital | Female: 14Male: 0 | NR | 39 |
Mean years of experience: 5 | |||||||
Wong et al.55 | Malaysia | 18 | General practitioner = 18 | Manage COPD patients within a hospital chest clinic or primary care | Female: 13Male: 5 | Malay: 7Indian: 5Chinese: 4Other Asian: 2 | NR |
Young et al.52 | UK | 14 | Allied health professionalPhysiotherapists = 3Occupational therapist = 1 | Currently or recently (last 12 months) working with COPD patientsPrimary, community, and secondary care | Female: 14Male: 0 | Caucasian: 13African Caribbean: 1 | NR |
Nurse (Respiratory) | |||||||
Respiratory research nurse = 3 | |||||||
Community respiratory nurses = 2 | |||||||
Respiratory nurse = 1 | |||||||
Nurse (other) | |||||||
Practice nurse = 3 | |||||||
Nurse practitioner = 1 | |||||||
Zakrisson and Hagglund51 | Sweden | 12 | Asthma/COPD nurses = 12 | Specialist / University education in asthma/COPD: 8No specialist education: 2 | NR | NR | NR |
Median years of experience in asthma/COPD clinics: 7 | |||||||
Primary care setting | |||||||
Total | 166 | Respiratory = 58 | Female: 82 | Caucasian: 47 | NA | ||
General practitioner = 42 | Male: 18 | Asian: 18 | |||||
Nurse = 18Other practitioner = 25Allied health professional = 11Pharmacists = 2NR = 10 | NR: 43 | White S African: 2 African Caribbean: 1Black African: 1NR: 74 |